TEDWomen 2017
Deanna Van Buren: What a world without prisons could look like
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
1,065,833 views
Deanna Van Buren designs restorative justice centers that, instead of taking the punitive approach used by a system focused on mass incarceration, treat crime as a breach of relationships and justice as a process where all stakeholders come together to repair that breach. With help and ideas from incarcerated men and women, Van Buren is creating dynamic spaces that provide safe venues for dialogue and reconciliation; employment and job training; and social services to help keep people from entering the justice system in the first place. "Imagine a world without prisons," Van Buren says. "And join me in creating all the things that we could build instead."
Deanna Van Buren - Activist, architect, artist
Deanna Van Buren is an architect who designs spaces for peacemaking, inside and out. Full bio
Deanna Van Buren is an architect who designs spaces for peacemaking, inside and out. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
A lot of people call me
a "justice architect."
a "justice architect."
0
825
4809
00:18
But I don't design prisons.
1
6865
1937
00:21
I don't design jails.
2
9786
1675
00:23
I don't design detention centers,
and I don't even design courthouses.
and I don't even design courthouses.
3
11960
4098
00:28
All the same, I get a call every week,
4
16872
3927
00:32
saying, "OK, but you design
better prisons, right?
better prisons, right?
5
20823
4349
00:37
You know, like those pretty ones
they're building in Europe."
they're building in Europe."
6
25196
2920
00:40
And I always pause.
7
28450
1738
00:43
And I invite them,
8
31466
1398
00:45
and I invite you today,
9
33586
1575
00:47
to imagine a world without prisons.
10
35617
2333
00:51
What does that justice feel and look like?
11
39101
3301
00:55
What do we need to build to get there?
12
43751
2335
00:59
I'd like to show you some ideas today
of things that we're building.
of things that we're building.
13
47673
3722
01:03
And I'm going to start
with an early prototype.
with an early prototype.
14
51419
2952
01:06
This I built when I was five.
15
54395
2158
01:08
I call it "the healing hut."
16
56577
1814
01:11
And I built it after I got
sent home from school
sent home from school
17
59212
3107
01:14
for punching this kid in the face
because he called me the N-word.
because he called me the N-word.
18
62343
3670
01:18
OK, he deserved it.
19
66037
1267
01:20
It happened a lot, though,
20
68427
1840
01:22
because my family had desegregated
a white community in rural Virginia.
a white community in rural Virginia.
21
70291
4816
01:28
And I was really scared.
22
76093
2340
01:30
I was afraid.
23
78893
1176
01:32
I was angry.
24
80498
1150
01:34
And so I would run into the forest,
and I would build these little huts.
and I would build these little huts.
25
82325
3419
01:37
They were made out of twigs and leaves
and blankets I had taken from my mom.
and blankets I had taken from my mom.
26
85768
4326
01:42
And as the light would stream
into my refuge,
into my refuge,
27
90776
3318
01:47
I would feel at peace.
28
95284
1466
01:51
Despite my efforts to comfort myself,
29
99006
2498
01:53
I still left my community
as soon as I could,
as soon as I could,
30
101528
3089
01:56
and I went to architecture school
31
104641
2023
01:58
and then into a professional career
designing shopping centers,
designing shopping centers,
32
106688
3670
02:02
homes for the wealthy
33
110382
1401
02:03
and office buildings,
34
111807
1532
02:06
until I stepped into a prison
for the first time.
for the first time.
35
114454
3203
02:10
It was the Chester State
Correctional Institution in Pennsylvania.
Correctional Institution in Pennsylvania.
36
118193
4048
02:14
And my friend, she invited me there
37
122265
2066
02:16
to work with some
of her incarcerated students
of her incarcerated students
38
124355
2159
02:18
and teach them about
the positive power of design.
the positive power of design.
39
126538
3399
02:22
The irony is so obvious, right?
