ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alice Goffman - Urban sociologist
Alice Goffman’s fieldwork in a struggling Philadelphia neighborhood sheds harsh light on a justice system that creates suspects rather than citizens.

Why you should listen

As an undergraduate studying sociology at the University of Pennsylvania, Alice Goffman was inspired to write her senior thesis about the lives of the young people living in the historic African-American neighborhood that surrounded the school. She lived side-by-side with a group of young men in one of the US’s most distressed communities, experiencing a troubling and rarely discussed side of urban policing -- the beatings, late night raids and body searches that systematically pit young men against authority.

Goffman spent six years in the community, the work transforming into her dissertation at Princeton and then into the book, On the Run. In it, Goffman weaves groundbreaking research into a narrative amplifying neglected and often-ignored voices into a stirring, personal indictment of the social, economic and political forces that unwittingly conspire to push entire communities to the margins of society.

Goffman is now an Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and a vocal advocate for change in America.

More profile about the speaker
Alice Goffman | Speaker | TED.com
TED2015

Alice Goffman: How we're priming some kids for college — and others for prison

Filmed:
1,909,544 views

In the United States, two institutions guide teenagers on the journey to adulthood: college and prison. Sociologist Alice Goffman spent six years in a troubled Philadelphia neighborhood and saw first-hand how teenagers of African-American and Latino backgrounds are funneled down the path to prison — sometimes starting with relatively minor infractions. In an impassioned talk she asks, "Why are we offering only handcuffs and jail time?"
- Urban sociologist
Alice Goffman’s fieldwork in a struggling Philadelphia neighborhood sheds harsh light on a justice system that creates suspects rather than citizens. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
On the path that American children
travel to adulthood,
0
1056
3915
00:16
two institutions oversee the journey.
1
4971
3548
00:20
The first is the one we hear
a lot about: college.
2
8519
3743
00:24
Some of you may remember
the excitement that you felt
3
12262
2583
00:26
when you first set off for college.
4
14845
2586
00:29
Some of you may be in college right now
5
17431
2552
00:31
and you're feeling this excitement
at this very moment.
6
19983
3015
00:35
College has some shortcomings.
7
23988
1679
00:37
It's expensive; it leaves
young people in debt.
8
25667
3336
00:41
But all in all, it's a pretty good path.
9
29003
2944
00:43
Young people emerge from college
with pride and with great friends
10
31947
5167
00:49
and with a lot of knowledge
about the world.
11
37114
2339
00:51
And perhaps most importantly,
12
39453
1836
00:53
a better chance in the labor market
than they had before they got there.
13
41289
4506
00:57
Today I want to talk about
the second institution
14
45795
2703
01:00
overseeing the journey from childhood
to adulthood in the United States.
15
48498
5558
01:06
And that institution is prison.
16
54056
3755
01:10
Young people on this journey
are meeting with probation officers
17
58791
3745
01:14
instead of with teachers.
18
62536
2403
01:16
They're going to court dates
instead of to class.
19
64939
3893
01:20
Their junior year abroad is instead
a trip to a state correctional facility.
20
68832
5077
01:25
And they're emerging from their 20s
21
73909
2690
01:28
not with degrees in business and English,
22
76599
3197
01:31
but with criminal records.
23
79796
2018
01:34
This institution is also costing us a lot,
24
82514
2593
01:37
about 40,000 dollars a year
25
85107
1642
01:38
to send a young person
to prison in New Jersey.
26
86749
3768
01:43
But here, taxpayers are footing the bill
27
91167
2556
01:45
and what kids are getting
is a cold prison cell
28
93723
3483
01:49
and a permanent mark against them
when they come home
29
97206
2810
01:52
and apply for work.
30
100016
2749
01:54
There are more and more kids
on this journey to adulthood
31
102765
3446
01:58
than ever before in the United States
and that's because in the past 40 years,
32
106211
5224
02:03
our incarceration rate
has grown by 700 percent.
33
111435
5752
02:09
I have one slide for this talk.
34
117187
2129
02:11
Here it is.
35
119316
1254
02:13
Here's our incarceration rate,
36
121760
1863
02:15
about 716 people per 100,000
in the population.
37
123623
6292
02:23
Here's the OECD countries.
38
131205
2860
02:30
What's more, it's poor kids
