ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Nina Fedoroff - Molecular biologist
Nina Fedoroff writes and lectures about the history and science of genetically modified organisms.

Why you should listen

Nina Fedoroff serves as science adviser to several organizations, including OFW Law and the Global Knowledge Initiative (GKI) in Washington, DC and the Santa Fe Institute in Santa Fe, NM. With former Secretary of Agriculture Jack Block, she recently published a New York Times editorial titled "Mosquito vs. Mosquito in the Battle Over the Zika Virus."

Fedoroff was trained as a molecular biologist and geneticist at the Rockefeller University in New York City. The university awarded her an honorary doctorate in 2008 as one of its most distinguished alumni on the occasion of its 50th anniversary.

Fedoroff's early scientific accomplishments include analyzing a curious enzyme that replicates the RNA genome of a tiny RNA virus and sequencing of one the first genes ever to be sequenced. On the strength of this work, she was appointed a member of the scientific staff of the Carnegie Institution for Science’s Department of Embryology. Her most important contributions began when she met the legendary biologist Barbara McClintock in 1978. She was intrigued by McClintock’s pioneering work on transposable elements, commonly known as "jumping genes," in corn plants.

McClintock's work was purely genetic, hence Fedoroff set out to study her jumping genes at the molecular level. That meant figuring out how to clone plant genes, none of which had yet been cloned. In fact, people had begun to wonder whether plant genes could be cloned at all. Solving the technical problems, Fedoroff and her students unraveled the molecular details of how these mobile DNA sequences move and how the plants exert epigenetic control of their movement. This work led to her election to the National Academy of Sciences in 1990. Her capstone book on transposable elements entitled Plant Transposons and Genome Dynamics in Evolution ,was published in 2013.

Fedoroff moved the Penn State University in 1995 as the Director of the Biotechnology Institute and Vern M. Willaman Chair in Life Sciences. Here she organized a multidisciplinary graduate and research program now known as the Huck Institute of the Life Sciences. Her laboratory research shifted to understanding how plants respond to stress and how they process small regulatory RNAs from larger precursors. She also began to dance Argentine tango. And she wrote a book with science writer Nancy Marie Brown titled Mendel in the Kitchen: A Scientist’s View of Genetically Modified Foods.

The year 2007 was marked by two extraordinary events in Fedoroff's life. She was named a National Medal of Science laureate for 2006 and she was appointed as the Science and Technology Adviser to the Secretary of State by then-Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice. The science advisory position gave her an unexpected bully pulpit to talk about the importance of science in diplomacy, about which she was interviewed by Claudia Dreifus of the New York Times. It also gave her many opportunities to talk about genetic modification and GMOs all over the world. Realizing that development efforts would benefit from increased involvement of scientists, she organized the GKI, an NGO that builds collaborative networks around problems requiring scientific and technological input.

Completing her advisory work at the State Department in 2010, Fedoroff was recruited to the new King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) as a Distinguished Professor of the Life Sciences. At KAUST, Fedoroff organized a Center for Desert Agriculture, seeking to address the difficulties facing agriculture in increasingly populous dryland areas.

Today Fedoroff continues write and lecture internationally, most recently keynoting the 2017 Mantua Food and Science Festival in Mantua, Italy. She continues to dance tango, traveling to Buenos Aires each of the past couple of years. 

More profile about the speaker
Nina Fedoroff | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxMidAtlantic

