ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tabetha Boyajian - Astronomer
Tabetha Boyajian is best known for her research on KIC 8462852, a puzzling celestial body that has inspired otherwise sober scientists to brainstorm outlandish hypotheses.

Why you should listen
Planet hunter Tabetha Boyajian studies KIC 8462852 (dubbed "Tabby's star" after her team's research): a star exhibiting bizarre (and thus far unique) variations in brightness. These fluctuations have led scientists to postulate causes ranging from comet dust (Boyajian's most likely scenario) to alien megastructures. The latest studies of Tabby's star have proved even more baffling: KIC 8462852 has been gradually dimming over the last century, a strikingly short period of time on an astronomical scale.

Boyajian currently serves as a postdoc with the Yale Exoplanet group, whose research is assisted by the Planet Hunters -- a citizen science group that combs data from the NASA Kepler Space Mission for evidence of exoplanets and other unusual interstellar activity.
More profile about the speaker
Tabetha Boyajian | Speaker | TED.com
TED2016

Tabetha Boyajian: The most mysterious star in the universe

Filmed:
4,729,927 views

Something massive, with roughly 1,000 times the area of Earth, is blocking the light coming from a distant star known as KIC 8462852, and nobody is quite sure what it is. As astronomer Tabetha Boyajian investigated this perplexing celestial object, a colleague suggested something unusual: Could it be an alien-built megastructure? Such an extraordinary idea would require extraordinary evidence. In this talk, Boyajian gives us a look at how scientists search for and test hypotheses when faced with the unknown.
- Astronomer
Tabetha Boyajian is best known for her research on KIC 8462852, a puzzling celestial body that has inspired otherwise sober scientists to brainstorm outlandish hypotheses. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Extraordinary claims
require extraordinary evidence,
0
760
4496
00:17
and it is my job,
my responsibility, as an astronomer
1
5280
4696
00:22
to remind people that alien hypotheses
should always be a last resort.
2
10000
6320
00:29
Now, I want to tell you
a story about that.
3
17440
2136
00:31
It involves data from a NASA mission,
4
19600
3576
00:35
ordinary people and one of the most
extraordinary stars in our galaxy.
5
23200
4960
00:41
It began in 2009 with the launch
of NASA's Kepler mission.
6
29800
3600
00:46
Kepler's main scientific objective
7
34000
2056
00:48
was to find planets
outside of our solar system.
8
36080
2976
00:51
It did this by staring
at a single field in the sky,
9
39080
3576
00:54
this one, with all the tiny boxes.
10
42680
1840
00:57
And in this one field,
11
45480
1416
00:58
it monitored the brightness
of over 150,000 stars
12
46920
4416
01:03
continuously for four years,
13
51360
2416
01:05
taking a data point every 30 minutes.
14
53800
2640
01:10
It was looking for what
astronomers call a transit.
15
58480
3016
01:13
This is when the planet's orbit
is aligned in our line of sight,
16
61520
5016
01:18
just so that the planet
crosses in front of a star.
17
66560
4136
01:22
And when this happens,
it blocks out a tiny bit of starlight,
18
70720
4376
01:27
which you can see as a dip in this curve.
19
75120
2720
01:31
And so the team at NASA
had developed very sophisticated computers
20
79600
4416
01:36
to search for transits
in all the Kepler data.
21
84040
2720
01:40
At the same time
of the first data release,
22
88160
3896
01:44
astronomers at Yale
were wondering an interesting thing:
23
92080
3120
01:48
What if computers missed something?
24
96240
3360
01:53
And so we launched the citizen
science project called Planet Hunters
25
101040
3680
01:57
to have people look at the same data.
26
105760
3200
02:01
The human brain has an amazing ability
for pattern recognition,
27
109600
3776
02:05
sometimes even better than a computer.
28
113400
2216
02:07
However, there was a lot
of skepticism around this.
29
115640
2536
02:10
My colleague, Debra Fischer,
founder of the Planet Hunters project,
30
118200
3536
02:13
said that people at the time were saying,
31
121760
1976
02:15
"You're crazy. There's no way
that a computer will miss a signal."
32
123760
3120
02:19
And so it was on, the classic
human versus machine gamble.
33
127560
4216
02:23
And if we found one planet,
we would be thrilled.
34
131800
3176
02:27
When I joined the team four years ago,
35
135000
2456
02:29
we had already found a couple.
36
137480
1440
02:32
And today, with the help
of over 300,000 science enthusiasts,
37
140360
4656
02:37
we have found dozens,
38
145040
1776
02:38
and we've also found
one of the most mysterious stars
39
146840
3256
02:42
in our galaxy.
40
150120
1200
02:45
So to understand this,
41
153040
1456
02:46