that we're sending to prison,
39
138885
2732
02:33
too many drawn from African-American
and Latino communities
40
141617
3488
02:37
so that prison now stands firmly between
the young people trying to make it
41
145105
4881
02:41
and the fulfillment of the American Dream.
42
149986
3432
02:45
The problem's actually
a bit worse than this
43
153418
2856
02:48
'cause we're not just sending
poor kids to prison,
44
156274
2678
02:50
we're saddling poor kids with court fees,
45
158952
2967
02:53
with probation and parole restrictions,
46
161919
2321
02:56
with low-level warrants,
47
164240
1887
02:58
we're asking them to live
in halfway houses and on house arrest,
48
166127
3495
03:01
and we're asking them
to negotiate a police force
49
169622
3605
03:05
that is entering poor
communities of color,
50
173227
2413
03:07
not for the purposes
of promoting public safety,
51
175640
3199
03:10
but to make arrest counts,
to line city coffers.
52
178839
4476
03:18
This is the hidden underside to our
historic experiment in punishment:
53
186537
4388
03:22
young people worried that at any moment,
they will be stopped, searched and seized.
54
190925
5046
03:28
Not just in the streets,
but in their homes,
55
196635
2623
03:31
at school and at work.
56
199258
2437
03:34
I got interested in this
other path to adulthood
57
202925
3191
03:38
when I was myself a college student
58
206116
2241
03:40
attending the University of Pennsylvania
59
208357
2058
03:42
in the early 2000s.
60
210415
2078
03:44
Penn sits within a historic
African-American neighborhood.
61
212493
3567
03:48
So you've got these two parallel
journeys going on simultaneously:
62
216060
5238
03:53
the kids attending
this elite, private university,
63
221298
3121
03:56
and the kids from
the adjacent neighborhood,
64
224419
2466
03:58
some of whom are making it to college,
65
226885
1928
04:00
and many of whom
are being shipped to prison.
66
228813
3498
04:04
In my sophomore year, I started tutoring
a young woman who was in high school
67
232831
4584
04:09
who lived about 10 minutes
away from the university.
68
237415
2994
04:12
Soon, her cousin came home
from a juvenile detention center.
69
240409
3533
04:15
He was 15, a freshman in high school.
70
243942
2658
04:18
I began to get to know him
and his friends and family,
71
246600
3659
04:22
and I asked him what he thought
about me writing about his life
72
250259
3352
04:25
for my senior thesis in college.
73
253611
2585
04:28
This senior thesis became
a dissertation at Princeton
74
256196
4191
04:32
and now a book.
75
260387
1548
04:33
By the end of my sophomore year,
76
261935
1598
04:35
I moved into the neighborhood
and I spent the next six years
77
263533
3370
04:38
trying to understand what young people
were facing as they came of age.
78
266903
4591
04:44
The first week I spent
in this neighborhood,
79
272234
2084
04:46
I saw two boys, five and seven years old,
80
274318
2576
04:48
play this game of chase,
81
276894
1492
04:50
where the older boy
ran after the other boy.
82
278386
2951
04:53
He played the cop.
83
281337
1195
04:54
When the cop caught up
to the younger boy,
84
282532
2188
04:56
he pushed him down,
85
284720
1700
04:58
handcuffed him with imaginary handcuffs,
86
286420
2551
05:00
took a quarter out of
the other child's pocket,
87
288971
2311
05:03
saying, "I'm seizing that."
88
291282
3592
05:06
He asked the child if
he was carrying any drugs
89
294874
3340
05:10
or if he had a warrant.
90
298214
2445
05:12
Many times, I saw this game repeated,
91
300659
2005
05:14
sometimes children would
simply give up running,
92
302664
2388
05:17
and stick their bodies flat
against the ground
93
305052
2196
05:19
with their hands above their heads,
or flat up against a wall.
94
307248
3345
05:22
Children would yell at each other,
95
310593
1995
05:24
"I'm going to lock you up,
96
312588
1282
05:25
I'm going to lock you up
and you're never coming home!"
97
313870
3182
05:29
Once I saw a six-year-old child
pull another child's pants down
98
317052
4354
05:33
and try to do a cavity search.
99
321406
2410
05:36
In the first 18 months that I lived
in this neighborhood,
100
324756
3179
05:39
I wrote down every time I saw
any contact between police
101
327935
3692
05:43
and people that were my neighbors.
102
331627
2546
05:46
So in the first 18 months,
103
334553
2099
05:48
I watched the police stop
pedestrians or people in cars,
104
336652
3769
05:52
search people, run people's names,
105
340421
2168
05:54
chase people through the streets,
106
342589
1944
05:56
pull people in for questioning,
107
344533
1773
05:58
or make an arrest every single day,
with five exceptions.
108
346306
4183
06:03
Fifty-two times, I watched the police
break down doors,