40
130704
2068
02:24
As I approached this concrete building,
these tiny little windows,
these tiny little windows,
41
132796
3456
02:28
barbed wire, high walls,
observation towers,
observation towers,
42
136276
3483
02:32
and on the inside,
these cold, hard spaces,
these cold, hard spaces,
43
140149
3872
02:36
little light or air,
44
144450
1850
02:38
the guards are screaming,
the doors are clanking,
the doors are clanking,
45
146324
2856
02:41
there's a wall of cells filled with
so many black and brown bodies.
so many black and brown bodies.
46
149204
5257
02:47
And I realized that what I was seeing
47
155257
2857
02:50
was the end result of our racist policies
that had caused mass incarceration.
that had caused mass incarceration.
48
158138
4737
02:55
But as an architect, what I was seeing
49
163641
2674
02:58
was how a prison is the worst
building type we could have created
building type we could have created
50
166339
3833
03:02
to address the harm
that we're doing to one another.
that we're doing to one another.
51
170196
2548
03:06
I thought, "Well, could I design
an alternative to this,
an alternative to this,
52
174085
2633
03:08
other than building a prettier prison?"
53
176742
2001
03:10
It didn't feel good to me;
it still doesn't feel good.
it still doesn't feel good.
54
178767
2696
03:14
But back then, I just
didn't know what to do.
didn't know what to do.
55
182395
2563
03:17
What do we build instead of this?
56
185315
1792
03:20
And then I heard
about restorative justice.
about restorative justice.
57
188348
2933
03:23
I felt at peace again,
58
191840
2126
03:26
because here was an alternative system
59
194632
2826
03:29
that says when a crime is committed,
it is a breach of relationship,
it is a breach of relationship,
60
197482
4681
03:34
that the needs of those
who have been harmed
who have been harmed
61
202680
2381
03:37
must be addressed first;
62
205085
1880
03:39
that those who have committed the offense
63
207657
2587
03:42
have an obligation to make amends.
64
210268
2356
03:45
And what they are
are really intense dialogues,
are really intense dialogues,
65
213085
2403
03:47
where all stakeholders come together
to find a way to repair the breach.
to find a way to repair the breach.
66
215512
5227
03:53
Early data shows that
restorative justice builds empathy;
restorative justice builds empathy;
67
221695
3357
03:57
that it reduces violent reoffending
by up to 75 percent;
by up to 75 percent;
68
225560
3980
04:02
that it eases PTSD in survivors
of the most severe violence.
of the most severe violence.
69
230020
4480
04:06
And because of these reasons,
70
234877
1929
04:08
we see prosecutors and judges
and district attorneys
and district attorneys
71
236830
2826
04:11
starting to divert cases out of court
and into restorative justice
and into restorative justice
72
239680
3572
04:15
so that some people never
touch the system altogether.
touch the system altogether.
73
243276
3380
04:19
And so I thought, "Well, damn --
why aren't we designing for this system?"
why aren't we designing for this system?"
74
247141
3572
04:22
(Applause)
75
250737
1262
04:24
Instead of building prisons,
76
252023
2499
04:26
we should be building spaces
to amplify restorative justice.
to amplify restorative justice.
77
254546
3448
04:30
And so I started in schools,
78
258870
2278
04:33
because suspensions and expulsions
79
261791
3238
04:37
have been fueling the pathway
to prison for decades.
to prison for decades.
80
265053
3287
04:40
And many school districts --
probably some of your own --
probably some of your own --
81
268953
2887
04:43
are turning to restorative justice
as an alternative.
as an alternative.
82
271864
3006
04:48
So, my first project -- I just turned
this dirty little storage room
this dirty little storage room
83
276125
3476
04:51
into a peacemaking room
for a program in a high school
for a program in a high school
84
279625
3754
04:55
in my hometown of Oakland.
