TED2013
Michael Green: Why we should build wooden skyscrapers
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
1,360,251 views
Building a skyscraper? Forget about steel and concrete, says architect Michael Green, and build it out of … wood. As he details in this intriguing talk, it's not only possible to build safe wooden structures up to 30 stories tall (and, he hopes, higher), it's necessary.
Michael Green - Architect
Michael Green wants to solve architecture’s biggest challenge -- meeting worldwide housing demand without increasing carbon emissions -- by building with carbon-sequestering wood instead of concrete and steel. Full bio
Michael Green wants to solve architecture’s biggest challenge -- meeting worldwide housing demand without increasing carbon emissions -- by building with carbon-sequestering wood instead of concrete and steel. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
This is my grandfather.
0
1342
2820
00:16
And this is my son.
1
4162
2344
00:18
My grandfather taught me to work with wood
2
6506
2228
00:20
when I was a little boy,
3
8734
1634
00:22
and he also taught me the idea that
4
10368
2003
00:24
if you cut down a tree to turn it into something,
5
12371
2909
00:27
honor that tree's life and make it as beautiful
6
15280
2279
00:29
as you possibly can.
7
17559
2150
00:31
My little boy reminded me
8
19709
3512
00:35
that for all the technology and all the toys in the world,
9
23221
2879
00:38
sometimes just a small block of wood,
10
26100
2390
00:40
if you stack it up tall,
11
28490
1831
00:42
actually is an incredibly inspiring thing.
12
30321
4083
00:46
These are my buildings.
13
34404
1837
00:48
I build all around the world
14
36241
1720
00:49
out of our office in Vancouver and New York.
15
37961
2832
00:52
And we build buildings of different sizes and styles
16
40793
2761
00:55
and different materials, depending on where we are.
17
43554
2026
00:57
But wood is the material that I love the most,
18
45580
2283
00:59
and I'm going to tell you the story about wood.
19
47863
1955
01:01
And part of the reason I love it is that every time
20
49818
1996
01:03
people go into my buildings that are wood,
21
51814
2293
01:06
I notice they react completely differently.
22
54107
2746
01:08
I've never seen anybody walk into one of my buildings
23
56853
2500
01:11
and hug a steel or a concrete column,
24
59353
2401
01:13
but I've actually seen that happen in a wood building.
25
61754
2900
01:16
I've actually seen how people touch the wood,
26
64654
2496
01:19
and I think there's a reason for it.
27
67150
2085
01:21
Just like snowflakes, no two pieces of wood
28
69235
2506
01:23
can ever be the same anywhere on Earth.
29
71741
2684
01:26
That's a wonderful thing.
30
74425
1897
01:28
I like to think that wood
31
76322
2536
01:30
gives Mother Nature fingerprints in our buildings.
32
78858
3561
01:34
It's Mother Nature's fingerprints that make
33
82419
2086
01:36
our buildings connect us to nature in the built environment.
34
84505
4646
01:41
Now, I live in Vancouver, near a forest
35
89151
2062
01:43
that grows to 33 stories tall.
36
91213
3077
01:46
Down the coast here in California, the redwood forest
37
94290
2491
01:48
grows to 40 stories tall.
38
96781
3109
01:51
But the buildings that we think about in wood
39
99890
2642
01:54
are only four stories tall in most places on Earth.
40
102532
3105
01:57
Even building codes actually limit the ability for us to build
41
105637
3721
02:01
much taller than four stories in many places,
42
109358
2383
02:03
and that's true here in the United States.
43
111741
1872
02:05
Now there are exceptions,
44
113613
1980
02:07
but there needs to be some exceptions,
45
115593
1548
02:09
and things are going to change, I'm hoping.
46
117141
1971
02:11
And the reason I think that way is that
47
119112
2074
02:13
today half of us live in cities,
48
121186
3124
02:16
and that number is going to grow to 75 percent.
49
124310
3388
02:19
Cities and density mean that our buildings
50
127698
2086
02:21
are going to continue to be big,
51
129784
2445
02:24
and I think there's a role for wood to play in cities.
