ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Marla Spivak - Bees scholar
Marla Spivak researches bees’ behavior and biology in an effort to preserve this threatened, but ecologically essential, insect.

Why you should listen

Bees pollinate a third of our food supply -- they don’t just make honey! -- but colonies have been disappearing at alarming rates in many parts of the world due to the accumulated effects of parasitic mites, viral and bacterial diseases, and exposure to pesticides and herbicides. Marla Spivak, University of Minnesota professor of entomology and 2010 MacArthur Fellow, tries as much as possible to think like bees in her work to protect them. They’re “highly social and complex” creatures, she says, which fuels her interest and her research.

Spivak has developed a strain of bees, the Minnesota Hygienic line, that can detect when pupae are infected and kick them out of the nest, saving the rest of the hive. Now, Spivak is studying how bees collect propolis, or tree resins, in their hives to keep out dirt and microbes. She is also analyzing how flowers’ decline due to herbicides, pesticides and crop monoculture affect bees’ numbers and diversity. Spivak has been stung by thousands of bees in the course of her work.

More profile about the speaker
Marla Spivak | Speaker | TED.com
TEDGlobal 2013

Marla Spivak: Why bees are disappearing

Filmed:
2,880,033 views

Honeybees have thrived for 50 million years, each colony 40 to 50,000 individuals coordinated in amazing harmony. So why, seven years ago, did colonies start dying en masse? Marla Spivak reveals four reasons which are interacting with tragic consequences. This is not simply a problem because bees pollinate a third of the world's crops. Could this incredible species be holding up a mirror for us?
- Bees scholar
Marla Spivak researches bees’ behavior and biology in an effort to preserve this threatened, but ecologically essential, insect. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
This is our life with bees,
0
883
3980
00:16
and this is our life without bees.
1
4863
3723
00:20
Bees are the most important pollinators
2
8586
2468
00:23
of our fruits and vegetables and flowers
3
11054
2809
00:25
and crops like alfalfa hay that feed our farm animals.
4
13863
3659
00:29
More than one third of the world's crop production
5
17522
2688
00:32
is dependent on bee pollination.
6
20210
2782
00:34
But the ironic thing is that bees are not out there
7
22992
2837
00:37
pollinating our food intentionally.
8
25829
2917
00:40
They're out there because they need to eat.
9
28746
2871
00:43
Bees get all of the protein they need in their diet
10
31617
2719
00:46
from pollen
11
34336
1329
00:47
and all of the carbohydrates they need from nectar.
12
35665
2936
00:50
They're flower-feeders,
13
38601
1765
00:52
and as they move from flower to flower,
14
40366
1934
00:54
basically on a shopping trip at the local floral mart,
15
42300
3471
00:57
they end up providing this valuable pollination service.
16
45771
4455
01:02
In parts of the world where there are no bees,
17
50226
2520
01:04
or where they plant varieties that are not attractive to bees,
18
52746
2906
01:07
people are paid to do the business of pollination by hand.
19
55652
4206
01:11
These people are moving pollen from flower to flower
20
59858
3684
01:15
with a paintbrush.
21
63542
1899
01:17
Now this business of hand pollination
22
65441
2446
01:19
is actually not that uncommon.
23
67887
2086
01:21
Tomato growers often pollinate their tomato flowers
24
69973
3352
01:25
with a hand-held vibrator.
25
73325
2657
01:27
Now this one's the tomato tickler. (Laughter)
26
75982
3944
01:31
Now this is because the pollen within a tomato flower
27
79926
5280
01:37
is held very securely within
28
85206
1780
01:38
the male part of the flower, the anther,
29
86986
