TEDxLeuvenSalon
Tristram Wyatt: The smelly mystery of the human pheromone
Filmed:
Readability: 4
1,414,757 views
Do our smells make us sexy? Popular science suggests yes — pheromones send chemical signals about sex and attraction from our armpits to potential mates. But, despite what you might have heard, there is no conclusive research confirming that humans have these smell molecules. In this eye-opening talk, zoologist Tristram Wyatt explains the fundamental flaws in current pheromone research, and shares his hope for a future that unlocks the fascinating, potentially life-saving knowledge tied up in our scent.
Tristram Wyatt - Zoologist
Do humans have pheromones? Tristram Wyatt is on the case. A researcher at Oxford, Wyatt is interested in the evolution of pheromones throughout the animal kingdom. Full bio
Do humans have pheromones? Tristram Wyatt is on the case. A researcher at Oxford, Wyatt is interested in the evolution of pheromones throughout the animal kingdom. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
"Pheromone" is a very powerful word.
0
880
3438
00:16
It conjures up sex, abandon, loss of control,
1
4318
4144
00:20
and you can see, it's very important as a word.
2
8462
3692
00:24
But it's only 50 years old. It was invented in 1959.
3
12154
5283
00:29
Now, if you put that word into the web,
4
17437
2549
00:31
as you may have done,
5
19986
1510
00:33
you'll come up with millions of hits,
6
21496
2392
00:35
and almost all of those sites are trying to sell you
7
23888
2645
00:38
something to make you irresistible
8
26533
2259
00:40
for 10 dollars or more.
9
28792
3073
00:43
Now, this is a very attractive idea,
10
31865
2223
00:46
and the molecules they mention
11
34088
2442
00:48
sound really science-y.
12
36530
1914
00:50
They've got lots of syllables.
13
38444
1584
00:52
It's things like androstenol, androstenone
14
40028
2873
00:54
or androstadienone.
15
42901
2441
00:57
It gets better and better,
16
45342
1642
00:58
and when you combine that with white lab coats,
17
46984
2790
01:01
you must imagine that there is
18
49774
1412
01:03
fantastic science behind this.
19
51186
2514
01:05
But sadly, these are fraudulent claims
20
53700
5122
01:10
supported by dodgy science.
21
58822
3339
01:14
The problem is that, although there are many
22
62161
2618
01:16
good scientists working on what they think
23
64779
2545
01:19
are human pheromones,
24
67324
1870
01:21
and they're publishing in respectable journals,
25
69194
2605
01:23
at the basis of this,
26
71799
1581
01:25
despite very sophisticated experiments,
27
73380
3336
01:28
there really is no good science behind it,
28
76716
2553
01:31
because it's based on a problem,
29
79269
3292
01:34
which is nobody has systematically gone through
30
82561
3450
01:38
all the odors that humans produce --
31
86011
2101
01:40
and there are thousands of
molecules that we give off.
molecules that we give off.
32
88112
2778
01:42
We're mammals. We produce a lot of smell.
33
90890
3110
01:46
Nobody has gone through systematically
34
94000
2144
01:48
to work out which molecules really are pheromones.
35
96144
2767
01:50
They've just plucked a few,
36
98911
1630
01:52
and all these experiments are based on those,
37
100541
1889
01:54
but there's no good evidence at all.
38
102430
3010
01:57
Now, that's not to say
39
105440
2178
01:59
that smell is not important to people.
40
107618
2162
02:01
It is, and some people are real enthusiasts,
41
109780
3502
02:05
and one of these was Napoleon.
42
113282
3497
02:08
And famously, you may remember
43
116779
1792
02:10
that out on the campaign trail for war,
44
118571
3097
02:13
he wrote to his lover, Empress Josephine,
45
121668
2807
02:16
saying, "Don't wash. I'm coming home."
46
124475
3234
02:19
(Laughter)
47
127709
602
02:20
So he didn't want to lose any of her richness
48
128311
2921
02:23
in the days before he'd get home,
49
131232
2349
02:25
and it is still, you'll find websites
50
133581
2377
02:27
that offer this as a major quirk.
51
135958
3902
02:31
At the same time, though,
52
139860
1164
02:33
we spend about as much money
53
141024
2453
02:35
taking the smells off us
54
143477
1771
02:37
as putting them back on in perfumes,
55
145248
2721
02:39
and perfumes are a multi-billion-dollar business.