109
351142
3935
06:07
chase people through houses
110
355077
2041
06:09
or make an arrest of someone
in their home.
111
357118
3219
06:12
Fourteen times
in this first year and a half,
112
360337
2813
06:15
I watched the police punch, choke,
kick, stomp on or beat young men
113
363150
5300
06:20
after they had caught them.
114
368450
2819
06:24
Bit by bit, I got to know two brothers,
115
372289
2376
06:26
Chuck and Tim.
116
374665
1544
06:28
Chuck was 18 when we met,
a senior in high school.
117
376209
3041
06:31
He was playing on the basketball team
and making C's and B's.
118
379250
3548
06:34
His younger brother, Tim, was 10.
119
382798
1899
06:36
And Tim loved Chuck;
he followed him around a lot,
120
384697
3151
06:39
looked to Chuck to be a mentor.
121
387848
2291
06:42
They lived with their mom and grandfather
122
390139
2146
06:44
in a two-story row home
with a front lawn and a back porch.
123
392285
3439
06:47
Their mom was struggling with addiction
all while the boys were growing up.
124
395724
3661
06:51
She never really was able
to hold down a job for very long.
125
399385
3848
06:55
It was their grandfather's pension
that supported the family,
126
403242
3039
06:58
not really enough to pay
for food and clothes
127
406281
3203
07:01
and school supplies for growing boys.
128
409484
2731
07:04
The family was really struggling.
129
412215
2186
07:06
So when we met, Chuck was
a senior in high school.
130
414401
2379
07:08
He had just turned 18.
131
416780
2118
07:11
That winter, a kid in the schoolyard
132
419628
3142
07:14
called Chuck's mom a crack whore.
133
422770
3259
07:18
Chuck pushed the kid's face into the snow
134
426029
2875
07:20
and the school cops charged him
with aggravated assault.
135
428904
3825
07:24
The other kid was fine the next day,
136
432729
1750
07:26
I think it was his pride that was injured
more than anything.
137
434479
3473
07:29
But anyway, since Chuck was 18,
138
437952
1713
07:31
this agg. assault case sent him
to adult county jail
139
439665
3188
07:34
on State Road in northeast Philadelphia,
140
442853
2425
07:37
where he sat, unable to pay the bail --
he couldn't afford it --
141
445278
4067
07:41
while the trial dates
dragged on and on and on
142
449345
3199
07:44
through almost his entire senior year.
143
452544
2722
07:47
Finally, near the end of this season,
144
455926
3050
07:50
the judge on this assault case
threw out most of the charges
145
458976
3347
07:54
and Chuck came home
146
462323
1334
07:55
with only a few hundred dollars' worth
of court fees hanging over his head.
147
463657
4347
08:00
Tim was pretty happy that day.
148
468004
2543
08:02
The next fall, Chuck tried
to re-enroll as a senior,
149
470547
2754
08:05
but the school secretary told him that
150
473301
2014
08:07
he was then 19 and too old
to be readmitted.
151
475315
3131
08:10
Then the judge on his assault case
issued him a warrant for his arrest
152
478446
3667
08:14
because he couldn't pay
the 225 dollars in court fees
153
482113
3275
08:17
that came due a few weeks after
the case ended.
154
485388
3527
08:20
Then he was a high school dropout
living on the run.
155
488915
4020
08:24
Tim's first arrest came later that year
156
492935
2052
08:26
after he turned 11.
157
494987
1783
08:28
Chuck had managed
to get his warrant lifted
158
496770
2130
08:30
and he was on a payment plan
for the court fees
159
498900
2661
08:33
and he was driving Tim to school
in his girlfriend's car.
160
501561
3510
08:37
So a cop pulls them over, runs the car,
161
505071
2735
08:39
and the car comes up
as stolen in California.
162
507806
3785
08:43
Chuck had no idea where in the history
of this car it had been stolen.
163
511591
4123
08:47
His girlfriend's uncle bought it
from a used car auction
164
515714
3476
08:51
in northeast Philly.
165
519190
1467
08:52
Chuck and Tim had never been
outside of the tri-state,
166
520657
2828
08:55
let alone to California.
167
523485
2349
08:57
But anyway, the cops down at the precinct
168
525834
2098
08:59
charged Chuck with
receiving stolen property.
169
527932
3568
09:03
And then a juvenile judge,
a few days later,
170
531500
2812
09:06
charged Tim, age 11,
171
534312
2152
09:08
with accessory to receiving
a stolen property
172
536464
3073
09:11
and then he was placed on
three years of probation.
173
539537
3653
09:16
With this probation sentence
hanging over his head,
174
544430
2902
09:19
Chuck sat his little brother down
175
547332
2087
09:21
and began teaching him
how to run from the police.
176
549419
3449
09:24
They would sit side by side
on their back porch
177
552868
2332
09:27
looking out into the shared alleyway
178
555200
2064
09:29
and Chuck would coach Tim
how to spot undercover cars,