2500
01:41
and the only way to release this pollen is to vibrate it.
30
89486
3374
01:44
So bumblebees are one of the few kinds of bees in the world
31
92860
3686
01:48
that are able to hold onto the flower and vibrate it,
32
96546
3123
01:51
and they do this by shaking their flight muscles
33
99669
2592
01:54
at a frequency similar to the musical note C.
34
102261
4552
01:58
So they vibrate the flower, they sonicate it,
35
106813
2586
02:01
and that releases the pollen in this efficient swoosh,
36
109399
3047
02:04
and the pollen gathers all over the fuzzy bee's body,
37
112446
2739
02:07
and she takes it home as food.
38
115185
2497
02:09
Tomato growers now put bumblebee colonies
39
117682
2841
02:12
inside the greenhouse to pollinate the tomatoes
40
120523
2531
02:15
because they get much more efficient pollination
41
123054
2363
02:17
when it's done naturally
42
125417
1495
02:18
and they get better quality tomatoes.
43
126912
3562
02:22
So there's other, maybe more personal reasons,
44
130474
3587
02:26
to care about bees.
45
134061
1423
02:27
There's over 20,000 species of bees in the world,
46
135484
4172
02:31
and they're absolutely gorgeous.
47
139656
3006
02:34
These bees spend the majority of their life cycle
48
142662
2619
02:37
hidden in the ground or within a hollow stem
49
145281
2820
02:40
and very few of these beautiful species
50
148101
2700
02:42
have evolved highly social behavior like honeybees.
51
150801
3433
02:46
Now honeybees tend to be the charismatic representative
52
154234
3620
02:49
for the other 19,900-plus species
53
157854
3169
02:53
because there's something about honeybees
54
161023
2641
02:55
that draws people into their world.
55
163664
2849
02:58
Humans have been drawn to honeybees
56
166513
2447
03:00
since early recorded history,
57
168960
1716
03:02
mostly to harvest their honey,
58
170676
1476
03:04
which is an amazing natural sweetener.
59
172152
3459
03:07
I got drawn into the honeybee world
60
175611
1788
03:09
completely by a fluke.
61
177399
2085
03:11
I was 18 years old and bored,
62
179484
2322
03:13
and I picked up a book in the library on bees
63
181806
2862
03:16
and I spent the night reading it.
64
184668
2242
03:18
I had never thought about insects
65
186910
1927
03:20
living in complex societies.
66
188837
1723
03:22
It was like the best of science fiction come true.
67
190560
3402
03:25
And even stranger, there were these people,
68
193962
2894
03:28
these beekeepers, that loved their bees like they were family,
69
196856
3991
03:32
and when I put down the book, I knew I had to see this for myself.
70
200847
3303
03:36
So I went to work for a commercial beekeeper,
71
204150
2485
03:38
a family that owned 2,000 hives of bees in New Mexico.
72
206635
4197
03:42
And I was permanently hooked.
73
210832
3407
03:46
Honeybees can be considered a super-organism,
74
214239
3314
03:49
where the colony is the organism
75
217553
2156
03:51
and it's comprised of 40,000 to 50,000
76
219709
2732
03:54
individual bee organisms.
77
222441
2928
03:57
Now this society has no central authority.
78
225369
3332
04:00
Nobody's in charge.
79
228701
1596
04:02
So how they come to collective decisions,
80
230297
2345
04:04
and how they allocate their tasks and divide their labor,
81
232642
2980
04:07
how they communicate where the flowers are,
82
235622
2482
04:10
all of their collective social behaviors are mindblowing.
83
238104
4164
04:14
My personal favorite, and one that I've studied for many years,
84
242268
3768
04:18
is their system of healthcare.
85
246036
1945
04:19
So bees have social healthcare.
86
247981
3485
04:23
So in my lab, we study how bees keep themselves healthy.
87
251466
4270
04:27
For example, we study hygiene,
88
255736
2339
04:30
where some bees are able to locate and weed out
89
258075
2886
04:32