let me show you what a normal transit
in Kepler data looks like.
42
154520
3200
02:50
On this graph on the left-hand side
you have the amount of light,
43
158680
3376
02:54
and on the bottom is time.
44
162080
1856
02:55
The white line
is light just from the star,
45
163960
3056
02:59
what astronomers call a light curve.
46
167040
2376
03:01
Now, when a planet transits a star,
it blocks out a little bit of this light,
47
169440
3856
03:05
and the depth of this transit
reflects the size of the object itself.
48
173320
5456
03:10
And so, for example, let's take Jupiter.
49
178800
2616
03:13
Planets don't get
much bigger than Jupiter.
50
181440
2136
03:15
Jupiter will make a one percent drop
in a star's brightness.
51
183600
3776
03:19
Earth, on the other hand,
is 11 times smaller than Jupiter,
52
187400
4176
03:23
and the signal
is barely visible in the data.
53
191600
2816
03:26
So back to our mystery.
54
194440
1280
03:28
A few years ago, Planet Hunters were
sifting through data looking for transits,
55
196520
3880
03:33
and they spotted a mysterious signal
coming from the star KIC 8462852.
56
201200
5960
03:39
The observations in May of 2009
were the first they spotted,
57
207920
4016
03:43
and they started talking about this
in the discussion forums.
58
211960
2858
03:47
They said and object like Jupiter
59
215320
2096
03:49
would make a drop like this
in the star's light,
60
217440
2896
03:52
but they were also saying it was giant.
61
220360
3336
03:55
You see, transits normally
only last for a few hours,
62
223720
3216
03:58
and this one lasted for almost a week.
63
226960
2120
04:01
They were also saying
that it looks asymmetric,
64
229880
3536
04:05
meaning that instead of the clean,
U-shaped dip that we saw with Jupiter,
65
233440
4256
04:09
it had this strange slope
that you can see on the left side.
66
237720
3496
04:13
This seemed to indicate
67
241240
1336
04:14
that whatever was getting in the way
and blocking the starlight
68
242600
3376
04:18
was not circular like a planet.
69
246000
1920
04:21
There are few more dips that happened,
70
249240
1896
04:23
but for a couple of years,
it was pretty quiet.
71
251160
2360
04:26
And then in March of 2011, we see this.
72
254400
4160
04:31
The star's light drops
by a whole 15 percent,
73
259120
4096
04:35
and this is huge compared to a planet,
74
263240
2176
04:37
which would only make a one percent drop.
75
265440
2000
04:40
We described this feature
as both smooth and clean.
76
268480
3536
04:44
It also is asymmetric,
77
272040
2016
04:46
having a gradual dimming
that lasts almost a week,
78
274080
2656
04:48
and then it snaps right back up to normal
in just a matter of days.
79
276760
3160
04:52
And again, after this, not much happens
80
280920
4256
04:57
until February of 2013.
81
285200
3696
05:00
Things start to get really crazy.
82
288920
2616
05:03
There is a huge complex of dips
in the light curve that appear,
83
291560
4496
05:08
and they last for like a hundred days,
84
296080
2136
05:10
all the way up
into the Kepler mission's end.
85
298240
2240
05:13
These dips have variable shapes.
86
301280
1976
05:15
Some are very sharp, and some are broad,
87
303280
2216
05:17
and they also have variable durations.
88
305520
2256
05:19
Some last just for a day or two,
and some for more than a week.
89
307800
3160
05:24
And there's also up and down trends
within some of these dips,
90
312120
3336
05:27
almost like several independent events
were superimposed on top of each other.
91
315480
4680
05:32
And at this time, this star drops
in its brightness over 20 percent.
92
320920
6216
05:39
This means that whatever
is blocking its light
93
327160
2143
05:41
has an area of over 1,000 times
the area of our planet Earth.
94
329327
4440
05:46
This is truly remarkable.
95
334200
2240
05:49
And so the citizen scientists,
when they saw this,
96
337360
2376
05:51
they notified the science team
that they found something weird enough
97
339760
3696
05:55
that it might be worth following up.
98
343480
2440
05:58
And so when the science team looked at it,
99
346680
2056
06:00
we're like, "Yeah, there's probably
just something wrong with the data."
100
348760
3381
06:04
But we looked really, really, really hard,
101
352165
2531
06:06
and the data were good.
102
354720
2400
06:10
And so what was happening
had to be astrophysical,
103
358680
3096
06:13
meaning that something in space
was getting in the way
104
361800
3656
06:17
and blocking starlight.
105
365480
1400
06:20
And so at this point,
106
368240
1216
06:21
we set out to learn
everything we could about the star
107
369480
2576
06:24
to see if we could find any clues
to what was going on.
108
372080
2920
06:27
And the citizen scientists
who helped us in this discovery,
109
375720
3176
06:30
they joined along for the ride
110
378920
1536
06:32
watching science in action firsthand.