Nina Fedoroff: A secret weapon against Zika and other mosquito-borne diseases

Filmed:
1,094,918 views

Where did Zika come from, and what can we do about it? Molecular biologist Nina Fedoroff takes us around the world to understand Zika's origins and how it spread, proposing a controversial way to stop the virus -- and other deadly diseases -- by preventing infected mosquitoes from multiplying.
- Molecular biologist
Nina Fedoroff writes and lectures about the history and science of genetically modified organisms. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
Zika fever:
0
1047
1150
00:16
our newest dread disease.
1
4120
3706
00:19
What is it? Where'd it come from?
2
7850
2996
00:22
What do we do about it?
3
10870
1230
00:25
Well for most adults,
it's a relatively mild disease --
4
13030
3270
00:28
a little fever, a little headache,
joint pain, maybe a rash.
5
16324
4301
00:33
In fact, most people who get it
don't even know they've had it.
6
21010
3310
00:36
But the more we find out
about the Zika virus
7
24820
3714
00:40
the more terrifying it becomes.
8
28558
1548
00:42
For example, doctors
have noticed an uptick
9
30130
3507
00:45
of something called Guillain-Barré
syndrome in recent outbreaks.
10
33661
3714
00:49
In Guillain-Barré, your immune system
attacks your nerve cells
11
37399
3152
00:52
it can partially
or even totally paralyze you.
12
40575
3119
00:56
Fortunately, that's quite rare,
and most people recover.
13
44272
3238
01:00
But if you're pregnant
when you're infected
14
48220
3873
01:05
you're at risk of something terrible.
15
53900
2423
01:08
Indeed, a child with a deformed head.
16
56704
3436
01:12
Here's a normal baby.
17
60680
1484
01:15
Here's that infant
with what's called microcephaly.
18
63314
3239
01:19
a brain in a head that's too small.
19
67075
2658
01:22
And there's no known cure.
20
70393
1594
01:25
It was actually doctors
in northeastern Brazil
21
73121
5730
01:30
who first noticed, just a year ago,
after a Zika outbreak,
22
78875
5110
01:36
that there was a peak
in the incidence of microcephaly.
23
84009
4127
01:40
It took medical doctors another year
24
88763
1723
01:42
to be sure that it was caused
by the Zika virus,
25
90510
2792
01:45
but they're now sure.
26
93326
1151
01:46
And if you're a "bring on
the evidence" type,
27
94501
2682
01:49
check out this publication.
28
97207
1563
01:51
So where did it come from,
and how did it get here?
29
99760
2944
01:54
And it is here.
30
102728
1309
01:56
Like many of our viruses,
it came out of Africa,
31
104061
2912
01:59
specifically the Zika forest in Uganda.
32
107441
3349
02:03
Researchers at the nearby
Yellow Fever Research Institute
33
111776
4778
02:08
identified an unknown virus
in a monkey in the Zika forest
34
116578
4286
02:12
which is how it got its name.
35
120888
2000
02:15
The first human cases of Zika fever
36
123593
2213
02:17
surfaced a few years later
in Uganda-Tanzania.
37
125830
2975
02:21
The virus then spread through West Africa
38
129479
2891
02:25
and east through equatorial Asia --
Pakistan, India, Malaysia, Indonesia.
39
133216
6414
02:32
But it was still mostly in monkeys
and, of course, mosquitoes.
40
140344
3992
02:37
In fact in the 60 years between the time
it was first identified in 1947 and 2007
41
145872
5798
02:43
there were only 13 reported cases
of human Zika fever.
42
151694
3603
02:47
And then something extraordinary happened
on the tiny Micronesian Yap islands.
43
155731
5945
02:53
There was an outbreak that affected
fully 75 percent of the population.
44
161700
5285
02:59
How did it get there? By air.
45
167866
2769
03:03
Today we have two billion
commercial airline passengers.
46
171580
3736
03:07
An infected passenger can board a plane,
fly halfway around the world
47
175340
4243
03:11
before developing symptoms --
if they develop symptoms at all.
48
179607
3531
03:16
Then when they land, the local mosquitoes
begin to bite them and spread the fever.
49
184140
4039
03:21
Zika fever then next surfaced
in 2013 in French Polynesia.
50
189117
5849
03:27
By December of that year, it was being
transmitted locally by the mosquitoes.
51
195360
5264
03:33
That led to an explosive outbreak in which
almost 30,000 people were affected.