sick individuals from the nest, from the colony,
90
260961
3167
04:36
and it keeps the colony healthy.
91
264128
2464
04:38
And more recently, we've been studying resins
92
266592
3427
04:42
that bees collect from plants.
93
270019
2109
04:44
So bees fly to some plants and they scrape
94
272128
3183
04:47
these very, very sticky resins off the leaves,
95
275311
2656
04:49
and they take them back to the nest
96
277967
1578
04:51
where they cement them into the nest architecture
97
279545
2866
04:54
where we call it propolis.
98
282411
2525
04:56
We've found that propolis is a natural disinfectant.
99
284936
4622
05:01
It's a natural antibiotic.
100
289558
1944
05:03
It kills off bacteria and molds and other germs
101
291502
3179
05:06
within the colony,
102
294681
1602
05:08
and so it bolsters the colony health and their social immunity.
103
296283
3963
05:12
Humans have known about the power of propolis
104
300246
3291
05:15
since biblical times.
105
303537
1647
05:17
We've been harvesting propolis out of bee colonies
106
305184
3350
05:20
for human medicine,
107
308534
2052
05:22
but we didn't know how good it was for the bees.
108
310586
3664
05:26
So honeybees have these remarkable natural defenses
109
314250
4053
05:30
that have kept them healthy and thriving
110
318303
2689
05:32
for over 50 million years.
111
320992
4257
05:37
So seven years ago, when honeybee colonies
112
325249
3349
05:40
were reported to be dying en masse,
113
328598
1799
05:42
first in the United States,
114
330397
1972
05:44
it was clear that there was something really, really wrong.
115
332369
3813
05:48
In our collective conscience, in a really primal way,
116
336182
3486
05:51
we know we can't afford to lose bees.
117
339668
3186
05:54
So what's going on?
118
342854
3115
05:57
Bees are dying from multiple and interacting causes,
119
345969
4089
06:02
and I'll go through each of these.
120
350058
2482
06:04
The bottom line is,
121
352540
1853
06:06
bees dying reflects a flowerless landscape
122
354393
4052
06:10
and a dysfunctional food system.
123
358445
3489
06:13
Now we have the best data on honeybees,
124
361934
1992
06:15
so I'll use them as an example.
125
363926
1856
06:17
In the United States, bees in fact have been
126
365782
3493
06:21
in decline since World War II.
127
369275
2864
06:24
We have half the number of managed hives
128
372139
2274
06:26
in the United States now compared to 1945.
129
374413
3014
06:29
We're down to about two million hives of bees, we think.
130
377427
3651
06:33
And the reason is, after World War II,
131
381078
2746
06:35
we changed our farming practices.
132
383824
3328
06:39
We stopped planting cover crops.
133
387152
2839
06:41
We stopped planting clover and alfalfa,
134
389991
2743
06:44
which are natural fertilizers that fix nitrogen in the soil,
135
392734
3846
06:48
and instead we started using synthetic fertilizers.
136
396580
3604
06:52
Clover and alfalfa are highly nutritious food plants for bees.
137
400184
5544
06:57
And after World War II, we started using herbicides
138
405728
3454
07:01
to kill off the weeds in our farms.
139
409182
2497
07:03
Many of these weeds are flowering plants
140
411679
2781
07:06
that bees require for their survival.
141
414460
2933
07:09
And we started growing larger and larger crop monocultures.
142
417393
5571
07:14
Now we talk about food deserts,
143
422964
2565
07:17
places in our cities, neighborhoods that have no grocery stores.
144
425529
4250
07:21
The very farms that used to sustain bees
145
429779
4043
07:25
are now agricultural food deserts,
146
433822
2756
07:28
dominated by one or two plant species
147
436578
2423
07:31
like corn and soybeans.
148
439001
2589
07:33
Since World War II, we have been systematically
149
441590
2905
07:36
eliminating many of the flowering plants
150
444495
2899
07:39
that bees need for their survival.