111
380480
3080
06:37
First, somebody said, you know,
what if this star was very young
112
385000
5456
06:42
and it still had the cloud of material
it was born from surrounding it.
113
390480
3600
06:47
And then somebody else said,
114
395040
1416
06:48
well, what if the star
had already formed planets,
115
396480
2776
06:51
and two of these planets had collided,
116
399280
2216
06:53
similar to the Earth-Moon forming event.
117
401520
2120
06:56
Well, both of these theories
could explain part of the data,
118
404440
3536
07:00
but the difficulties were that the star
showed no signs of being young,
119
408000
3416
07:03
and there was no glow
from any of the material
120
411440
2936
07:06
that was heated up by the star's light,
121
414400
2096
07:08
and you would expect this
if the star was young
122
416520
2856
07:11
or if there was a collision
and a lot of dust was produced.
123
419400
3560
07:15
And so somebody else said,
124
423800
1616
07:17
well, how about a huge swarm of comets
125
425440
4976
07:22
that are passing by this star
in a very elliptical orbit?
126
430440
3656
07:26
Well, it ends up that this is actually
consistent with our observations.
127
434120
4400
07:32
But I agree, it does feel
a little contrived.
128
440000
3256
07:35
You see, it would take hundreds of comets
129
443280
3296
07:38
to reproduce what we're observing.
130
446600
1640
07:41
And these are only the comets
131
449200
1576
07:42
that happen to pass
between us and the star.
132
450800
2616
07:45
And so in reality, we're talking
thousands to tens of thousands of comets.
133
453440
6456
07:51
But of all the bad ideas we had,
134
459920
3456
07:55
this one was the best.
135
463400
2136
07:57
And so we went ahead
and published our findings.
136
465560
2936
08:00
Now, let me tell you, this was one
of the hardest papers I ever wrote.
137
468520
4216
08:04
Scientists are meant to publish results,
138
472760
2336
08:07
and this situation was far from that.
139
475120
2160
08:09
And so we decided
to give it a catchy title,
140
477960
3136
08:13
and we called it: "Where's The Flux?"
141
481120
2176
08:15
I will let you work out the acronym.
142
483320
2080
08:18
(Laughter)
143
486160
3720
08:22
So this isn't the end of the story.
144
490840
1696
08:24
Around the same time
I was writing this paper,
145
492560
2176
08:26
I met with a colleague
of mine, Jason Wright,
146
494760
2136
08:28
and he was also writing a paper
on Kepler data.
147
496920
2216
08:31
And he was saying that with Kepler's
extreme precision,
148
499160
4176
08:35
it could actually detect
alien megastructures around stars,
149
503360
4856
08:40
but it didn't.
150
508240
1200
08:42
And then I showed him this weird data
that our citizen scientists had found,
151
510520
3960
08:47
and he said to me,
152
515559
1216
08:48
"Aw crap, Tabby.
153
516799
1777
08:50
Now I have to rewrite my paper."
154
518600
1959
08:54
So yes, the natural
explanations were weak,
155
522440
2200
08:58
and we were curious now.
156
526480
1576
09:00
So we had to find a way
to rule out aliens.
157
528080
3176
09:03
So together, we convinced
a colleague of ours
158
531280
2856
09:06
who works on SETI, the Search
for Extraterrestrial Intelligence,
159
534160
3256
09:09
that this would be
an extraordinary target to pursue.
160
537440
2920
09:14
We wrote a proposal to observe the star
161
542480
2376
09:16
with the world's largest radio telescope
at the Green Bank Observatory.
162
544880
4176
09:21
A couple months later,
163
549080
1376
09:22
news of this proposal
got leaked to the press
164
550480
4240
09:27
and now there are thousands of articles,
165
555760
3456
09:31
over 10,000 articles, on this star alone.
166
559240
3136
09:34
And if you search Google Images,
167
562400
1840
09:36
this is what you'll find.
168
564920
1200
09:39
Now, you may be wondering,
OK, Tabby, well,
169
567600
2496
09:42
how do aliens actually explain
this light curve?
170
570120
3856
09:46
OK, well, imagine a civilization
that's much more advanced than our own.
171
574000
5296
09:51
In this hypothetical circumstance,
172
579320
2320
09:54
this civilization would have exhausted
the energy supply of their home planet,
173
582680
4656
09:59
so where could they get more energy?
174
587360
2176
10:01
Well, they have a host star
just like we have a sun,
175
589560
2800
10:05
and so if they were able
to capture more energy from this star,
176
593240
4056
10:09
then that would solve their energy needs.
177
597320
1960
10:11
So they would go
and build huge structures.
178
599800
3416
10:15
These giant megastructures,
179
603240
2776
10:18
like ginormous solar panels,
are called Dyson spheres.
180
606040
3720
10:22
This image above
181
610440
1296
10:23
are lots of artists' impressions
of Dyson spheres.
182
611760
3176
10:26
It's really hard to provide perspective