56
147969
4191
02:44
So what I want to do in the rest of this talk
57
152160
2403
02:46
is tell you about what pheromones really are,
58
154563
5278
02:51
tell you why I think we would expect
59
159841
2998
02:54
humans to have pheromones,
60
162839
2748
02:57
tell you about some of the
confusions in pheromones,
confusions in pheromones,
61
165587
4493
03:02
and then finally, I want to end with
62
170080
2792
03:04
a promising avenue which shows us
63
172872
1970
03:06
the way we ought to be going.
64
174842
4148
03:10
So the ancient Greeks knew
65
178990
4181
03:15
that dogs sent invisible signals between each other.
66
183171
4054
03:19
A female dog in heat
67
187225
2374
03:21
sent an invisible signal to male dogs
68
189599
1916
03:23
for miles around,
69
191515
1455
03:24
and it wasn't a sound, it was a smell.
70
192970
2105
03:27
You could take the smell from the female dog,
71
195075
2181
03:29
and the dogs would chase the cloth.
72
197256
2463
03:31
But the problem for everybody
73
199719
1608
03:33
who could see this effect
74
201327
2113
03:35
was that you couldn't identify the molecules.
75
203440
1622
03:37
You couldn't demonstrate it was chemical.
76
205062
2453
03:39
The reason for that, of course,
77
207515
1315
03:40
is that each of these animals
78
208830
1415
03:42
produces tiny quantities,
79
210245
1606
03:43
and in the case of the dog,
80
211851
1659
03:45
males dogs can smell it, but we can't smell it.
81
213510
2902
03:48
And it was only in 1959 that a German team,
82
216412
4358
03:52
after spending 20 years in
search of these molecules,
search of these molecules,
83
220770
3352
03:56
discovered, identified, the first pheromone,
84
224122
3781
03:59
and this was the sex pheromone of a silk moth.
85
227903
3278
04:03
Now, this was an inspired choice
by Adolf Butenandt and his team,
by Adolf Butenandt and his team,
86
231181
3674
04:06
because he needed half a million moths
87
234855
2126
04:08
to get enough material to do the chemical analysis.
88
236981
3027
04:12
But he created the model
89
240008
2089
04:14
for how you should go about pheromone analysis.
90
242097
2364
04:16
He basically went through systematically,
91
244461
2681
04:19
showing that only the molecule in question
92
247142
2945
04:22
was the one that stimulated the males,
93
250087
1866
04:23
not all the others.
94
251953
2053
04:26
He analyzed it very carefully.
95
254006
2158
04:28
He synthesized the molecule,
96
256164
1817
04:29
and then tried the synthesized
molecule on the males
molecule on the males
97
257981
3308
04:33
and got them to respond and showed it was,
98
261289
2861
04:36
indeed, that molecule.
99
264150
1760
04:37
That's closing the circle.
100
265910
2150
04:40
That's the thing which has
never been done with humans:
never been done with humans:
101
268060
2705
04:42
nothing systematic, no real demonstration.
102
270765
3610
04:46
With that new concept,
103
274375
1734
04:48
we needed a new word,
104
276109
1709
04:49
and that was the word "pheromone,"
105
277818
2835
04:52
and it's basically transferred excitement,
106
280653
3601
04:56
transferred between individuals,
107
284254
2269
04:58
and since 1959, pheromones have been found
108
286523
2826
05:01
right the way across the animal kingdom,
109
289349
1875
05:03
in male animals, in female animals.
110
291224
2202
05:05
It works just as well underwater
111
293426
1545
05:06
for goldfish and lobsters.
112
294971
2022
05:08
And almost every mammal you can think of
113
296993
1747
05:10
has had a pheromone identified,
114
298740
1823
05:12
and of course, an enormous number of insects.
115
300563
3830
05:16
So we know that pheromones exist
116
304393
1969
05:18
right the way across the animal kingdom.
117
306362
3061
05:21
What about humans?
118
309423
1773
05:23
Well, the first thing, of course,
119
311196
1248
05:24
is that we're mammals,
120
312444
1657
05:26
and mammals are smelly.
121
314101
1559
05:27
As any dog owner can tell you,
122
315660
1876
05:29
we smell, they smell.
123
317536
1981
05:31
But the real reason we might think
124
319517
1981
05:33
that humans have pheromones
125
321498
1825
05:35
is the change that occurs as we grow up.
126
323323
3218
05:38
The smell of a room of teenagers
127
326541
2451
05:40
is quite different
128
328992
1489
05:42
from the smell of a room of small children.
129
330481
2820
05:45
What's changed? And of course, it's puberty.
130
333301
2872
05:48
Along with the pubic hair
131
336173
1459
05:49
and the hair in the armpits,
132
337632
1693
05:51
new glands start to secrete in those places,
133
339325
3742
05:55
and that's what's making the change in smell.