151
447394
3552
07:42
And these monocultures extend even to crops
152
450946
2898
07:45
that are good for bees, like almonds.
153
453844
2547
07:48
Fifty years ago, beekeepers would take a few colonies,
154
456391
3986
07:52
hives of bees into the almond orchards, for pollination,
155
460377
3011
07:55
and also because the pollen in an almond blossom
156
463388
3932
07:59
is really high in protein. It's really good for bees.
157
467320
4180
08:03
Now, the scale of almond monoculture
158
471500
3997
08:07
demands that most of our nation's bees,
159
475497
2552
08:10
over 1.5 million hives of bees,
160
478049
2736
08:12
be transported across the nation
161
480785
2992
08:15
to pollinate this one crop.
162
483777
2351
08:18
And they're trucked in in semi-loads,
163
486128
2645
08:20
and they must be trucked out,
164
488773
2330
08:23
because after bloom, the almond orchards
165
491103
2739
08:25
are a vast and flowerless landscape.
166
493842
5210
08:31
Bees have been dying over the last 50 years,
167
499052
2466
08:33
and we're planting more crops that need them.
168
501518
3805
08:37
There has been a 300 percent increase in crop production
169
505323
4184
08:41
that requires bee pollination.
170
509507
3804
08:45
And then there's pesticides.
171
513311
3026
08:48
After World War II, we started using pesticides
172
516337
3344
08:51
on a large scale, and this became necessary
173
519681
2564
08:54
because of the monocultures that put out a feast
174
522245
3794
08:58
for crop pests.
175
526039
2293
09:00
Recently, researchers from Penn State University
176
528332
2941
09:03
have started looking at the pesticide residue
177
531273
3297
09:06
in the loads of pollen that bees carry home as food,
178
534570
3550
09:10
and they've found that every batch of pollen
179
538120
3591
09:13
that a honeybee collects
180
541711
2007
09:15
has at least six detectable pesticides in it,
181
543718
3787
09:19
and this includes every class of insecticides,
182
547505
4043
09:23
herbicides, fungicides,
183
551548
2843
09:26
and even inert and unlabeled ingredients
184
554391
3580
09:29
that are part of the pesticide formulation
185
557971
2572
09:32
that can be more toxic than the active ingredient.
186
560543
4222
09:36
This small bee is holding up a large mirror.
187
564765
5642
09:42
How much is it going to take to contaminate humans?
188
570407
4448
09:46
One of these class of insecticides,
189
574855
2980
09:49
the neonicontinoids,
190
577835
1375
09:51
is making headlines around the world right now.
191
579210
2260
09:53
You've probably heard about it.
192
581470
1446
09:54
This is a new class of insecticides.
193
582916
2058
09:56
It moves through the plant so that a crop pest,
194
584974
3159
10:00
a leaf-eating insect,
195
588133
1443
10:01
would take a bite of the plant
196
589576
1234
10:02
and get a lethal dose and die.
197
590810
3340
10:06
If one of these neonics, we call them,
198
594150
2823
10:08
is applied in a high concentration,
199
596973
2454
10:11
such as in this ground application,
200
599427
2262
10:13
enough of the compound moves through the plant
201
601689
2468
10:16
and gets into the pollen and the nectar,
202
604157
2212
10:18
where a bee can consume, in this case,
203
606369
2104
10:20
a high dose of this neurotoxin
204
608473
3018
10:23
that makes the bee twitch and die.
205
611491
4149
10:27
In most agricultural settings, on most of our farms,
206
615640
3173
10:30
it's only the seed that's coated with the insecticide,
207
618813
3943
10:34
and so a smaller concentration moves through the plant
208
622756
2991
10:37
and gets into the pollen and nectar,
209
625747
1968
10:39
and if a bee consumes this lower dose,
210
627715
2543
10:42
either nothing happens
211
630258
1342
10:43
or the bee becomes intoxicated and disoriented
212
631600
3588
10:47