85
283403
1800
04:57
And after we were done, the director said
86
285860
3198
05:01
that the circles
she was holding in this space
she was holding in this space
87
289082
2588
05:03
were more powerful in bringing
the community together
the community together
88
291694
2999
05:06
after fighting at school
and gun violence in the community,
and gun violence in the community,
89
294717
3571
05:10
and that students and teachers
started to come here
started to come here
90
298673
3063
05:13
just because they saw it
as a space of refuge.
as a space of refuge.
91
301760
2667
05:17
So what was happening is that the space
was amplifying the effects of the process.
was amplifying the effects of the process.
92
305434
5411
05:24
OK, then I did something
that architects always do, y'all.
that architects always do, y'all.
93
312290
4402
05:29
I was like, I'm going to build
something massive now, right?
something massive now, right?
94
317323
3548
05:32
I'm going to build the world's first
restorative justice center all by myself.
restorative justice center all by myself.
95
320895
4784
05:38
And it's going to be
a beautiful figure on the skyline,
a beautiful figure on the skyline,
96
326173
3015
05:41
like a beacon in the night.
97
329212
1825
05:43
Thousands of people will come here
instead of going to court.
instead of going to court.
98
331061
3873
05:46
I will single-handedly
end mass incarceration
end mass incarceration
99
334958
2746
05:49
and win lots of design awards.
100
337728
2227
05:51
(Laughter)
101
339979
2773
05:54
And then I checked myself --
102
342776
1553
05:56
(Laughter)
103
344353
1462
05:57
because here's the deal:
104
345839
1427
06:00
we are incarcerating more
of our citizens per capita
of our citizens per capita
105
348014
3509
06:03
than any country in the world.
106
351547
1609
06:05
And the fastest-growing
population there are black women.
population there are black women.
107
353180
3278
06:08
Ninety-five percent
of all these folks are coming home.
of all these folks are coming home.
108
356966
3635
06:13
And most of them are survivors of severe
sexual, physical and emotional abuse.
sexual, physical and emotional abuse.
109
361530
6401
06:20
They have literally been
on both sides of the harm.
on both sides of the harm.
110
368323
2547
06:23
So I thought, uh, maybe I should ask them
111
371577
2373
06:25
what we should build instead of prisons.
112
373974
2238
06:29
So I returned with
a restorative justice expert,
a restorative justice expert,
113
377317
4198
06:33
and we started to run
the country's first design studios
the country's first design studios
114
381539
3104
06:36
with incarcerated men and women
115
384667
1870
06:38
around the intersection
of restorative justice and design.
of restorative justice and design.
116
386561
3046
06:42
And it was transformative for me.
117
390069
1580
06:43
I saw all these people behind walls
in a totally different way.
in a totally different way.
118
391673
4407
06:48
These were souls deeply committed
to their personal transformation
to their personal transformation
119
396998
3786
06:52
and being accountable.
120
400808
1466
06:54
They were creative, they were visionary.
121
402602
2734
06:58
Danny is one of those souls.
122
406490
1953
07:01
He's been incarcerated
at San Quentin for 27 years
at San Quentin for 27 years
123
409039
4832
07:05
for taking a life at the age of 21.
124
413895
2662
07:09
From the very beginning,
125
417474
1619
07:11
he's been focused
on being accountable for that act
on being accountable for that act
126
419117
2968
07:14
and doing his best to make amends
from behind bars.
from behind bars.
127
422109
2850
07:18
He brought that work into a design
for a community center
for a community center
128
426458
5921
07:24
for reconciliation and wellness.
129
432403
2133
07:27
It was a beautiful design, right?
130
435449
1676
07:29
So it's this green campus
filled with these circular structures
filled with these circular structures
131
437149
3428
07:32
for victim and offender dialogue.
132
440601
1857
07:35
And when he presented the project to me,
133
443149
2515
07:37
he started crying.
134
445688
1427
07:40
He said, "After being in the brutality
of San Quentin for so long,
of San Quentin for so long,
135
448133
5439
07:45
we don't think reconciliation will happen.
136
453596
2624
07:49
This design is for a place that fulfills
the promise of restorative justice.
the promise of restorative justice.