179
557264
3840
09:33
how to negotiate a late-night police raid,
how and where to hide.
180
561104
4967
09:39
I want you to imagine for a second
181
567011
1680
09:40
what Chuck and Tim's lives would be like
182
568691
2369
09:43
if they were living in a neighborhood
where kids were going to college,
183
571060
4749
09:47
not prison.
184
575809
1429
09:49
A neighborhood like the one
I got to grow up in.
185
577918
3153
09:53
Okay, you might say.
186
581071
1465
09:54
But Chuck and Tim, kids like them,
they're committing crimes!
187
582536
3752
09:58
Don't they deserve to be in prison?
188
586288
2126
10:00
Don't they deserve to be
living in fear of arrest?
189
588414
3814
10:04
Well, my answer would be no.
190
592228
3122
10:07
They don't.
191
595350
1080
10:08
And certainly not for the same things
that other young people
192
596430
3027
10:11
with more privilege are doing
with impunity.
193
599457
3444
10:14
If Chuck had gone to my high school,
194
602901
1817
10:16
that schoolyard fight
would have ended there,
195
604718
2323
10:19
as a schoolyard fight.
196
607041
1676
10:20
It never would have become
an aggravated assault case.
197
608717
3550
10:24
Not a single kid that
I went to college with
198
612937
2821
10:27
has a criminal record right now.
199
615758
1679
10:29
Not a single one.
200
617437
1874
10:31
But can you imagine how many might have
if the police had stopped those kids
201
619311
4005
10:35
and searched their pockets for drugs
as they walked to class?
202
623316
3867
10:39
Or had raided their frat parties
in the middle of the night?
203
627183
4061
10:44
Okay, you might say.
204
632384
1272
10:45
But doesn't this high incarceration rate
205
633656
1990
10:47
partly account for our
really low crime rate?
206
635646
2753
10:50
Crime is down. That's a good thing.
207
638399
2424
10:52
Totally, that is a good thing.
Crime is down.
208
640823
2487
10:55
It dropped precipitously in
the '90s and through the 2000s.
209
643310
3527
10:58
But according to a committee of academics
210
646837
2045
11:00
convened by the National Academy
of Sciences last year,
211
648882
3654
11:04
the relationship between our
historically high incarceration rates
212
652536
4009
11:08
and our low crime rate is pretty shaky.
213
656545
3584
11:12
It turns out that the crime rate
goes up and down
214
660129
3440
11:15
irrespective of how many young people
we send to prison.
215
663569
4526
11:21
We tend to think about justice
in a pretty narrow way:
216
669265
3093
11:24
good and bad, innocent and guilty.
217
672358
3604
11:27
Injustice is about being
wrongfully convicted.
218
675962
3355
11:31
So if you're convicted
of something you did do,
219
679317
2315
11:33
you should be punished for it.
220
681632
1835
11:35
There are innocent and guilty people,
221
683467
1766
11:37
there are victims and
there are perpetrators.
222
685233
2437
11:39
Maybe we could think a little bit
more broadly than that.
223
687670
4401
11:44
Right now, we're asking kids who live
in the most disadvantaged neighborhoods,
224
692071
4434
11:48
who have the least amount
of family resources,
225
696505
2281
11:50
who are attending
the country's worst schools,
226
698786
2561
11:53
who are facing the toughest time
in the labor market,
227
701347
2906
11:56
who are living in neighborhoods
where violence is an everyday problem,
228
704253
3653
11:59
we're asking these kids to walk
the thinnest possible line --
229
707906
4573
12:04
to basically never do anything wrong.
230
712479
3811
12:08
Why are we not providing support
to young kids facing these challenges?
231
716290
4501
12:12
Why are we offering only handcuffs,
jail time and this fugitive existence?
232
720791
7246
12:20
Can we imagine something better?
233
728037
2506
12:22
Can we imagine a criminal justice system
that prioritizes recovery,
234
730543
4255
12:26
prevention, civic inclusion,
235
734798
2587
12:29
rather than punishment?
236
737385
2701
12:32
(Applause)
237
740086
3389
12:39
A criminal justice system
that acknowledges
238
747855
2275
12:42
the legacy of exclusion that poor people
of color in the U.S. have faced
239
750130
3980
12:46
and that does not promote
and perpetuate those exclusions.
240
754110
4156
12:50
(Applause)
241
758266
3385
12:55
And finally, a criminal justice system
that believes in black young people,
242
763291
4562
12:59
rather than treating black young people
as the enemy to be rounded up.
243
767853
3864
13:03
(Applause)
244
771717
3723
13:11
The good news is that we already are.
245
779460
2827
13:14
A few years ago, Michelle Alexander
wrote "The New Jim Crow,"
246
782287
4823
13:19
which got Americans to see
incarceration as a civil rights issue
247
787110
4013
13:23