and she may not find her way home.
213
635188
3712
10:50
And on top of everything else, bees have
214
638900
2132
10:53
their own set of diseases and parasites.
215
641032
2268
10:55
Public enemy number one for bees is this thing.
216
643300
2860
10:58
It's called varroa destructor.
217
646160
2305
11:00
It's aptly named.
218
648465
1104
11:01
It's this big, blood-sucking parasite
219
649569
2612
11:04
that compromises the bee's immune system
220
652181
2374
11:06
and circulates viruses.
221
654555
2771
11:09
Let me put this all together for you.
222
657326
2929
11:12
I don't know what it feels like to a bee
223
660255
2667
11:14
to have a big, bloodsucking parasite running around on it,
224
662922
2701
11:17
and I don't know what it feels like to a bee to have a virus,
225
665623
3139
11:20
but I do know what it feels like when I have a virus, the flu,
226
668762
5128
11:25
and I know how difficult it is for me to get
227
673890
3232
11:29
to the grocery store to get good nutrition.
228
677122
2789
11:31
But what if I lived in a food desert?
229
679911
3046
11:34
And what if I had to travel a long distance
230
682957
2495
11:37
to get to the grocery store,
231
685452
1873
11:39
and I finally got my weak body out there
232
687325
2874
11:42
and I consumed, in my food,
233
690199
2144
11:44
enough of a pesticide, a neurotoxin,
234
692343
2801
11:47
that I couldn't find my way home?
235
695144
2756
11:49
And this is what we mean by multiple
236
697900
3187
11:53
and interacting causes of death.
237
701087
3703
11:56
And it's not just our honeybees.
238
704790
2189
11:58
All of our beautiful wild species of bees
239
706979
2875
12:01
are at risk, including those tomato-pollinating bumblebees.
240
709854
4171
12:06
These bees are providing backup for our honeybees.
241
714025
3551
12:09
They're providing the pollination insurance
242
717576
2050
12:11
alongside our honeybees.
243
719626
1618
12:13
We need all of our bees.
244
721244
2423
12:15
So what are we going to do?
245
723667
2541
12:18
What are we going to do about this big bee bummer
246
726208
2414
12:20
that we've created?
247
728622
2263
12:22
It turns out, it's hopeful. It's hopeful.
248
730885
3817
12:26
Every one of you out there can help bees
249
734702
3583
12:30
in two very direct and easy ways.
250
738285
4465
12:34
Plant bee-friendly flowers,
251
742750
2955
12:37
and don't contaminate these flowers,
252
745705
2133
12:39
this bee food, with pesticides.
253
747838
2662
12:42
So go online and search for flowers
254
750500
3334
12:45
that are native to your area and plant them.
255
753834
3412
12:49
Plant them in a pot on your doorstep.
256
757246
2123
12:51
Plant them in your front yard, in your lawns,
257
759369
2574
12:53
in your boulevards.
258
761943
1530
12:55
Campaign to have them planted in public gardens,
259
763473
3613
12:59
community spaces, meadows.
260
767086
2581
13:01
Set aside farmland.
261
769667
1749
13:03
We need a beautiful diversity of flowers
262
771416
2700
13:06
that blooms over the entire growing season,
263
774116
2171
13:08
from spring to fall.
264
776287
1894
13:10
We need roadsides seeded in flowers for our bees,
265
778181
3698
13:13
but also for migrating butterflies and birds
266
781879
3454
13:17
and other wildlife.
267
785333
1976
13:19
And we need to think carefully about putting back in
268
787309
3440
13:22
cover crops to nourish our soil
269
790749
3185
13:25
and nourish our bees.
270
793934
3021
13:28
And we need to diversify our farms.
271
796955
3263
13:32
We need to plant flowering crop borders and hedge rows
272
800218
3782
13:36
to disrupt the agricultural food desert
273
804000
3856
13:39
and begin to correct the dysfunctional food system
274
807856
3290
13:43
that we've created.
275
811146
2231
13:45
So maybe it seems like a really small countermeasure
276
813377
3384
13:48