52
201014
5000
03:38
From there it radiated around the Pacific.
53
206371
2397
03:40
There were outbreaks in the Cook
Islands, in New Caledonia,
54
208792
4523
03:45
in Vanuatu, in the Solomon Islands
55
213704
2420
03:48
and almost all the way around to the coast
of South America and Easter Island.
56
216148
4888
03:53
And then, in early 2015,
57
221060
3452
03:56
there was an upsurge of cases
of a dengue-like syndrome
58
224536
4365
04:01
in the city of Natal
in northeastern Brazil.
59
229393
3428
04:05
The virus wasn't dengue, it was Zika,
and it spread rapidly --
60
233321
5412
04:11
Recife down the coast, a big metropolitan
center, soon became the epicenter.
61
239447
5350
04:17
Well people have speculated that it was
2014 World Cup soccer fans
62
245415
5602
04:23
that brought the virus into the country.
63
251041
2049
04:25
But others have speculated that perhaps
it was Pacific Islanders
64
253840
4071
04:29
participating in championship canoe races
65
257935
2659
04:32
that were held in Rio that year
that brought it in.
66
260618
2428
04:35
Well today, this is only a year later.
67
263830
3619
04:39
The virus is being locally transmitted
by mosquitoes
68
267763
3417
04:43
virtually throughout South America,
Central America, Mexico
69
271204
3261
04:46
and the Caribbean Islands
70
274489
1421
04:48
Until this year, the many
thousands of cases
71
276680
3387
04:52
that have been diagnosed in the US
were contracted elsewhere.
72
280091
3819
04:57
But as of this summer, it's being
transmitted locally in Miami.
73
285076
5158
05:02
It's here.
74
290258
1241
05:03
So what do we do about it?
75
291523
1285
05:05
Well, preventing infection
76
293170
3373
05:10
is either about protecting people
or about eliminating the mosquitoes.
77
298035
3857
05:14
Let's focus on people first.
78
302260
1571
05:16
You can get vaccinated.
79
304690
1681
05:19
You can not travel to Zika areas.
80
307072
3973
05:23
Or you can cover up
and apply insect repellent.
81
311069
2928
05:26
Getting vaccinated is not an option,
because there isn't a vaccine yet
82
314838
3405
05:30
and there probably won't be
for a couple of years.
83
318267
2380
05:33
Staying home isn't
a foolproof protection either
84
321853
3943
05:37
because we now know that
it can be sexually transmitted.
85
325820
3015
05:42
Covering up and applying
insect repellent does work ...
86
330180
2936
05:45
until you forget.
87
333656
1666
05:47
(Laughter)
88
335822
1778
05:49
So that leaves the mosquitoes,
and here's how we control them now:
89
337624
3103
05:53
spraying insecticides.
90
341235
1825
05:56
The protective gear is necessary
because these are toxic chemicals
91
344314
3866
06:00
that kill people as well as bugs.
92
348204
2601
06:02
Although it does take quite a lot more
to kill a person than to kill a bug.
93
350829
3767
06:06
These are pictures from
Brazil and Nicaragua.
94
354620
4176
06:10
But it looks the same in Miami, Florida.
95
358820
2633
06:13
And we of course can spray
insecticides from planes.
96
361770
5293
06:19
Last summer, mosquito control officials
in Dorchester County, South Carolina,
97
367460
6214
06:25
authorized spraying of Naled,
an insecticide,
98
373698
3905
06:29
early one morning,
as recommended by the manufacturer.
99
377627
2880
06:32
Later that day, a beekeeper told reporters
100
380990
4215
06:37
that her bee yard looked
like it had been nuked.
101
385229
3801
06:41
Oops.
102
389824
1389
06:43
Bees are the good guys.
103
391879
1332
06:45
The citizens of Florida protested,
but spraying continued.
104
393640
7000
06:53
Unfortunately, so did the increase
in the number of Zika fever cases.
105
401251
4214
06:58
That's because insecticides
aren't very effective.
106
406200
3503
07:02
So are there any approaches that are
perhaps more effective than spraying
107
410390
6261
07:10
but with less downsides
than toxic chemicals?
108
418560
5333
07:16
I'm a huge fan of biological controls,
109
424330
3491
07:19
and I share that view with Rachel Carson,
author of "Silent Spring,"
110
427845
4493
07:24
the book that is credited with starting
the environmental movement.
111
432362
5014
07:29
In this book she tells the story,
as an example,
112