52
132229
3818
02:28
And I feel that way because three billion people
53
136047
3156
02:31
in the world today, over the next 20 years,
54
139203
2846
02:34
will need a new home.
55
142049
1520
02:35
That's 40 percent of the world that are going to need
56
143569
1699
02:37
a new building built for them in the next 20 years.
57
145268
3934
02:41
Now, one in three people living in cities today
58
149202
2575
02:43
actually live in a slum.
59
151777
1850
02:45
That's one billion people in the world live in slums.
60
153627
3341
02:48
A hundred million people in the world are homeless.
61
156968
4321
02:53
The scale of the challenge for architects
62
161289
2591
02:55
and for society to deal with in building
63
163880
2141
02:58
is to find a solution to house these people.
64
166021
4594
03:02
But the challenge is, as we move to cities,
65
170615
3480
03:06
cities are built in these two materials,
66
174095
2989
03:09
steel and concrete, and they're great materials.
67
177084
3246
03:12
They're the materials of the last century.
68
180330
2102
03:14
But they're also materials with very high energy
69
182432
2589
03:17
and very high greenhouse gas emissions in their process.
70
185021
4319
03:21
Steel represents about three percent
71
189340
2275
03:23
of man's greenhouse gas emissions,
72
191615
2320
03:25
and concrete is over five percent.
73
193935
2601
03:28
So if you think about that, eight percent
74
196536
2614
03:31
of our contribution to greenhouse gases today
75
199150
3417
03:34
comes from those two materials alone.
76
202567
3168
03:37
We don't think about it a lot, and unfortunately,
77
205735
2416
03:40
we actually don't even think about buildings, I think,
78
208151
2302
03:42
as much as we should.
79
210453
1200
03:43
This is a U.S. statistic about the impact of greenhouse gases.
80
211653
3914
03:47
Almost half of our greenhouse gases are related to the building industry,
81
215567
3266
03:50
and if we look at energy, it's the same story.
82
218833
2287
03:53
You'll notice that transportation's sort of second down that list,
83
221120
3100
03:56
but that's the conversation we mostly hear about.
84
224220
2757
03:58
And although a lot of that is about energy,
85
226977
3566
04:02
it's also so much about carbon.
86
230543
2881
04:05
The problem I see is that, ultimately,
87
233424
2983
04:08
the clash of how we solve that problem
88
236407
2307
04:10
of serving those three billion people that need a home,
89
238714
3268
04:13
and climate change, are a head-on collision
90
241982
3472
04:17
about to happen, or already happening.
91
245454
2953
04:20
That challenge means that we have to start thinking in new ways,
92
248407
2711
04:23
and I think wood is going to be part of that solution,
93
251118
2507
04:25
and I'm going to tell you the story of why.
94
253625
1586
04:27
As an architect, wood is the only material,
95
255211
2504
04:29
big material, that I can build with
96
257715
2415
04:32
that's already grown by the power of the sun.
97
260130
2970
04:35
When a tree grows in the forest and gives off oxygen
98
263100
3778
04:38
and soaks up carbon dioxide,
99
266878
2097
04:40
and it dies and it falls to the forest floor,
100
268975
2966
04:43
it gives that carbon dioxide back to the atmosphere or into the ground.
101
271941
4305
04:48
If it burns in a forest fire, it's going to give that carbon
102
276246
2970
04:51
back to the atmosphere as well.
103
279216
2436
04:53
But if you take that wood and you put it into a building
104
281652
3044
04:56
or into a piece of furniture or into that wooden toy,
105
284696
3336
05:00
it actually has an amazing capacity
106
288032
1675
05:01
to store the carbon and provide us with a sequestration.
107
289707
4171
05:05
One cubic meter of wood will store
108
293878
3279
05:09
one tonne of carbon dioxide.
109
297157
2766
05:11
Now our two solutions to climate are obviously
110
299923
2156
05:14
to reduce our emissions and find storage.
111
302079
2595
05:16
Wood is the only major material building material
112
304674
2195
05:18
I can build with that actually does both those two things.