137
457611
4221
07:55
And it feels closer now."
138
463331
1600
07:58
I know for a fact
139
466720
2936
08:01
that just the visualization of spaces
for restorative justice and healing
for restorative justice and healing
140
469680
4270
08:05
are transformative.
141
473974
1159
08:07
I've seen it in our workshops
over and over again.
over and over again.
142
475157
2523
08:09
But I think we know that just visualizing
these spaces is not enough.
these spaces is not enough.
143
477704
3754
08:13
We have to build them.
144
481482
1671
08:16
And so I started to look
for justice innovators.
for justice innovators.
145
484188
3267
08:20
They are not easy to find.
146
488131
2139
08:22
But I found one.
147
490732
1206
08:24
I found the Center for Court Innovation.
148
492544
2303
08:27
They were bringing Native American
peacemaking practices
peacemaking practices
149
495641
2953
08:30
into a non-Native community
150
498618
1753
08:32
for the very first time
in the United States.
in the United States.
151
500395
2603
08:35
And I approached them, and I said,
152
503022
2039
08:37
"OK, well, as you set up your process,
153
505085
2960
08:40
could I work with the community
to design a peacemaking center?"
to design a peacemaking center?"
154
508069
3794
08:45
And they said yes.
155
513179
1827
08:47
Thank God, because
I had no backup to these guys.
I had no backup to these guys.
156
515030
3333
08:51
And so, in the Near Westside
of Syracuse, New York,
of Syracuse, New York,
157
519466
3698
08:55
we started to run design workshops
with the community
with the community
158
523188
3691
08:58
to both locate and reenvision
an old drug house
an old drug house
159
526903
3301
09:02
to be a peacemaking center.
160
530228
1867
09:04
The Near Westside
Peacemaking Project is complete.
Peacemaking Project is complete.
161
532537
3215
09:07
And they are already running
over 80 circles a year,
over 80 circles a year,
162
535776
2444
09:10
with a very interesting outcome,
163
538244
2181
09:12
and that it is the space itself
164
540449
1669
09:14
that's convincing people
to engage in peacemaking
to engage in peacemaking
165
542142
2405
09:16
for the very first time in their lives.
166
544571
2023
09:19
Isabel and her daughter are some
of those community members.
of those community members.
167
547807
3111
09:22
And they had been referred to peacemaking
168
550942
2667
09:25
to heal their relationship
after a history of family abuse,
after a history of family abuse,
169
553633
3650
09:29
sexual abuse
170
557307
1359
09:30
and other issues that they'd been having
in their own family
in their own family
171
558690
2826
09:33
and the community.
172
561540
1226
09:35
And, you know, Isabel didn't want
to do peacemaking.
to do peacemaking.
173
563133
2627
09:37
She was like, "This is just
like going to court.
like going to court.
174
565784
2285
09:40
What is this peacemaking stuff?"
175
568093
1563
09:41
But when she showed up,
176
569680
2096
09:43
she was stressed, she was anxious.
177
571800
2269
09:46
But when she got in,
she kind of looked around,
she kind of looked around,
178
574093
2588
09:48
and she settled in.
179
576705
1348
09:50
And she turned
to the coordinator and said,
to the coordinator and said,
180
578639
2137
09:53
"I feel comfortable here -- at ease.
181
581446
2880
09:57
It's homey."
182
585410
1170
10:00
Isabel and her daughter
made a decision that day
made a decision that day
183
588720
2247
10:02
to engage and complete
the peacemaking process.
the peacemaking process.
184
590991
2792
10:05
And today, their relationship
is transformed;
is transformed;
185
593807
3008
10:08
they're doing really well
and they're healing.
and they're healing.
186
596839
2199
10:12
So after this project,
I didn't go into a thing
I didn't go into a thing
187
600955
2375
10:15
where I'm going to make a huge
peacemaking center.
peacemaking center.
188
603354
2347
10:17
I did want to have peacemaking
centers in every community.
centers in every community.