134
343067
2615
05:57
If we were any other kind of mammal,
135
345682
2148
05:59
or any other kind of animal,
136
347830
1189
06:01
we would say,
137
349019
1137
06:02
"That must be something to do with pheromones,"
138
350156
1872
06:04
and we'd start looking properly.
139
352028
2656
06:06
But there are some problems, and this is why,
140
354684
1976
06:08
I think, people have not looked for
141
356660
3069
06:11
pheromones so effectively in humans.
142
359729
2917
06:14
There are, indeed, problems.
143
362646
1571
06:16
And the first of these
144
364217
2184
06:18
is perhaps surprising.
145
366401
1517
06:19
It's all about culture.
146
367918
1834
06:21
Now moths don't learn a lot
147
369752
2147
06:23
about what is good to smell, but humans do,
148
371899
3617
06:27
and up to the age of about four,
149
375516
1846
06:29
any smell, no matter how rancid,
150
377362
2719
06:32
is simply interesting.
151
380081
1799
06:33
And I understand that the major role of parents
152
381880
2052
06:35
is to stop kids putting their fingers in poo,
153
383932
3681
06:39
because it's always something nice to smell.
154
387613
2798
06:42
But gradually we learn what's not good,
155
390411
2691
06:45
and one of the things we learn
156
393102
1490
06:46
at the same time as what is not good
157
394592
2135
06:48
is what is good.
158
396727
1758
06:50
Now, the cheese behind me
159
398485
2262
06:52
is a British, if not an English, delicacy.
160
400747
3951
06:56
It's ripe blue Stilton.
161
404698
3437
07:00
Liking it is incomprehensible to
people from other countries.
people from other countries.
162
408135
4362
07:04
Every culture has its own special food
163
412497
3285
07:07
and national delicacy.
164
415782
2096
07:09
If you were to come from Iceland,
165
417878
2052
07:11
your national dish
166
419930
1324
07:13
is deep rotted shark.
167
421254
2976
07:16
Now, all of these things are acquired tastes,
168
424230
2130
07:18
but they form almost a badge of identity.
169
426360
3160
07:21
You're part of the in-group.
170
429520
4820
07:26
The second thing is the sense of smell.
171
434340
3582
07:29
Each of us has a unique odor world,
172
437922
3469
07:33
in the sense that what we smell,
173
441391
2539
07:35
we each smell a completely different world.
174
443930
2859
07:38
Now, smell was the hardest
175
446789
1709
07:40
of the senses to crack,
176
448498
1861
07:42
and the Nobel Prize awarded to
177
450359
1715
07:44
Richard Axel and Linda Buck
178
452074
1633
07:45
was only awarded in 2004
179
453707
2433
07:48
for their discovery of how smell works.
180
456140
2790
07:50
It's really hard,
181
458930
1377
07:52
but in essence, nerves from the brain
182
460307
2591
07:54
go up into the nose
183
462898
2213
07:57
and on these nerves exposed in the nose
184
465111
2381
07:59
to the outside air are receptors,
185
467492
3054
08:02
and odor molecules coming in on a sniff
186
470546
3149
08:05
interact with these receptors,
187
473695
2150
08:07
and if they bond, they send the nerve a signal
188
475845
4259
08:12
which goes back into the brain.
189
480104
2308
08:14
We don't just have one kind of receptor.
190
482412
2062
08:16
If you're a human, you have about 400
191
484474
1876
08:18
different kinds of receptors,
192
486350
2065
08:20
and the brain knows what you're smelling
193
488415
2967
08:23
because of the combination of receptors
194
491382
1811
08:25
and nerve cells that they trigger,
195
493193
2513
08:27
sending messages up to the brain
196
495706
1558
08:29
in a combinatorial fashion.
197
497264
2906
08:32
But it's a bit more complicated,
198
500170
990
08:33
because each of those 400
199
501160
2135
08:35
comes in various variants,
200
503295
2151
08:37
and depending which variant you have,
201
505446
2071
08:39
you might smell coriander, or cilantro, that herb,
202
507517
4182
08:43
either as something delicious and savory
203
511699
2618
08:46
or something like soap.
204
514317
2174
08:48
So we each have an individual world of smell,
205
516491
2686
08:51
and that complicates anything
206
519177
1641
08:52
when we're studying smell.
207
520818
2296
08:55
Well, we really ought to talk about armpits,
208
523114
2692
08:57
and I have to say that I do
have particularly good ones.
have particularly good ones.
209
525806
3396
09:01
Now, I'm not going to share them with you,
210
529202
2002
09:03
but this is the place that most people
211
531204
1979
09:05
have looked for pheromones.