of historic proportions in a way
they had not seen it before.
248
791123
4356
13:27
President Obama and Attorney General
Eric Holder have come out very strongly
249
795479
3759
13:31
on sentencing reform,
250
799238
1717
13:32
on the need to address
racial disparity in incarceration.
251
800955
3744
13:36
We're seeing states throw out
Stop and Frisk
252
804699
2610
13:39
as the civil rights violation that it is.
253
807309
3036
13:42
We're seeing cities and states
decriminalize possession of marijuana.
254
810345
5055
13:47
New York, New Jersey
and California
255
815400
1857
13:49
have been dropping their
prison populations, closing prisons,
256
817257
3837
13:53
while also seeing a big drop in crime.
257
821094
2281
13:55
Texas has gotten into the game now,
258
823375
1693
13:57
also closing prisons,
investing in education.
259
825068
3845
14:00
This curious coalition is building
from the right and the left,
260
828913
3657
14:04
made up of former prisoners
and fiscal conservatives,
261
832570
3448
14:08
of civil rights activists
and libertarians,
262
836018
3331
14:11
of young people taking to the streets
to protest police violence
263
839349
3980
14:15
against unarmed black teenagers,
264
843329
2836
14:18
and older, wealthier people --
265
846165
2046
14:20
some of you are here in the audience --
266
848211
1871
14:22
pumping big money into
decarceration initiatives
267
850082
3935
14:27
In a deeply divided Congress,
268
855357
1750
14:29
the work of reforming
our criminal justice system
269
857107
2703
14:31
is just about the only thing
that the right and the left
270
859810
2792
14:34
are coming together on.
271
862602
2585
14:37
I did not think I would see
this political moment in my lifetime.
272
865187
3914
14:41
I think many of the people
who have been working tirelessly
273
869102
3608
14:44
to write about the causes and consequences
274
872710
2162
14:46
of our historically
high incarceration rates
275
874872
2232
14:49
did not think we would see
this moment in our lifetime.
276
877104
3766
14:52
The question for us now is,
how much can we make of it?
277
880870
3783
14:56
How much can we change?
278
884653
2965
14:59
I want to end with a call to young people,
279
887618
2564
15:02
the young people attending college
280
890182
1634
15:03
and the young people
struggling to stay out of prison
281
891816
3110
15:06
or to make it through prison
and return home.
282
894926
3104
15:10
It may seem like these paths
to adulthood are worlds apart,
283
898030
4033
15:14
but the young people participating
in these two institutions
284
902063
4442
15:18
conveying us to adulthood,
285
906505
1925
15:20
they have one thing in common:
286
908430
2565
15:22
Both can be leaders in the work
of reforming our criminal justice system.
287
910995
4682
15:28
Young people have always been leaders
in the fight for equal rights,
288
916483
3332
15:31
the fight for more people
to be granted dignity
289
919815
2265
15:34
and a fighting chance at freedom.
290
922080
2555
15:36
The mission for the generation
of young people
291
924635
2379
15:39
coming of age in this, a sea-change
moment, potentially,
292
927014
4980
15:43
is to end mass incarceration and
build a new criminal justice system,
293
931994
5264
15:49
emphasis on the word justice.
294
937258
2927
15:52
Thanks.
295
940185
1404
15:53
(Applause)
296
941589
3579

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alice Goffman - Urban sociologist
Alice Goffman’s fieldwork in a struggling Philadelphia neighborhood sheds harsh light on a justice system that creates suspects rather than citizens.

Why you should listen

As an undergraduate studying sociology at the University of Pennsylvania, Alice Goffman was inspired to write her senior thesis about the lives of the young people living in the historic African-American neighborhood that surrounded the school. She lived side-by-side with a group of young men in one of the US’s most distressed communities, experiencing a troubling and rarely discussed side of urban policing -- the beatings, late night raids and body searches that systematically pit young men against authority.

Goffman spent six years in the community, the work transforming into her dissertation at Princeton and then into the book, On the Run. In it, Goffman weaves groundbreaking research into a narrative amplifying neglected and often-ignored voices into a stirring, personal indictment of the social, economic and political forces that unwittingly conspire to push entire communities to the margins of society.

Goffman is now an Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and a vocal advocate for change in America.

More profile about the speaker
Alice Goffman | Speaker | TED.com