437400
3556
07:32
of how a very nasty insect
pest of livestock
113
440980
5658
07:38
was eliminated in the last century.
114
446662
3040
07:42
No one knows that
extraordinary story today.
115
450150
2452
07:44
So Jack Block and I,
when we were writing an editorial
116
452626
4239
07:48
about the mosquito problem today,
retold that story.
117
456889
3214
07:52
And in capsule form, it's that pupae --
that's the immature form of the insect --
118
460127
4666
07:56
were irradiated until they were sterile,
grown to adulthood
119
464817
4779
08:01
and then released from planes
all over the Southwest,
120
469620
3610
08:05
the Southeast and down into Mexico
and into Central America
121
473254
4413
08:09
literally by the hundreds of millions
from little airplanes,
122
477691
3809
08:13
eventually eliminating
that terrible insect pest
123
481809
4524
08:18
for most of the Western Hemisphere.
124
486682
2078
08:22
Our real purpose in writing this editorial
125
490175
2404
08:24
was to introduce readers
to how we can do that today --
126
492603
2984
08:27
not with radiation
but with our knowledge of genetics.
127
495999
4055
08:32
Let me explain.
128
500078
1150
08:33
This is the bad guy: Aedes aegypti.
129
501910
2476
08:36
It's the most common insect
vector of diseases,
130
504410
4661
08:41
not just Zika but dengue,
Chikungunya, West Nile virus
131
509095
3794
08:44
and that ancient plague, yellow fever.
132
512913
3634
08:48
It's an urban mosquito,
133
516970
1865
08:50
and it's the female
that does the dirty work.
134
518859
3906
08:54
She bites to get a blood meal
to feed her offspring.
135
522789
4754
09:00
Males don't bite; they don't even
have the mouth parts to bite.
136
528250
3857
09:04
A little British company called Oxitec
genetically modified that mosquito
137
532599
6158
09:10
so that when it mates with a wild female,
its eggs don't develop to adulthood.
138
538781
6345
09:17
Let me show you.
139
545150
1150
09:18
This is the normal reproductive cycle.
140
546657
2524
09:21
Oxitec designed the mosquito so that
when the male mates with the wild female
141
549895
4246
09:27
the eggs don't develop.
142
555077
1206
09:28
Sounds impossible?
143
556780
1420
09:30
Well let me show you
just diagrammatically how they do it.
144
558740
3412
09:34
Now this represents the nucleus
of a mosquito cell,
145
562540
3452
09:38
and that tangle in the middle
represents its genome,
146
566016
2952
09:40
the sum total of its genes.
147
568992
2500
09:43
Scientists added a single gene
148
571516
3349
09:46
that codes for a protein represented
by this orange ball
149
574889
4309
09:51
that feeds back on itself
to keep cranking out more of that protein.
150
579222
5492
09:57
The extra copies, however,
go and gum up the mosquitoes' genes,
151
585240
4753
10:02
killing the organism.
152
590017
1278
10:04
To keep it alive in the laboratory
they use a compound called tetracycline.
153
592240
3888
10:08
Tetracycline shuts off that gene
and allows normal development.
154
596636
5364
10:14
They added another little wrinkle
so that they could study what happens.
155
602024
4333
10:18
And that is they added a gene
that makes the insect glow under UV light
156
606381
6763
10:25
so that when they released it
they could follow exactly how far it went
157
613636
3342
10:29
how long it lived
and all of the kinds of data
158
617002
3754
10:32
for a good scientific study.
159
620780
1492
10:35
Now this is the pupal stage,
and at this stage
160
623150
3158
10:39
the females are larger than the males.
161
627286
2721
10:42
That allows them to sort them
into the males and the females
162
630600
3868
10:46
and they allow only the males
to grow to adulthood.
163
634492
4722
10:51
And let me remind you
that males don't bite.
164
639238
2318
10:53
From there it's pretty simple.
165
641580
1596
10:55
They take beakers full of male mosquitoes,
166
643200
3602
10:58
load them into milk cartons,
and drive around the city,
167
646826
2580
11:01
releasing them guided by GPS.
168
649430
2587
11:04
Here's the mayor of a city
releasing the first batch
169
652858
2517
11:07
of what they call the "friendly Aedes."
170
655399
2987
11:10
Now I wish I could tell you
this is an American city, but it's not.
