ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Roger McNamee - Tech investor
Ten years from now we will interact with the internet in completely different ways. Roger McNamee identifies six changes that are already transforming the ways we consume and create content.

Why you should listen

Roger McNamee has been an investor in science and tech for close to 30 years. His 2004 book -- The New Normal: Opportunities in a Time of Great Risk -- offers business strategies based on the economic and technological trends that are defining this era. He also plays guitar and bass in the band Moonalice, a band known for its clever use of social media.

More profile about the speaker
Roger McNamee | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxSantaCruz

Roger McNamee: 6 ways to save the internet

Filmed:
340,035 views

The next big shift is now, and it's not what you think: Facebook is the new Windows; Google must be sacrificed. Tech investor Roger McNamee presents 6 bold ways to prepare for the next internet.
- Tech investor
Ten years from now we will interact with the internet in completely different ways. Roger McNamee identifies six changes that are already transforming the ways we consume and create content. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:04
Have you ever been in the position
of watching Silicon Valley take off
0
842
4854
00:09
and wish that you had known
what was about to happen?
1
5720
4333
00:14
(Laughter)
2
10077
2049
00:17
So, I'm here to talk about
what I think is going to be
3
13929
2999
00:20
the most intense disruption
of the technology world
4
16952
5034
00:26
that's occurred in the last 15 years.
5
22010
1948
00:28
And I believe the end product of it
will be entirely about engagement.
6
24680
5367
00:34
In fact, I think it is possibly
a transformational change
7
30476
4133
00:38
in the way we're going
to think about engagement.
8
34633
2774
00:41
So what would you do if you knew today
9
37431
5285
00:47
that there was going to be
a major technology cycle
10
43978
2398
00:50
beginning in the next couple years,
11
46400
1783
00:52
and that you could participate in it?
12
48207
1859
00:54
What would you do?
13
50411
2061
00:56
(Audience) Jump in!
14
52789
1166
00:57
So, this is the situation
in which I find myself:
15
53979
3450
01:01
I'm a professional investor
about half the day,
16
57969
3044
01:06
the daylight half.
17
62052
1508
01:07
I was paying close attention earlier,
18
63584
1771
01:09
and I now know I need to have
10 hours sleep at night,
19
65379
2660
01:12
which is tricky, because last
night the show ended
20
68063
2624
01:14
about 12:30, and so I was, I got --
21
70711
3007
01:17
and that was in Santa Rosa,
so I got home a little late.
22
73742
2904
01:21
I want you to understand,
I've been studying the technology world,
23
77175
3144
01:24
and things have already begun to change.
24
80343
2536
01:26
But they're changing in ways
25
82903
1450
01:28
that I see literally no
commentator referring to today.
26
84377
2926
01:32
There are six things going on
that I'm going to focus on.
27
88091
2707
01:34
I want you to understand,
each one of these is a hypothesis;
28
90822
2869
01:37
it is subject to revision.
29
93715
1853
01:39
It may even be subject to elimination.
30
95592
2361
01:41
But I want you to understand
31
97977
1351
01:43
I've been working with this group
of hypotheses now for about 10 months,
32
99352
3417
01:46
and what's really interesting
is that I've been exposing them
33
102793
3160
01:49
to a lot of people in the industry,
34
105977
1916
01:51
and people have been finding it
very hard to debunk them.
35
107917
2715
01:54
So I'm going to share them with you today,
36
110656
2022
01:56
because I think collectively, we have
a chance of figuring this out.
37
112702
3222
01:59
The first thing -- and I think
this is fairly obvious --
38
115948
2709
02:02
is: Windows is dying.
39
118681
1898
02:04
And --
40
120603
1165
02:05
(Applause)
41
121792
1909
02:08
I mean no disrespect to Microsoft,
42
124326
1824
02:10
because I think, in fact, Microsoft
as a company has many things it can do
43
126174
3725
02:13
to maintain growth,
44
129923
1343
02:15
but desktops would not be one of them.
45
131290
2716
02:18
And the key indicator here,
and the only one you need to know
46
134030
3162
02:21
to understand what's going on here,
47
137216
1875
02:24
is that smartphones have
basically taken Windows
48
140567
4562
02:29
from 96% of internet-connected
devices 3 or 4 years ago,
49
145153
3847
02:34
to under 50% now.
50
150038