189
605725
4297
10:22
But then a new idea emerged.
190
610847
1979
10:25
I was doing a workshop
in Santa Rita Jail in California,
in Santa Rita Jail in California,
191
613744
4453
10:30
and one of our incarcerated
designers, Doug, said,
designers, Doug, said,
192
618221
3745
10:33
"Yeah, you know, repairing the harm,
getting back on my feet, healing --
getting back on my feet, healing --
193
621990
3421
10:37
really important.
194
625435
1316
10:38
But the reality is, Deanna,
when I get home,
when I get home,
195
626775
2444
10:41
I don't have anywhere to go.
196
629243
2421
10:43
I have no job -- who's going to hire me?
197
631688
2230
10:45
I'm just going to end up back here."
198
633942
1744
10:47
And you know what, he's right,
199
635710
1700
10:49
because 60 to 75 percent of those
returning to their communities
returning to their communities
200
637434
4222
10:53
will be unemployed
a year after their release.
a year after their release.
201
641680
3238
10:57
We also know, if you can't meet
your basic economic needs,
your basic economic needs,
202
645315
3627
11:00
you're going to commit crime --
203
648966
1497
11:02
any of us would do that.
204
650487
1356
11:05
So instead of building prisons,
205
653173
3666
11:08
what we could build are spaces
for job training and entrepreneurship.
for job training and entrepreneurship.
206
656863
4611
11:13
These are spaces for what we call
"restorative economics."
"restorative economics."
207
661498
3157
11:17
Located in East Oakland, California,
208
665387
2865
11:20
"Restore Oakland" will be
the country’s first center
the country’s first center
209
668276
2770
11:23
for restorative justice
and restorative economics.
and restorative economics.
210
671070
2594
11:25
(Applause)
211
673688
6040
11:31
So here's what we're going to do.
212
679752
1603
11:33
We're going to gut this building
and turn it into three things.
and turn it into three things.
213
681379
3206
11:36
First, a restaurant called "Colors,"
214
684609
2278
11:38
that will break the racial divide
in the restaurant industry
in the restaurant industry
215
686911
2849
11:41
by training low-wage restaurant workers
216
689784
2000
11:43
to get living-wage jobs in fine dining.
217
691808
1944
11:45
It does not matter if you have
a criminal record or not.
a criminal record or not.
218
693776
2674
11:48
On the second floor,
we have bright, open, airy spaces
we have bright, open, airy spaces
219
696839
3675
11:52
to support a constellation
of activist organizations
of activist organizations
220
700538
3167
11:55
to amplify their cry
of "Healthcare Not Handcuffs,"
of "Healthcare Not Handcuffs,"
221
703729
3435
11:59
and "Housing as a human right."
222
707188
1590
12:01
And third, the county's first
dedicated space for restorative justice,
dedicated space for restorative justice,
223
709276
5492
12:06
filled with nature, color,
texture and spaces of refuge
texture and spaces of refuge
224
714792
3587
12:10
to support the dialogues here.
225
718403
1928
12:12
This project breaks ground
in just two months.
in just two months.
226
720804
2634
12:15
And we have plans to replicate it
227
723820
1602
12:17
in Washington D.C., Detroit,
New York and New Orleans.
New York and New Orleans.
228
725446
3516
12:20
(Applause)
229
728986
5438
12:30
So you've seen two things
we can build instead of prisons.
we can build instead of prisons.
230
738609
3071
12:33
And look, the price point is better.
231
741704
2524
12:36
For one jail, we can build
30 restorative justice centers.
30 restorative justice centers.
232
744252
4600
12:40
(Applause)
233
748876
1480
12:42
That is a better use of your tax dollars.
234
750380
2586
12:45
So I want to build all of these.
235
753982
2133
12:48
But building buildings
is a really heavy lift.
is a really heavy lift.
236
756712
2419
12:51
It takes time.