on the vastness of these things,
183
614960
5016
10:32
but you can think of it this way.
184
620000
1816
10:33
The Earth-Moon distance
is a quarter of a million miles.
185
621840
3040
10:38
The simplest element
on one of these structures
186
626040
3896
10:41
is 100 times that size.
187
629960
2440
10:45
They're enormous.
188
633400
1320
10:48
And now imagine one of these structures
in motion around a star.
189
636080
4416
10:52
You can see how it would produce
anomalies in the data
190
640520
3096
10:55
such as uneven, unnatural looking dips.
191
643640
3216
10:58
But it remains that even
alien megastructures
192
646880
3976
11:02
cannot defy the laws of physics.
193
650880
2416
11:05
You see, anything that uses
a lot of energy
194
653320
3440
11:09
is going to produce heat,
195
657800
1760
11:12
and we don't observe this.
196
660840
1976
11:14
But it could be something as simple
197
662840
1696
11:16
as they're just reradiating it away
in another direction,
198
664560
3456
11:20
just not at Earth.
199
668040
1200
11:23
Another idea that's one
of my personal favorites
200
671000
2440
11:26
is that we had just witnessed
an interplanetary space battle
201
674320
3776
11:30
and the catastrophic
destruction of a planet.
202
678120
3000
11:34
Now, I admit that this
would produce a lot of dust
203
682520
3256
11:37
that we don't observe.
204
685800
1896
11:39
But if we're already invoking aliens
in this explanation,
205
687720
4336
11:44
then who is to say they didn't
efficiently clean up all this mess
206
692080
3696
11:47
for recycling purposes?
207
695800
1536
11:49
(Laughter)
208
697360
1016
11:50
You can see how this quickly
captures your imagination.
209
698400
2960
11:55
Well, there you have it.
210
703760
1256
11:57
We're in a situation that could unfold
211
705040
3216
12:00
to be a natural phenomenon
we don't understand
212
708280
3416
12:03
or an alien technology
we don't understand.
213
711720
2560
12:07
Personally, as a scientist,
my money is on the natural explanation.
214
715600
5240
12:14
But don't get me wrong, I do think
it would be awesome to find aliens.
215
722040
3320
12:18
Either way, there is something new
and really interesting to discover.
216
726800
4520
12:24
So what happens next?
217
732040
1856
12:25
We need to continue to observe this star
218
733920
2656
12:28
to learn more about what's happening.
219
736600
2416
12:31
But professional astronomers, like me,
220
739040
2576
12:33
we have limited resources
for this kind of thing,
221
741640
2816
12:36
and Kepler is on to a different mission.
222
744480
1920
12:39
And I'm happy to say that once again,
223
747400
4216
12:43
citizen scientists have come in
and saved the day.
224
751640
3120
12:47
You see, this time,
225
755880
2456
12:50
amateur astronomers
with their backyard telescopes
226
758360
2880
12:54
stepped up immediately
and started observing this star nightly
227
762120
3976
12:58
at their own facilities,
228
766120
1496
12:59
and I am so excited to see what they find.
229
767640
2800
13:03
What's amazing to me is that this star
would have never been found by computers
230
771520
4176
13:07
because we just weren't looking
for something like this.
231
775720
2640
13:11
And what's more exciting
232
779400
4256
13:15
is that there's more data to come.
233
783680
1640
13:18
There are new missions that are coming up
234
786200
1976
13:20
that are observing millions more stars
235
788200
2680
13:23
all over the sky.
236
791840
1400
13:26
And just think: What will it mean
when we find another star like this?
237
794280
5520
13:32
And what will it mean
if we don't find another star like this?
238
800520
4080
13:37
Thank you.
239
805280
1216
13:38
(Applause)
240
806520
6921

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tabetha Boyajian - Astronomer
Tabetha Boyajian is best known for her research on KIC 8462852, a puzzling celestial body that has inspired otherwise sober scientists to brainstorm outlandish hypotheses.

Why you should listen
Planet hunter Tabetha Boyajian studies KIC 8462852 (dubbed "Tabby's star" after her team's research): a star exhibiting bizarre (and thus far unique) variations in brightness. These fluctuations have led scientists to postulate causes ranging from comet dust (Boyajian's most likely scenario) to alien megastructures. The latest studies of Tabby's star have proved even more baffling: KIC 8462852 has been gradually dimming over the last century, a strikingly short period of time on an astronomical scale.

Boyajian currently serves as a postdoc with the Yale Exoplanet group, whose research is assisted by the Planet Hunters -- a citizen science group that combs data from the NASA Kepler Space Mission for evidence of exoplanets and other unusual interstellar activity.
More profile about the speaker
Tabetha Boyajian | Speaker | TED.com