113
306869
3763
05:22
So I believe that we have
114
310632
3101
05:25
an ethic that the Earth grows our food,
115
313733
2552
05:28
and we need to move to an ethic in this century
116
316285
1938
05:30
that the Earth should grow our homes.
117
318223
3006
05:33
Now, how are we going to do that
118
321229
1569
05:34
when we're urbanizing at this rate
119
322798
1290
05:36
and we think about wood buildings only at four stories?
120
324088
2600
05:38
We need to reduce the concrete and steel and we need
121
326688
2419
05:41
to grow bigger, and what we've been working on
122
329107
1825
05:42
is 30-story tall buildings made of wood.
123
330932
4820
05:47
We've been engineering them with an engineer
124
335752
3598
05:51
named Eric Karsh who works with me on it,
125
339350
2450
05:53
and we've been doing this new work because
126
341800
2313
05:56
there are new wood products out there for us to use,
127
344113
2545
05:58
and we call them mass timber panels.
128
346658
2222
06:00
These are panels made with young trees,
129
348880
2323
06:03
small growth trees, small pieces of wood
130
351203
3642
06:06
glued together to make panels that are enormous:
131
354845
2519
06:09
eight feet wide, 64 feet long, and of various thicknesses.
132
357364
4355
06:13
The way I describe this best, I've found, is to say
133
361719
3139
06:16
that we're all used to two-by-four construction
134
364858
2043
06:18
when we think about wood.
135
366901
1007
06:19
That's what people jump to as a conclusion.
136
367908
2539
06:22
Two-by-four construction is sort of like the little
137
370447
1872
06:24
eight-dot bricks of Lego that we all played with as kids,
138
372319
2631
06:26
and you can make all kinds of cool things out of Lego
139
374950
3045
06:29
at that size, and out of two-by-fours.
140
377995
2919
06:32
But do remember when you were a kid,
141
380914
868
06:33
and you kind of sifted through the pile in your basement,
142
381782
1761
06:35
and you found that big 24-dot brick of Lego,
143
383543
3112
06:38
and you were kind of like,
144
386655
835
06:39
"Cool, this is awesome. I can build something really big,
145
387490
2154
06:41
and this is going to be great."
146
389644
1579
06:43
That's the change.
147
391223
1343
06:44
Mass timber panels are those 24-dot bricks.
148
392566
2946
06:47
They're changing the scale of what we can do,
149
395512
1701
06:49
and what we've developed is something we call FFTT,
150
397213
2673
06:51
which is a Creative Commons solution
151
399886
2454
06:54
to building a very flexible system
152
402340
4915
06:59
of building with these large panels where we tilt up
153
407255
2683
07:01
six stories at a time if we want to.
154
409938
3859
07:05
This animation shows you how the building goes together
155
413797
3616
07:09
in a very simple way, but these buildings are available
156
417413
3556
07:12
for architects and engineers now to build on
157
420969
2253
07:15
for different cultures in the world,
158
423222
1321
07:16
different architectural styles and characters.
159
424543
2603
07:19
In order for us to build safely,
160
427146
3220
07:22
we've engineered these buildings, actually,
161
430366
2200
07:24
to work in a Vancouver context,
162
432566
1720
07:26
where we're a high seismic zone,
163
434286
1517
07:27
even at 30 stories tall.
164
435803
3202
07:31
Now obviously, every time I bring this up,
165
439005
1922
07:32
people even, you know, here at the conference, say,
166
440927
1964
07:34
"Are you serious? Thirty stories? How's that going to happen?"
167
442891
2887
07:37
And there's a lot of really good questions that are asked
168
445778
3497
07:41
and important questions that we spent quite a long time
169
449275
1807
07:43
working on the answers to as we put together
170
451082
2379
07:45
our report and the peer reviewed report.
171
453461
2573
07:48
I'm just going to focus on a few of them,
172
456034
1584
07:49
and let's start with fire, because I think fire
173
457618
1509
07:51
is probably the first one that you're all thinking about right now.
174
459127
2699
07:53
Fair enough.