1510
02:36
And it is falling precipitously;
51
152097
1640
02:37
they'll be under 30 percent,
probably about a year and a half from now.
52
153761
3673
02:42
Microsoft has lots of things it can do.
53
158468
1974
02:44
It can retreat to Exchange
and crank the price there.
54
160466
2830
02:47
But the reason this is so significant
55
163320
2421
02:49
is that Windows and Enterprise
software, which is related to it --
56
165765
3910
02:53
think SAP and people like that --
57
169699
2162
02:55
those businesses account for hundreds
of billions of dollars in revenue.
58
171885
4521
03:00
And I'm suggesting we're going to have
a jump ball for that revenue.
59
176430
3284
03:03
And in a world where the US economy
is not growing that rapidly,
60
179738
3728
03:08
having somebody go away is the simplest
way to create room for new industries.
61
184532
5399
03:13
And this is where the revenues
are going to come from.
62
189955
2593
03:16
But guess what? Like a Ginsu
knife commercial, there's more!
63
192572
3821
03:20
(Laughter)
64
196417
1279
03:21
It turns out Microsoft
is not the only company
65
197720
3384
03:25
whose body is lying
across the railroad tracks today.
66
201128
3015
03:29
Another one is Google.
67
205849
1641
03:32
Now, you may not have focused on this,
68
208590
2464
03:35
but index search accounted for
90% of all search volume
69
211078
4300
03:39
about 4 years ago.
70
215402
1197
03:42
But an interesting thing happened.
71
218234
1650
03:43
Google got to be so successful
that the index became full of garbage.
72
219908
5998
03:49
In fact, the entire Web
has become full of garbage.
73
225930
3589
03:54
If you think about it, the Web has become
almost a digital Detroit.
74
230106
3485
03:57
(Laughter)
75
233615
1067
03:58
If you look hard enough,
76
234706
1408
04:00
you can find really
compelling things there.
77
236138
2804
04:04
But if you aren't really careful,
you can get mugged.
78
240100
3505
04:07
(Laughter)
79
243629
1636
04:09
And it is no shock
80
245289
1431
04:10
that each one of us
and everyone else out there
81
246744
2655
04:13
have looked for other ways to find
the things we want to find.
82
249423
3597
04:17
We started with Wikipedia,
83
253044
1811
04:18
but then Facebook came along
for matters of taste and money;
84
254879
3531
04:22
Twitter came along for real-time news;
85
258434
1938
04:24
LinkedIn, for professional things;
86
260396
1972
04:26
Match.com, for less professional things;
87
262392
2613
04:29
TripAdvisor for travel,
Yelp for restaurants,
88
265029
2819
04:31
Realtor.com for finding a home,
Dictionary.com for words,
89
267872
4146
04:36
Wordnik for the whole language.
90
272042
2106
04:38
So the thing has really changed.
91
274172
2148
04:40
And here's what's interesting:
92
276344
1453
04:41
like Microsoft, Google has
plenty of ways to respond
93
277821
3033
04:44
in terms of growing its business.
94
280878
1627
04:46
But what it cannot do
is recover its position
95
282529
3582
04:50
as the dominant player on the internet.
96
286135
1984
04:52
It is my belief that when
Google came along in 1998,
97
288746
4002
04:56
the internet was an open-source,
98
292772
2731
04:59
long-tail world with no leader.
99
295527
2954
05:02
And Google stepped into this void,
provided leadership
100
298505
2994
05:05
and implemented a strategy
101
301523
1461
05:07
that systematically commoditized
all forms of content.
102
303008
4096
05:11
And the simplest way to look at it
is to look at a Google results page:
103
307628
3424
05:15
the only logo on that page is Google's;
104
311076
3385
05:18
everything else is in the same font.
105
314485
1886
05:21
That form of commoditization
has been tremendous for Google
106
317270
3229
05:24
and horrible for almost everyone else.
107
320523
2284
05:26
And I believe, to a first
order, it is over --
108
322831
3301
05:30
not because index search is going away,
but because, like word processing,
109
326156
4437
05:34
it's gone from the most important
application we all had,
110
330617
2723
05:37
to just another thing we do.
111
333364
1988
05:39
And you see this in mobile in particular.
112
335831
2345
05:42
Because in mobile, people have found
other ways to find what they want.
113
338200
4758
05:46
Index search is too disruptive
on a cell phone,
114
342982
3005
05:50
so the rate of index search
is a small fraction on cell phones
115
346011
3956
05:53
to what it is on desktops.
116
349991
1520
05:55
And that is the leading indicator
that Google's recovery, if you will,
117
351535
4731
06:00
will be in something other than search.
