ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Nathalie Cabrol - Planetary explorer
To determine how life might persist on Mars, Nathalie Cabrol explores one of Earth’s most extreme environments: high-elevation Andean lakes and deserts.

Why you should listen

While hunting for life in the fragile biomes of the Andes, Nathalie Cabrol has braved earthquakes, set a diving record and gathered data on the threats faced by mountain ecosystems in the face of climate change.

But Cabrol’s eyes are always fixed on Mars, which may have once had a climate similar to Earth’s mountain deserts. As a science team member for NASA, Cabrol helps design interplanetary experiments for the Martian Spirit rover, and researches new technologies for future missions to Mars and beyond.

More profile about the speaker
Nathalie Cabrol | Speaker | TED.com
TED2015

Nathalie Cabrol: How Mars might hold the secret to the origin of life

Filmed:
1,261,913 views

While we like to imagine little green men, it's far more likely that life on other planets will be microbial. Planetary scientist Nathalie Cabrol takes us inside the search for microbes on Mars, a hunt which counterintuitively leads us to the remote lakes of the Andes mountains. This extreme environment — with its thin atmosphere and scorched land — approximates the surface of Mars about 3.5 billion years ago. How microbes adapt to survive here may just show us where to look on Mars — and could help us understand why some microbial pathways lead to civilization while others are a dead end.
- Planetary explorer
To determine how life might persist on Mars, Nathalie Cabrol explores one of Earth’s most extreme environments: high-elevation Andean lakes and deserts. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Well, you know, sometimes
0
765
1511
00:14
the most important things come
in the smallest packages.
1
2276
2982
00:17
I am going to try to convince you,
in the 15 minutes I have,
2
5258
3589
00:20
that microbes have a lot to say
about questions such as,
3
8847
4253
00:25
"Are we alone?"
4
13100
1898
00:26
and they can tell us more about
not only life in our solar system
5
14998
5225
00:32
but also maybe beyond,
6
20223
1877
00:34
and this is why I am tracking them down
in the most impossible places on Earth,
7
22100
5297
00:39
in extreme environments where conditions
8
27397
2369
00:41
are really pushing them
to the brink of survival.
9
29766
2684
00:44
Actually, sometimes me too,
when I'm trying to follow them too close.
10
32450
3254
00:47
But here's the thing:
11
35704
1817
00:49
We are the only advanced civilization
in the solar system,
12
37521
5613
00:55
but that doesn't mean that there is
no microbial life nearby.
13
43134
3744
00:58
In fact, the planets
and moons you see here
14
46878
3785
01:02
could host life -- all of them --
and we know that,
15
50663
3970
01:06
and it's a strong possibility.
16
54633
2849
01:09
And if we were going to find life
on those moons and planets,
17
57482
4653
01:14
then we would answer questions such as,
18
62135
3016
01:17
are we alone in the solar system?
19
65151
2136
01:19
Where are we coming from?
20
67287
1969
01:21
Do we have family in the neighborhood?
21
69256
2977
01:24
Is there life beyond our solar system?
22
72233
3924
01:28
And we can ask all those questions
because there has been a revolution
23
76157
4087
01:32
in our understanding
of what a habitable planet is,
24
80244
4276
01:36
and today, a habitable planet is a planet
25
84520
3340
01:39
that has a zone where
water can stay stable,
26
87860
4333
01:44
but to me this is a horizontal
definition of habitability,
27
92193
3729
01:47
because it involves a distance to a star,
28
95922
2275
01:50
but there is another
dimension to habitability,
29
98197
2972
01:53
and this is a vertical dimension.
30
101169
2181
01:55
Think of it as
31
103840
3687
01:59
conditions in the subsurface of a planet
where you are very far away from a sun,
32
107527
6683
02:06
but you still have water,
energy, nutrients,
33
114210
3143
02:09
which for some of them means food,
34
117353
1951
02:11
and a protection.
35
119304
1903
02:13
And when you look at the Earth,
36
121207
2044
02:15
very far away from any sunlight,
deep in the ocean,
37
123251
4545
02:19
you have life thriving
38
127796
1869
02:21
and it uses only chemistry
for life processes.
39
129665
4011
02:25
So when you think of it
at that point, all walls collapse.
40
133676
5650
02:31
You have no limitations, basically.
41
139326
2274
02:33
And if you have been looking
at the headlines lately,
42
141600
2560
02:36
then you will see that we have
discovered a subsurface ocean
43
144160
2960
02:39
on Europa, on Ganymede,
on Enceladus, on Titan,
44
147120
3869
02:42
and now we are finding a geyser
and hot springs on Enceladus,
45
150989
2934
02:45
Our solar system is turning