171
658410
3261
11:13
It's Piracicaba, Brazil.
172
661695
1944
11:16
The amazing thing is that in just a year
173
664171
4793
11:20
it brought down the cases
of dengue by 91 percent.
174
668988
5008
11:26
That's better than any insecticide
spraying can do.
175
674490
3040
11:30
So why aren't we using this remarkable
biological control in the US?
176
678420
5506
11:35
That's because it's a GMO:
a genetically modified organism.
177
683950
6926
11:42
Notice the subtitle here says
if the FDA would let them
178
690900
4634
11:47
they could do the same thing here,
when Zika arrives.
179
695844
2702
11:50
And of course it has arrived.
180
698570
1738
11:52
So now I have to tell you the short form
181
700608
3708
11:56
of the long, torturous story
of GM regulation in the US
182
704340
5769
12:02
In the US, there are three agencies that
regulate genetically modified organisms:
183
710927
6579
12:10
the FDA, the Food and Drug Administration,
184
718165
2491
12:12
the EPA, the Environmental
Protection Agency,
185
720680
2222
12:14
and the USDA, US Department
of Agriculture.
186
722926
2873
12:18
Took these folks two years
to decide that it would be the FDA
187
726520
4793
12:23
that would regulate the genetically
modified mosquito.
188
731337
2903
12:26
And they would do it as a new animal drug,
if that makes any sense.
189
734264
6484
12:33
Took them another five years going back
and forth and back and forth
190
741310
3531
12:36
to convince the FDA
that this would not harm people,
191
744865
5387
12:42
and it would not harm the environment.
192
750276
2980
12:45
They finally gave them, this summer,
permission to run a little test
193
753280
5327
12:50
in the Florida Keys,
194
758631
1539
12:52
where they had been invited years earlier
when they Keys had an outbreak of dengue.
195
760194
6484
12:59
Would that it were that easy.
196
767784
2031
13:02
When the local residents heard
197
770350
2206
13:04
that there would be genetically modified
mosquitoes tested in their community
198
772580
4095
13:08
some of them began to organize protests.
199
776699
2825
13:11
They even organized a petition on
the internet with this cuddly logo,
200
779548
5039
13:17
which eventually accumulated
some 160,000 signatures
201
785143
6237
13:23
And they demanded a referendum
202
791404
1682
13:25
which will be conducted
in just a couple of weeks
203
793110
2872
13:28
about whether the trials
would be permitted at all.
204
796006
3103
13:32
Well it's Miami that really needs
these better ways of controlling insects.
205
800315
6397
13:38
And there the attitudes are changing.
206
806736
2141
13:40
In fact, very recently a bipartisan group
of more than 60 legislators
207
808901
6015
13:46
wrote to HHS Secretary Sylvia Burwell
208
814940
3182
13:50
asking that she, at the Federal level,
expedite access for Florida
209
818146
5344
13:55
to this new technology.
210
823514
2084
13:58
So the bottom line is this:
211
826200
1587
13:59
biological control of harmful insects
212
827811
3650
14:03
can be both more effective and
very much more environmentally friendly
213
831763
4912
14:08
than using insecticides,
which are toxic chemicals.
214
836699
4793
14:13
That was true in Rachel Carson's
time; it's true today.
215
841516
3440
14:16
What's different is that we have
enormously more information
216
844980
5714
14:22
about genetics than we had then,
217
850718
1897
14:24
and therefore more ability
to use that information
218
852639
4134
14:29
to affect these biological controls.
219
857179
2380
14:32
And I hope that what I've done
is aroused your curiosity enough
220
860440
4928
14:37
to start your own inquiry --
not into just GM mosquitoes
221
865392
5284
14:42
but to the other genetically modified
organisms that are so controversial today.
222
870700
6404
14:49
I think if you do that, and you dig down
through all of the misinformation,
223
877747
4697
14:54
and the marketing
224
882468
1310
14:55
on the part of the organic food industry
and the Greenpeaces
225
883802
3388
14:59
and find the science,
the accurate science,
226
887214
3150
15:02
you'll be surprised and pleased.
227
890388
2310
15:05
Thank you.
228
893120
1150
15:06
(Applause)
229
894294
2000