118
356290
2347
06:03
The third hypothesis I have
is no longer controversial,
119
359319
4976
06:08
but it's important
to understand what happened.
120
364319
2217
06:10
If the left-hand side of this equation
is the open-source World Wide Web,
121
366560
3735
06:14
with its belief in the long tail,
122
370319
1699
06:16
its belief in an absence of regulation,
123
372042
2443
06:18
of an absence of security and control,
124
374509
2348
06:20
it's really a frontier.
125
376881
2078
06:22
Apple came along with a different vision.
126
378983
2134
06:25
They said, "We think the Web is dead.
127
381141
2084
06:27
We're going to go on the internet,
128
383249
1683
06:28
because that's the big data store,
129
384956
1651
06:30
and we're going to provide you
with branded, thoughtful, value-added,
130
386631
5326
06:35
copyright-protected content."
131
391981
2840
06:39
And people have overwhelmingly chosen that
132
395502
3226
06:42
over Google's vision.
133
398752
1371
06:44
Over the last three years,
134
400147
1481
06:45
Apple's gone from being
an also-ran in computers
135
401652
4040
06:49
to this year they will ship approximately
100 million internet-enabled devices.
136
405716
6110
06:56
One hundred million.
137
412693
1577
06:58
They'll probably be just short of that.
138
414294
1928
07:01
The point here is, it's Apple's world.
139
417054
2464
07:05
We're lucky to be part of it,
140
421849
1397
07:07
because Steve is quite intolerant
about who he lets in.
141
423270
2721
07:10
(Laughter)
142
426015
1013
07:11
But think about this:
imagine Georgia in the Civil War. OK?
143
427052
4058
07:15
Apple is Sherman,
144
431134
1794
07:16
World Wide Web is Joe Johnston.
145
432952
1528
07:18
And the point is, they've lost.
146
434504
1917
07:20
So the Web is looking at this and going,
147
436889
1942
07:22
"My God, we've got to come back."
148
438855
1595
07:24
And the cost in order to do this is
they have to sacrifice Google.
149
440474
4141
07:29
So Google has pushed
the pendulum of technology
150
445253
2855
07:32
to the absolute limit of commoditization,
151
448132
2520
07:35
to the point where people
who spent their whole lives
152
451310
2775
07:38
developing really valuable,
compelling entertainment
153
454109
3497
07:41
and really valuable, compelling journalism
154
457630
2034
07:43
and really valuable, compelling novels,
155
459688
1873
07:45
can't make money doing it anymore.
156
461585
2046
07:47
So the Web said, "OK,
if Google's over here, and Apple's here,
157
463655
4736
07:52
HTML 5, the next generation, is going
to be on the other side of Apple."
158
468415
3647
07:56
So the new battle, instead of being
commoditization versus the App Store,
159
472086
3618
07:59
is going to be between the App Store
and highly differentiated content.
160
475728
4357
08:04
If you don't know what HTML 5 is,
let me help you understand.
161
480109
3603
08:07
It is a programming language.
162
483736
1653
08:09
But it's a profound one.
163
485950
2075
08:12
Because for the first time,
164
488049
1896
08:13
you're going to be able
to construct a web page
165
489969
2852
08:16
where the entire thing can have
embedded interactivity,
166
492845
3690
08:20
can have video, audio,
whatever it is that you want.
167
496559
3297
08:23
But no more Flash boxes.
168
499880
1960
08:26
And it's a huge, huge change,
169
502486
1659
08:28
because it essentially
opens up a new canvas.
170
504169
2663
08:30
And it doesn't just open it
up for The New York Times,
171
506856
3017
08:33
it opens it up for everybody on WordPress,
172
509897
2444
08:36
it opens it up for every band ...
173
512365
1798
08:38
Because suddenly, the ability to produce
a differentiated, highly compelling,
174
514855
4733
08:43
value-added -- maybe
even monetizable -- product
175
519612
3334
08:46
will be there.
176
522970
1366
08:48
And what's really interesting
is, thanks to Apple,
177
524360
3268
08:51
there's nothing that commoditizers
can do about you.
178
527652
2975
08:55
Apple may try to stop us,
but I don't think they will.
179
531609
3046
08:58
I think they're smarter than that.
180
534679
1838
09:00
So the key point is, I don't know
where we're going to stop
181
536903
2894
09:03
as the pendulum swings back.
182
539821
1698
09:05
But I think the days
of hypercommoditization are behind us.
183
541543
3549
09:09
And we can all play in this.
184
545517
1484
09:11
In a moment I'm going to tell you
how I'm doing it personally.
185
547025
3306
09:14
Tablets.
186
550355
1167
09:16
This is the other side
of why Windows is dead.