237
759155
1150
12:53
And what was happening
in the communities that I was serving
in the communities that I was serving
238
761188
2873
12:56
is we were losing people every week
to gun violence and mass incarceration.
to gun violence and mass incarceration.
239
764085
4733
13:01
We needed to serve more people and faster
and keep them out of the system.
and keep them out of the system.
240
769521
4203
13:06
And a new idea emerged from the community,
241
774720
2587
13:09
one that was a lot lighter on its feet.
242
777331
2600
13:12
Instead of building prisons,
we could build villages on wheels.
we could build villages on wheels.
243
780918
3925
13:18
It's called the Pop-Up Resource Village,
244
786640
2579
13:21
and it brings an entire
constellation of resources
constellation of resources
245
789243
2873
13:24
to isolated communities
in the greater San Francisco area,
in the greater San Francisco area,
246
792140
3207
13:27
including mobile medical,
social services and pop-up shops.
social services and pop-up shops.
247
795371
3595
13:32
And so what we're doing now
248
800022
1356
13:33
is we're building this whole village
with the community,
with the community,
249
801402
2762
13:36
starting with transforming municipal buses
into classrooms on wheels
into classrooms on wheels
250
804188
4865
13:41
that bring GED and high school
education across turf lines.
education across turf lines.
251
809077
3905
13:45
(Applause)
252
813006
1151
13:46
We will serve thousands
of more students with this.
of more students with this.
253
814181
2893
13:49
We're creating mobile spaces of refuge
254
817581
2211
13:51
for women released from jail
in the middle of the night,
in the middle of the night,
255
819816
2643
13:54
at their most vulnerable.
256
822483
1317
13:56
Next summer, the village will launch,
and it pops up every single week,
and it pops up every single week,
257
824246
3863
14:00
expanding to more and more
communities as it goes.
communities as it goes.
258
828133
3211
14:04
So look out for it.
259
832077
1278
14:05
(Applause)
260
833379
5008
14:10
So what do we build instead of prisons?
261
838411
2766
14:13
We've looked at three things:
262
841807
1532
14:15
peacemaking centers,
263
843363
1420
14:16
centers for restorative justice
and restorative economics
and restorative economics
264
844807
3405
14:20
and pop-up villages.
265
848236
1333
14:23
But I'm telling you,
I have a list a mile long.
I have a list a mile long.
266
851038
3396
14:27
This is customized housing for youth
transitioning out of foster care.
transitioning out of foster care.
267
855403
3587
14:31
These are reentry centers for women
to reunite with their children.
to reunite with their children.
268
859014
3277
14:34
These are spaces
for survivors of violence.
for survivors of violence.
269
862315
2934
14:37
These are spaces
that address the root causes
that address the root causes
270
865807
3127
14:40
of mass incarceration.
271
868958
1611
14:42
And not a single one of them
is a jail or a prison.
is a jail or a prison.
272
870593
3904
14:48
Activist, philosopher, writer
Cornel West says
Cornel West says
273
876300
4222
14:53
that "Justice is what love
looks like in public."
looks like in public."
274
881363
2571
14:56
So with this in mind,
I ask you one more time
I ask you one more time
275
884871
4420
15:01
to imagine a world without prisons,
276
889315
2698
15:05
and join me in creating all the things
that we could build instead.
that we could build instead.
277
893038
3674
15:09
Thank you.
278
897545
1151
15:10
(Applause)
279
898720
6893
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Deanna Van Buren - Activist, architect, artistDeanna Van Buren is an architect who designs spaces for peacemaking, inside and out.
Why you should listen
After practicing as a corporate architect for 12 years, Deanna Van Buren left her job to become an activist architect, and for the past six years she has been designing restorative justice centers instead of prisons in order to end the age of mass incarceration. She's the co-founder and design director of Designing Justice + Designing Spaces, based in Oakland, California. She's also interested in designing virtual spaces for peacemaking and was the lead architect for The Witness.
Deanna Van Buren | Speaker | TED.com