into a giant spa.
46
153923
4055
02:49
For anybody who has gone to a spa
knows how much microbes like that, right?
47
157978
3886
02:53
(Laughter)
48
161864
1718
02:55
So at that point, think also about Mars.
49
163582
3529
02:59
There is no life possible
at the surface of Mars today,
50
167111
3367
03:02
but it might still be hiding underground.
51
170478
3251
03:05
So, we have been making progress
in our understanding of habitability,
52
173729
5610
03:11
but we also have been making progress
in our understanding
53
179339
2772
03:14
of what the signatures
of life are on Earth.
54
182111
3576
03:17
And you can have what we call
organic molecules,
55
185687
2856
03:20
and these are the bricks of life,
56
188543
1927
03:22
and you can have fossils,
57
190470
1880
03:24
and you can minerals, biominerals,
58
192350
2903
03:27
which is due to the reaction
between bacteria and rocks,
59
195253
3390
03:30
and of course you can have
gases in the atmosphere.
60
198643
3134
03:33
And when you look at those
tiny green algae
61
201777
2206
03:35
on the right of the slide here,
62
203983
1951
03:37
they are the direct descendants
of those who have been pumping oxygen
63
205934
3516
03:41
a billion years ago
in the atmosphere of the Earth.
64
209450
2393
03:43
When they did that, they poisoned
90 percent of the life
65
211843
2622
03:46
at the surface of the Earth,
66
214465
1522
03:47
but they are the reason why
you are breathing this air today.
67
215987
3203
03:52
But as much as our understanding grows
of all of these things,
68
220740
5185
03:57
there is one question
we still cannot answer,
69
225925
2926
04:00
and this is, where are we coming from?
70
228851
2275
04:03
And you know, it's getting worse,
71
231126
1718
04:04
because we won't be able
to find the physical evidence
72
232844
3042
04:07
of where we are coming from
on this planet,
73
235886
2554
04:10
and the reason being is that anything that
is older than four billion years is gone.
74
238440
5690
04:16
All record is gone,
75
244130
1624
04:17
erased by plate tectonics and erosion.
76
245754
3878
04:21
This is what I call the Earth's
biological horizon.
77
249632
3552
04:25
Beyond this horizon we don't know
where we are coming from.
78
253184
3483
04:28
So is everything lost? Well, maybe not.
79
256667
2926
04:31
And we might be able to find
evidence of our own origin
80
259593
3715
04:35
in the most unlikely place,
and this place in Mars.
81
263308
3111
04:39
How is this possible?
82
267929
1491
04:41
Well clearly at the beginning
of the solar system,
83
269420
2781
04:44
Mars and the Earth were bombarded
by giant asteroids and comets,
84
272201
4968
04:49
and there were ejecta
from these impacts all over the place.
85
277169
3158
04:52
Earth and Mars kept throwing rocks
at each other for a very long time.
86
280327
3860
04:56
Pieces of rocks landed on the Earth.
87
284187
2043
04:58
Pieces of the Earth landed on Mars.
88
286230
1951
05:00
So clearly, those two planets may have
been seeded by the same material.
89
288181
5178
05:05
So yeah, maybe Granddady is sitting
there on the surface and waiting for us.
90
293359
3924
05:10
But that also means that we can go to Mars
and try to find traces of our own origin.
91
298659
7531
05:18
Mars may hold that secret for us.
92
306190
2252
05:20
This is why Mars is so special to us.
93
308442
2708
05:23
But for that to happen,
94
311150
2010
05:25
Mars needed to be habitable
at the time when conditions were right.
95
313160
5384
05:30
So was Mars habitable?
96
318544
1856
05:32
We have a number of missions
telling us exactly the same thing today.
97
320400
3854
05:36
At the time when life
appeared on the Earth,
98
324254
3738
05:39
Mars did have an ocean,
it had volcanoes, it had lakes,
99
327992
4838
05:44
and it had deltas like the beautiful
picture you see here.
100
332830
2843
05:47
This picture was sent by the Curiosity
rover only a few weeks ago.
101
335673
3787
05:51
It shows the remnants of a delta,
and this picture tells us something:
102
339460
3682
05:55
water was abundant
103
343142
1954
05:57
and stayed founting at the surface
for a very long time.
104
345096
2661
05:59
This is good news for life.
105
347757
1811
06:01
Life chemistry takes a long time
to actually happen.
106
349568
3422
06:04
So this is extremely good news,
107
352990
1517
06:06
but does that mean that if we go there,
life will be easy to find on Mars?
108
354507
3620
06:10
Not necessarily.
109
358127
1883
06:12
Here's what happened:
110
360010
1851
06:13
At the time when life exploded
at the surface of the Earth,
111
361861
3369
06:17
then everything went south for Mars,
112
365230
2139
06:19
literally.
113
367369
1532
06:20
The atmosphere was
stripped away by solar winds,
114
368901
3571
06:24
Mars lost its magnetosphere,
115
372472
2303
06:26
and then cosmic rays and U.V.
bombarded the surface