187
552187
2655
09:19
If any of you does not own an iPad --
188
555680
2304
09:22
Look, I don't own any Apple stock,
so I have no axe in this,
189
558008
3441
09:25
but seriously, if you don't own an iPad,
you cannot possibly understand
190
561473
4622
09:30
the most important things going on now.
191
566119
1952
09:32
(Laughter)
192
568095
1056
09:33
No, I'm really serious about this.
193
569175
1655
09:34
And I think the most important point
is that the other players on this thing,
194
570854
3978
09:38
at the moment,
195
574856
1534
09:40
have made no impact.
196
576414
1261
09:42
And keep in mind,
197
578166
1448
09:43
it was our investment that built
Palm's webOS that HP's shipping
198
579638
4639
09:48
soon, eventually, someday.
199
584301
1724
09:50
(Laughter)
200
586049
1750
09:52
I think it's highly probable
Apple wins this thing
201
588119
2498
09:54
with market share closer
to what they have on the iPod
202
590641
3268
09:57
than to what they have on the iPhone.
203
593933
1960
10:00
That would be 70 or 80%.
204
596930
1894
10:02
If that's right, Apple's going to be
50 to 100 billion dollars bigger
205
598848
3640
10:06
in a few years
206
602512
1157
10:07
than they are today.
207
603693
1151
10:09
And I literally don't see anybody
else even challenging them.
208
605318
3062
10:13
It's really important to understand
209
609013
1696
10:14
that Apple's cost structure is so
favorable relative to everybody else,
210
610733
3370
10:18
it's almost impossible to imagine
any of the cell phone guys,
211
614127
2893
10:21
particularly Android guys, catching up.
212
617044
1932
10:23
Because Apple's gross margins
exceed the retail price
213
619000
4079
10:27
of almost every Android phone.
214
623103
1733
10:30
Here is the one that I want
to leave you with
215
626561
2476
10:33
as an investment idea, first and foremost.
216
629061
2139
10:35
The mania on Wall Street is about social.
217
631224
2258
10:37
Social is a sideshow.
218
633506
3415
10:40
And I say this as somebody whose fund
has most of its money in Facebook.
219
636945
3876
10:45
It is a one-off.
220
641671
1664
10:47
This is not ...
221
643359
1515
10:49
To borrow a phrase from Star Wars:
222
645731
2673
10:52
this is not the mania
you are looking for.
223
648428
2471
10:55
The one we're talking about will be
so much bigger than this.
224
651969
3358
10:59
Facebook has won.
225
655351
1401
11:00
It is the new Windows. OK?
226
656776
2631
11:03
A few other guys -- Twitter,
Yelp, Skype, LinkedIn --
227
659431
4364
11:07
are building successful platforms
228
663819
3636
11:11
that are much smaller
than what Facebook has.
229
667479
3216
11:15
And they'll be successful.
230
671503
1255
11:16
But everybody else coming along is going
to have to follow the Zynga model.
231
672782
3588
11:20
They're going to have to make themselves
subordinate to the platform of Facebook.
232
676394
4056
11:24
And Zynga's inability to build
anything successful off of Facebook,
233
680474
3521
11:28
I think, is the key indicator
of why this platform is so powerful.
234
684019
4764
11:32
So if you do a start-up today
in the social world,
235
688807
2359
11:35
build it on top of Facebook.
236
691190
1337
11:36
It's the only piece of advice
I can give you.
237
692551
2113
11:38
But the most important piece
of advice is: forget social.
238
694688
2685
11:41
Social is now a feature,
it's not a platform.
239
697397
2169
11:43
So embed social,
240
699590
1324
11:44
the same way that Catherine said,
"Embed gamification into everything."
241
700938
3535
11:49
It's all about engagement.
242
705138
1548
11:52
The future is going to be different.
243
708478
3384
11:56
And the core question is:
244
712640
1381
11:58
What are we all going to do about it?
245
714045
1977
12:00
What I do is very simple:
I believe in full-contact investing.
246
716459
3776
12:04
So I looked at HTML 5
about a year ago, and I said,
247
720757
3393
12:08
"This thing could be really important.
How do I find out?"
248
724174
2839
12:11
So my band, Moonalice,
249
727037
1580
12:12
which, a couple years ago,
did an album with T Bone Burnett,
250
728641
2906
12:15
that we thought was going to be
a huge hit and blah, blah, blah ...
251
731571
3431
12:19
Well, we learned that nobody cared about
hippie music done by old folks, so --
252
735026
4519
12:23
(Laughter)
253
739569
1063
12:24
So we put it all onto the net,
went on Facebook and Twitter.
254
740656
2901
12:27
We started doing things
called "Twittercasts,"
255
743581
2191
12:29
the first live concerts
and then prerecorded concerts,