175
461826
1119
07:54
And the way I describe it is this.
176
462945
1693
07:56
If I asked you to take a match and light it
177
464638
2195
07:58
and hold up a log and try to get that log to go on fire,
178
466833
3988
08:02
it doesn't happen, right? We all know that.
179
470821
1799
08:04
But to build a fire, you kind of start with small pieces
180
472620
2773
08:07
of wood and you work your way up,
181
475393
1291
08:08
and eventually you can add the log to the fire,
182
476684
2952
08:11
and when you do add the log to the fire, of course,
183
479636
2331
08:13
it burns, but it burns slowly.
184
481967
2654
08:16
Well, mass timber panels, these new products
185
484621
1850
08:18
that we're using, are much like the log.
186
486471
2517
08:20
It's hard to start them on fire, and when they do,
187
488988
2695
08:23
they actually burn extraordinarily predictably,
188
491683
2617
08:26
and we can use fire science in order to predict
189
494300
2352
08:28
and make these buildings as safe as concrete
190
496652
2064
08:30
and as safe as steel.
191
498716
2644
08:33
The next big issue, deforestation.
192
501360
2765
08:36
Eighteen percent of our contribution
193
504125
2470
08:38
to greenhouse gas emissions worldwide
194
506595
2085
08:40
is the result of deforestation.
195
508680
1404
08:42
The last thing we want to do is cut down trees.
196
510084
3539
08:45
Or, the last thing we want to do is cut down the wrong trees.
197
513623
4197
08:49
There are models for sustainable forestry
198
517820
2942
08:52
that allow us to cut trees properly,
199
520762
2171
08:54
and those are the only trees appropriate
200
522933
1640
08:56
to use for these kinds of systems.
201
524573
1721
08:58
Now I actually think that these ideas
202
526294
2418
09:00
will change the economics of deforestation.
203
528712
3578
09:04
In countries with deforestation issues,
204
532290
2101
09:06
we need to find a way to provide
205
534391
2484
09:08
better value for the forest
206
536875
2466
09:11
and actually encourage people to make money
207
539341
2384
09:13
through very fast growth cycles --
208
541725
1878
09:15
10-, 12-, 15-year-old trees that make these products
209
543603
2971
09:18
and allow us to build at this scale.
210
546574
2399
09:20
We've calculated a 20-story building:
211
548973
2201
09:23
We'll grow enough wood in North America every 13 minutes.
212
551174
3287
09:26
That's how much it takes.
213
554461
2442
09:28
The carbon story here is a really good one.
214
556903
2769
09:31
If we built a 20-story building out of cement and concrete,
215
559672
3602
09:35
the process would result in the manufacturing
216
563274
2473
09:37
of that cement and 1,200 tonnes of carbon dioxide.
217
565747
3965
09:41
If we did it in wood, in this solution,
218
569712
2304
09:44
we'd sequester about 3,100 tonnes,
219
572016
1903
09:45
for a net difference of 4,300 tonnes.
220
573919
2700
09:48
That's the equivalent of about 900 cars
221
576619
2677
09:51
removed from the road in one year.
222
579296
2737
09:54
Think back to that three billion people
223
582033
1732
09:55
that need a new home,
224
583765
1389
09:57
and maybe this is a contributor to reducing.
225
585154
3072
10:00
We're at the beginning of a revolution, I hope,
226
588226
2681
10:02
in the way we build, because this is the first new way
227
590907
2050
10:04
to build a skyscraper in probably 100 years or more.
228
592957
4975
10:09
But the challenge is changing society's perception
229
597932
2523
10:12
of possibility, and it's a huge challenge.
230
600455
1908
10:14
The engineering is, truthfully, the easy part of this.
231
602363
3625
10:17
And the way I describe it is this.
232
605988
2017
10:20
The first skyscraper, technically --
233
608005
2160
10:22
and the definition of a skyscraper is 10 stories tall, believe it or not —
234
610165
2550
10:24
but the first skyscraper was this one in Chicago,
235
612715
2280
10:26
and people were terrified to walk underneath this building.