to a big, huge problem -- just go plant flowers --
277
816761
3018
13:51
but when bees have access to good nutrition,
278
819779
3028
13:54
we have access to good nutrition
279
822807
2186
13:56
through their pollination services.
280
824993
2415
13:59
And when bees have access to good nutrition,
281
827408
2536
14:01
they're better able to engage their own natural defenses,
282
829944
3599
14:05
their healthcare,
283
833543
1418
14:06
that they have relied on for millions of years.
284
834961
4098
14:11
So the beauty of helping bees this way, for me,
285
839059
4849
14:15
is that every one of us needs to behave
286
843908
4450
14:20
a little bit more like a bee society, an insect society,
287
848358
4780
14:25
where each of our individual actions
288
853138
3032
14:28
can contribute to a grand solution,
289
856170
3106
14:31
an emergent property,
290
859276
1687
14:32
that's much greater than the mere sum
291
860963
1981
14:34
of our individual actions.
292
862944
2745
14:37
So let the small act of planting flowers
293
865689
5150
14:42
and keeping them free of pesticides
294
870839
3327
14:46
be the driver of large-scale change.
295
874166
4215
14:50
On behalf of the bees, thank you.
296
878381
3036
14:53
(Applause)
297
881417
4123
14:57
Chris Anderson: Thank you. Just a quick question.
298
885540
3968
15:01
The latest numbers on the die-off of bees,
299
889508
3156
15:04
is there any sign of things bottoming out?
300
892664
2228
15:06
What's your hope/depression level on this?
301
894892
2779
15:09
Maria Spivak: Yeah.
302
897671
614
15:10
At least in the United States,
303
898285
1953
15:12
an average of 30 percent of all bee hives
304
900238
2352
15:14
are lost every winter.
305
902590
2127
15:16
About 20 years ago,
306
904717
1805
15:18
we were at a 15-percent loss.
307
906522
2336
15:20
So it's getting precarious.
308
908858
2121
15:22
CA: That's not 30 percent a year, that's --
MS: Yes, thirty percent a year.
309
910979
2607
15:25
CA: Thirty percent a year.
MS: But then beekeepers are able to divide their colonies
310
913586
3554
15:29
and so they can maintain the same number,
311
917140
2650
15:31
they can recuperate some of their loss.
312
919790
2321
15:34
We're kind of at a tipping point.
313
922111
1618
15:35
We can't really afford to lose that many more.
314
923729
2869
15:38
We need to be really appreciative
315
926598
1820
15:40
of all the beekeepers out there. Plant flowers.
316
928418
3353
15:43
CA: Thank you.
317
931771
1150
15:44
(Applause)
318
932921
5370

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Marla Spivak - Bees scholar
Marla Spivak researches bees’ behavior and biology in an effort to preserve this threatened, but ecologically essential, insect.

Why you should listen

Bees pollinate a third of our food supply -- they don’t just make honey! -- but colonies have been disappearing at alarming rates in many parts of the world due to the accumulated effects of parasitic mites, viral and bacterial diseases, and exposure to pesticides and herbicides. Marla Spivak, University of Minnesota professor of entomology and 2010 MacArthur Fellow, tries as much as possible to think like bees in her work to protect them. They’re “highly social and complex” creatures, she says, which fuels her interest and her research.

Spivak has developed a strain of bees, the Minnesota Hygienic line, that can detect when pupae are infected and kick them out of the nest, saving the rest of the hive. Now, Spivak is studying how bees collect propolis, or tree resins, in their hives to keep out dirt and microbes. She is also analyzing how flowers’ decline due to herbicides, pesticides and crop monoculture affect bees’ numbers and diversity. Spivak has been stung by thousands of bees in the course of her work.

More profile about the speaker
Marla Spivak | Speaker | TED.com