256
745796
2636
12:32
distributed over Twitter.
257
748456
1211
12:33
Then we started using live stream,
the same thing we're using here today,
258
749691
3443
12:37
to do internet-based
live video of our shows.
259
753158
2104
12:39
And then recently, we bought
a satellite network.
260
755286
2861
12:42
Why? 'Cause it cost less than three months
of what our manager used to cost.
261
758171
4254
12:46
(Laughter)
262
762449
1023
12:47
And right now, we broadcast
every one of our shows --
263
763496
3081
12:50
other than the U2 show --
264
766601
1357
12:51
live, in HTML 5,
265
767982
2660
12:54
via satellite,
266
770666
1554
12:56
in a system we totally control.
267
772244
2104
12:59
We have an app that's about to ship
within the next month.
268
775640
4534
13:04
It's -- "app" is the wrong term;
our website is being upgraded to HTML 5.
269
780198
3755
13:07
And in it, you will be able,
from any phone, anywhere,
270
783977
3622
13:11
to play any song we've ever played live
271
787623
2503
13:14
and view any live video that we have,
272
790150
1787
13:15
which is 150, 200 shows.
273
791961
1939
13:18
Now, it cost practically
nothing to do this.
274
794935
3452
13:22
And we're this teeny-weeny little band.
275
798768
2278
13:26
Now, I know more about technology
than most people,
276
802073
2798
13:28
but that's just because I know
more than most people who are 55.
277
804895
3616
13:32
But people who are 18 to 20,
who live in this world,
278
808535
3224
13:35
are going to be able
to use these platforms
279
811783
2031
13:37
in music and everywhere else
280
813838
1567
13:39
in a fundamentally different way.
281
815429
1590
13:42
I think creativity is coming back.
282
818319
1678
13:44
Moonalice is something
that's built around that.
283
820021
2287
13:46
We have poster artists
for every single show.
284
822332
2411
13:49
We have photographers who work
every show, we have painters.
285
825187
3253
13:52
And the notion is, I believe
that creativity has been stifled,
286
828464
4182
13:56
not so much by technology,
287
832670
1867
13:58
but by the general deterioration
of American culture --
288
834561
5164
14:03
you know, people's unwillingness
to be educated,
289
839749
2350
14:06
this notion that we have to fall back
on ritual and beliefs, instead of facts.
290
842123
5605
14:12
But I think technology is finally
going to do us a favor.
291
848338
3031
14:16
I think it's finally going to give us
the tools to make us independent.
292
852346
4567
14:20
And there's little glimmers, right?
293
856937
1708
14:22
We see the Arab Spring
294
858669
1717
14:24
and the impact that Twitter
and Facebook had.
295
860410
2358
14:28
Pretty exciting.
296
864164
1648
14:29
But imagine a world
297
865836
1732
14:32
in which everything is an app.
298
868505
4130
14:36
In HTML 5, digital Detroit
gets replaced by this thing
299
872659
3878
14:40
where every tweet is an app,
300
876561
2397
14:42
every advertisement
is an instance of a store.
301
878982
3203
14:46
Think about what that means.
302
882801
1694
14:48
So instead of seeing an Amazon display ad,
303
884519
2084
14:50
you see the store, say,
on the New York Times Book Review.
304
886627
3608
14:54
You can both create demand
and satisfy it in the same place.
305
890944
4080
14:59
Why?
306
895395
1276
15:00
Because that's better for everybody.
307
896695
1730
15:02
Saves time, increases engagement,
308
898449
2962
15:05
because it keeps you on the page.
309
901435
1998
15:07
We're going from a web of elevators,
310
903457
3362
15:10
where you go to different places,
and you go off sites and you lose people,
311
906843
4232
15:15
to a control panel model.
312
911099
1579
15:17
And guess who's going to make it?
313
913402
1710
15:19
You are.
314
915841
1247
15:21
Thank you very much.
315
917112
1182
15:22
(Applause)
316
918318
2337

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Roger McNamee - Tech investor
Ten years from now we will interact with the internet in completely different ways. Roger McNamee identifies six changes that are already transforming the ways we consume and create content.

Why you should listen

Roger McNamee has been an investor in science and tech for close to 30 years. His 2004 book -- The New Normal: Opportunities in a Time of Great Risk -- offers business strategies based on the economic and technological trends that are defining this era. He also plays guitar and bass in the band Moonalice, a band known for its clever use of social media.

More profile about the speaker
Roger McNamee | Speaker | TED.com