236
614995
3033
10:30
But only four years after it was built,
237
618028
1940
10:31
Gustave Eiffel was building the Eiffel Tower,
238
619968
2626
10:34
and as he built the Eiffel Tower,
239
622594
1494
10:36
he changed the skylines of the cities of the world,
240
624088
4709
10:40
changed and created a competition
241
628797
3072
10:43
between places like New York City and Chicago,
242
631869
2167
10:46
where developers started building bigger and bigger buildings
243
634036
2791
10:48
and pushing the envelope up higher and higher
244
636827
3467
10:52
with better and better engineering.
245
640294
2100
10:54
We built this model in New York, actually,
246
642394
2034
10:56
as a theoretical model on the campus
247
644428
2787
10:59
of a technical university soon to come,
248
647215
2348
11:01
and the reason we picked this site
249
649563
1851
11:03
to just show you what these buildings may look like,
250
651414
2737
11:06
because the exterior can change.
251
654151
1787
11:07
It's really just the structure that we're talking about.
252
655938
2733
11:10
The reason we picked it is because this is a technical university,
253
658671
2601
11:13
and I believe that wood is the most
254
661272
2408
11:15
technologically advanced material I can build with.
255
663680
3640
11:19
It just happens to be that Mother Nature holds the patent,
256
667320
2801
11:22
and we don't really feel comfortable with it.
257
670121
2691
11:24
But that's the way it should be,
258
672812
1844
11:26
nature's fingerprints in the built environment.
259
674656
3795
11:30
I'm looking for this opportunity
260
678451
1919
11:32
to create an Eiffel Tower moment, we call it.
261
680370
3190
11:35
Buildings are starting to go up around the world.
262
683560
2040
11:37
There's a building in London that's nine stories,
263
685600
1881
11:39
a new building that just finished in Australia
264
687481
2383
11:41
that I believe is 10 or 11.
265
689864
1957
11:43
We're starting to push the height up of these wood buildings,
266
691821
3547
11:47
and we're hoping, and I'm hoping,
267
695368
1805
11:49
that my hometown of Vancouver actually potentially
268
697173
3012
11:52
announces the world's tallest at around 20 stories
269
700185
2670
11:54
in the not-so-distant future.
270
702855
2683
11:57
That Eiffel Tower moment will break the ceiling,
271
705538
2730
12:00
these arbitrary ceilings of height,
272
708268
1668
12:01
and allow wood buildings to join the competition.
273
709936
2715
12:04
And I believe the race is ultimately on.
274
712651
1965
12:06
Thank you.
275
714616
1450
12:08
(Applause)
276
716066
5262
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Green - ArchitectMichael Green wants to solve architecture’s biggest challenge -- meeting worldwide housing demand without increasing carbon emissions -- by building with carbon-sequestering wood instead of concrete and steel.
Why you should listen
Michael Green is calling for rapid systemic change in the way we build. To end the global housing and climate crises, we need to get past innovation-stifling regulations and well-meaning but misguided ideas popularized by mainstream media. His proposal: Forget steel, straw, concrete, shipping containers, and rammed earth. Use wood to erect urban skyscrapers. “When the Eiffel Tower was built, nobody thought it could be done. Now it’s a symbol of Paris,” Green told the Vancouver Sun. “Projects like it really triggered an innovation on how cities were built. Man moves by innovation and [by] aiming for the moon.”
Green, whose projects range from retail boutiques and housing in North America to a sustainable community in Asia, explores the plausibility of tall wood buildings -- the costs, benefits, and engineering challenges -- in an extensive 2012 white paper. The TED Talent Search winner also teaches and mentors at the University of British Columbia’s School of Architecture and Landscape Architecture (SALA).
More profile about the speakerGreen, whose projects range from retail boutiques and housing in North America to a sustainable community in Asia, explores the plausibility of tall wood buildings -- the costs, benefits, and engineering challenges -- in an extensive 2012 white paper. The TED Talent Search winner also teaches and mentors at the University of British Columbia’s School of Architecture and Landscape Architecture (SALA).
Michael Green | Speaker | TED.com