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Nina Fedoroff - Molecular biologist
Nina Fedoroff writes and lectures about the history and science of genetically modified organisms.

Why you should listen

Nina Fedoroff serves as science adviser to several organizations, including OFW Law and the Global Knowledge Initiative (GKI) in Washington, DC and the Santa Fe Institute in Santa Fe, NM. With former Secretary of Agriculture Jack Block, she recently published a New York Times editorial titled "Mosquito vs. Mosquito in the Battle Over the Zika Virus."

Fedoroff was trained as a molecular biologist and geneticist at the Rockefeller University in New York City. The university awarded her an honorary doctorate in 2008 as one of its most distinguished alumni on the occasion of its 50th anniversary.

Fedoroff's early scientific accomplishments include analyzing a curious enzyme that replicates the RNA genome of a tiny RNA virus and sequencing of one the first genes ever to be sequenced. On the strength of this work, she was appointed a member of the scientific staff of the Carnegie Institution for Science’s Department of Embryology. Her most important contributions began when she met the legendary biologist Barbara McClintock in 1978. She was intrigued by McClintock’s pioneering work on transposable elements, commonly known as "jumping genes," in corn plants.

McClintock's work was purely genetic, hence Fedoroff set out to study her jumping genes at the molecular level. That meant figuring out how to clone plant genes, none of which had yet been cloned. In fact, people had begun to wonder whether plant genes could be cloned at all. Solving the technical problems, Fedoroff and her students unraveled the molecular details of how these mobile DNA sequences move and how the plants exert epigenetic control of their movement. This work led to her election to the National Academy of Sciences in 1990. Her capstone book on transposable elements entitled Plant Transposons and Genome Dynamics in Evolution ,was published in 2013.

Fedoroff moved the Penn State University in 1995 as the Director of the Biotechnology Institute and Vern M. Willaman Chair in Life Sciences. Here she organized a multidisciplinary graduate and research program now known as the Huck Institute of the Life Sciences. Her laboratory research shifted to understanding how plants respond to stress and how they process small regulatory RNAs from larger precursors. She also began to dance Argentine tango. And she wrote a book with science writer Nancy Marie Brown titled Mendel in the Kitchen: A Scientist’s View of Genetically Modified Foods.

The year 2007 was marked by two extraordinary events in Fedoroff's life. She was named a National Medal of Science laureate for 2006 and she was appointed as the Science and Technology Adviser to the Secretary of State by then-Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice. The science advisory position gave her an unexpected bully pulpit to talk about the importance of science in diplomacy, about which she was interviewed by Claudia Dreifus of the New York Times. It also gave her many opportunities to talk about genetic modification and GMOs all over the world. Realizing that development efforts would benefit from increased involvement of scientists, she organized the GKI, an NGO that builds collaborative networks around problems requiring scientific and technological input.

Completing her advisory work at the State Department in 2010, Fedoroff was recruited to the new King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) as a Distinguished Professor of the Life Sciences. At KAUST, Fedoroff organized a Center for Desert Agriculture, seeking to address the difficulties facing agriculture in increasingly populous dryland areas.

Today Fedoroff continues write and lecture internationally, most recently keynoting the 2017 Mantua Food and Science Festival in Mantua, Italy. She continues to dance tango, traveling to Buenos Aires each of the past couple of years. 

More profile about the speaker
Nina Fedoroff | Speaker | TED.com