212
533183
1737
09:06
There is one good reason,
213
534920
1503
09:08
which is, the great apes have armpits
214
536423
3404
09:11
as their unique characteristic.
215
539827
2328
09:14
The other primates have scent glands
216
542155
2401
09:16
in other parts of the body.
217
544556
1830
09:18
The great apes have these armpits
218
546386
2354
09:20
full of secretory glands
219
548740
2217
09:22
producing smells all the time,
220
550957
2341
09:25
enormous numbers of molecules.
221
553298
3700
09:28
When they're secreted from the glands,
222
556998
1703
09:30
the molecules are odorless.
223
558701
2004
09:32
They have no smell at all,
224
560705
2075
09:34
and it's only the wonderful bacteria
225
562780
1969
09:36
growing on the rainforest of hair
226
564749
2213
09:38
that actually produces the smells
227
566962
1456
09:40
that we know and love.
228
568418
2021
09:42
And so incidentally, if you want to reduce
229
570439
1900
09:44
the amount of smell,
230
572339
1430
09:45
clear-cutting your armpits
231
573769
1920
09:47
is a very effective way of reducing
232
575689
2256
09:49
the habitat for bacteria,
233
577945
1514
09:51
and you'll find they remain less smelly
234
579459
2337
09:53
for much longer.
235
581796
2094
09:55
But although we've focused on armpits,
236
583890
2546
09:58
I think it's partly because they're the least
237
586436
1367
09:59
embarrassing place to go and ask people for samples.
238
587803
3967
10:03
There is actually another reason why we might not
239
591770
2612
10:06
be looking for a universal sex pheromone there,
240
594382
2776
10:09
and that's because 20 percent
of the world's population
of the world's population
241
597158
3839
10:12
doesn't have smelly armpits like me.
242
600997
3445
10:16
And these are people from China, Japan,
243
604442
3916
10:20
Korea, and other parts of northeast Asia.
244
608358
2595
10:22
They simply don't secrete those odorless precursors
245
610953
3524
10:26
that the bacteria love to use to produce the smells
246
614477
4253
10:30
that in an ethnocentric way we always thought of
247
618730
2349
10:33
as characteristic of armpits.
248
621079
2105
10:35
So it doesn't apply to 20 percent of the world.
249
623184
4507
10:39
So what should we be doing
250
627691
3002
10:42
in our search for human pheromones?
251
630693
3053
10:45
I'm fairly convinced that we do have them.
252
633746
2452
10:48
We're mammals, like everybody else
253
636198
1953
10:50
who's a mammal, and we probably do have them.
254
638151
3979
10:54
But what I think we should do
255
642130
1583
10:55
is go right back to the beginning,
256
643713
1939
10:57
and basically look all over the body.
257
645652
2339
10:59
No matter how embarrassing,
258
647991
1691
11:01
we need to search and go for the first time
259
649682
3378
11:05
where no one else has dared tread.
260
653060
2460
11:07
It's going to be difficult,
261
655520
1148
11:08
it's going to be embarrassing, but we need to look.
262
656668
2575
11:11
We also need to go back to the ideas
263
659243
2947
11:14
that Butenandt used when he
was studying the silk moth.
was studying the silk moth.
264
662190
3267
11:17
We need to go back and look systematically
265
665457
3468
11:20
at all the molecules that are being produced,
266
668925
2138
11:23
and work out which ones are really involved.
267
671063
2433
11:25
It isn't good enough simply to pluck a couple
268
673496
2106
11:27
and say, "They'll do."
269
675602
1944
11:29
We have to actually demonstrate
270
677546
1399
11:30
that they really have the effects we claim.
271
678945
2810
11:33
There is one team that I'm
actually very impressed by.
actually very impressed by.
272
681755
3234
11:36
They're in France, and their previous success
273
684989
3176
11:40
was identifying the rabbit mammary pheromone.
274
688165
4377
11:44
They've turned their attention now
275
692542
2569
11:47
to human babies and mothers.
276
695111
3185
11:50
So this is a baby having a drink of milk
277
698296
3071
11:53
from its mother's breast.
278
701367
2643
11:56
Her nipple is completely hidden
279
704010
2183
11:58
by the baby's head,
280
706193
1246
11:59
but what you'll notice is a white droplet
281
707439
3751
12:03
with an arrow pointing to it,
282
711190
1781
12:04
and that's the secretion from the areolar glands.
283
712971
3199
12:08
Now, we all have them, men and women,
284
716170
2990
12:11
and these are the little bumps around the nipple,
285
719160
2818
12:13
and if you're a lactating woman,
286
721978
1959
12:15
these start to secrete.
287
723937
2337
12:18
It's a very interesting secretion.
288
726274
2589
12:20
What Benoist Schaal and his team developed
289
728863
3003
12:23
was a simple test to investigate
290
731866
2407
12:26
what the effect of this secretion might be,
291
734273
2806
12:29
in effect, a simple bioassay.
292
737079
2976
12:32
So this is a sleeping baby,
293
740055
2675
12:34
and under its nose, we've put a clean glass rod.
294
742730
4989
12:39
The baby remains sleeping,
295
747719
2111
12:41
showing no interest at all.
296
749830
2341
12:44
But if we go to any mother
297
752171
2074
12:46
who is secreting from the areolar glands,
298
754245
2429
12:48
so it's not about recognition,
299
756674
1577
12:50
it can be from any mother,
300
758251
2228
12:52
if we take the secretion
301
760479
1352
12:53
and now put it under the baby's nose,
302
761831
2904
12:56
we get a very different reaction.
303
764735
2091
12:58
It's a connoisseur's reaction of delight,
304
766826
2984
13:01
and it opens its mouth
305
769810
2060
13:03
and sticks out its tongue
306
771870
1653
13:05
and starts to suck.
307
773523
2087
13:07
Now, since this is from any mother,
308
775610
2340
13:09
it could really be a pheromone.
309
777950
1792
13:11
It's not about individual recognition.
310
779742
1779
13:13
Any mother will do.
311
781521
1876
13:15
Now, why is this important,
312
783397
1463
13:16
apart from being simply very interesting?
313
784860
2458
13:19
It's because women vary
314
787318
1807
13:21
in the number of areolar glands that they have,
315
789125
2773
13:23
and there is a correlation between the ease
316
791898
2196
13:26
with which babies start to suckle
317
794094
2542
13:28
and the number of areolar glands she has.
318
796636
1862
13:30
It appears that the more secretions she's got,
319
798498
2798
13:33
the more likely the baby is to suckle quickly.
320
801296
3662
13:36
If you're a mammal,
321
804958
1460
13:38
the most dangerous time in life
322
806418
2543
13:40
is the first few hours after birth.
323
808961
2309
13:43
You have to get that first drink of milk,
324
811270
3760
13:47
and if you don't get it, you won't survive.
325
815030
3491
13:50
You'll be dead.
326
818521
1464
13:51
Since many babies actually find it difficult
327
819985
2638
13:54
to take that first meal,
328
822623
1649
13:56
because they're not getting the right stimulus,
329
824272
1977
13:58
if we could identify what that molecule was,
330
826249
3210
14:01
and the French team are being very cautious,
331
829459
1987
14:03
but if we could identify the molecule,
332
831446
2115
14:05
synthesize it, it would then mean
333
833561
2794
14:08
premature babies would be more likely to suckle,
334
836355
1906
14:10
and every baby would have a better chance
335
838261
2928
14:13
of survival.
336
841189
1321
14:14
So what I want to argue is this is one example
337
842510
2540
14:17
of where a systematic, really scientific approach
338
845050
3596
14:20
can actually bring you a real understanding
339
848646
2722
14:23
of pheromones.
340
851368
1108
14:24
There could be all sorts of medical interventions.
341
852476
2614
14:27
There could be all sorts of things
342
855090
1254
14:28
that humans are doing with pheromones
343
856344
1700
14:30
that we simply don't know at the moment.
344
858044
2048
14:32
What we need to remember is pheromones
345
860092
1886
14:33
are not just about sex.
346
861978
1378
14:35
They're about all sorts of things to do
347
863356
1716
14:37
with a mammal's life.
348
865072
1723
14:38
So do go forward and do search for more.
349
866795
2689
14:41
There's lots to find.
350
869484
1040
14:42
Thank you very much.
351
870524
1866
14:44
(Applause)
352
872390
4488
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tristram Wyatt - ZoologistDo humans have pheromones? Tristram Wyatt is on the case. A researcher at Oxford, Wyatt is interested in the evolution of pheromones throughout the animal kingdom.
Why you should listen
Tristram Wyatt wants to understand the messages that animals send with their smell. At Oxford, he researches the intersection of pheromone evolution and animal behavior, particularly in mammals. He's interested in the distinction between pheromones, the chemical signals a species produces, and each individual's signature mixture of distinct molecules. The zoologist has discovered some surprising biological coincidences along the way — like the fact that Asian elephants have the same female sex pheromones as 140 species of moths.
Wyatt is the author of Pheromones and Animal Behavior.
Tristram Wyatt | Speaker | TED.com