116
374775
4412
06:31
and water escaped to space
and went underground.
117
379187
4223
06:35
So if we want to be able to understand,
118
383410
3091
06:38
if we want to be able to find those traces
of the signatures of life
119
386501
4929
06:43
at the surface of Mars, if they are there,
120
391430
2214
06:45
we need to understand what was
the impact of each of these events
121
393644
3187
06:48
on the preservation of its record.
122
396831
3653
06:52
Only then will we be able
to know where those signatures are hiding,
123
400484
4830
06:57
and only then will we be able
to send our rover to the right places
124
405314
3683
07:00
where we can sample those rocks
that may be telling us something
125
408997
3149
07:04
really important about who we are,
126
412146
2716
07:06
or, if not, maybe telling us
that somewhere, independently,
127
414862
4110
07:10
life has appeared on another planet.
128
418972
2856
07:13
So to do that, it's easy.
129
421828
2508
07:16
You only need to go back
3.5 billion years ago
130
424336
3558
07:19
in the past of a planet.
131
427894
2391
07:22
We just need a time machine.
132
430285
2624
07:24
Easy, right?
133
432909
2194
07:27
Well, actually, it is.
134
435103
1570
07:28
Look around you -- that's planet Earth.
135
436673
1901
07:30
This is our time machine.
136
438574
2044
07:32
Geologists are using it
to go back in the past of our own planet.
137
440618
4170
07:36
I am using it a little bit differently.
138
444788
2183
07:38
I use planet Earth to go
in very extreme environments
139
446971
2995
07:41
where conditions were similar
to those of Mars
140
449966
2902
07:44
at the time when the climate changed,
141
452868
1997
07:46
and there I'm trying
to understand what happened.
142
454865
2880
07:49
What are the signatures of life?
143
457745
1694
07:51
What is left? How are we going to find it?
144
459439
2833
07:54
So for one moment now
I'm going to take you with me
145
462272
3004
07:57
on a trip into that time machine.
146
465276
2854
08:00
And now, what you see here,
we are at 4,500 meters in the Andes,
147
468130
4735
08:04
but in fact we are less than a billion
years after the Earth and Mars formed.
148
472865
6729
08:11
The Earth and Mars will have looked
pretty much exactly like that --
149
479594
3691
08:15
volcanoes everywhere,
evaporating lakes everywhere,
150
483285
3511
08:18
minerals, hot springs,
151
486796
3307
08:22
and then you see those mounds
on the shore of those lakes?
152
490103
3831
08:25
Those are built by the descendants
of the first organisms
153
493934
3460
08:29
that gave us the first fossil on Earth.
154
497394
3102
08:32
But if we want to understand what's
going on, we need to go a little further.
155
500496
4059
08:36
And the other thing about those sites
156
504555
1915
08:38
is that exactly like on Mars
three and a half billion years ago,
157
506470
3476
08:41
the climate is changing very fast,
and water and ice are disappearing.
158
509946
4517
08:46
But we need to go back to that time
when everything changed on Mars,
159
514463
3215
08:49
and to do that, we need to go higher.
160
517678
2083
08:52
Why is that?
161
520441
1417
08:53
Because when you go higher,
162
521858
1357
08:55
the atmosphere is getting thinner,
it's getting more unstable,
163
523215
3122
08:58
the temperature is getting cooler,
and you have a lot more U.V. radiation.
164
526337
5311
09:03
Basically,
165
531648
809
09:04
you are getting to those conditions
on Mars when everything changed.
166
532457
4734
09:10
So I was not promising anything about
a leisurely trip on the time machine.
167
538340
6497
09:16
You are not going to be sitting
in that time machine.
168
544837
2534
09:19
You have to haul 1,000 pounds
of equipment to the summit
169
547371
3028
09:22
of this 20,000-foot volcano
in the Andes here.
170
550399
3785
09:26
That's about 6,000 meters.
171
554184
2600
09:28
And you also have to sleep
on 42-degree slopes
172
556784
3623
09:32
and really hope that there won't
be any earthquake that night.
173
560407
3111
09:35
But when we get to the summit,
we actually find the lake we came for.
174
563518
4946
09:40
At this altitude, this lake is
experiencing exactly the same conditions
175
568464
4662
09:45
as those on Mars
three and a half billion years ago.
176
573126
3119
09:48
And now we have to change our voyage
177
576245
2925
09:51
into an inner voyage inside that lake,
178
579170
2720
09:53
and to do that, we have to remove
our mountain gear
179
581890
3651
09:57
and actually don suits and go for it.
180
585541
4306
10:02
But at the time we enter that lake,
at the very moment we enter that lake,
181
590277
4175
10:06
we are stepping back
182
594452
1928
10:08
three and a half billion years
in the past of another planet,
183
596380
3181
10:11
and then we are going to get
the answer came for.
184
599561
4100
10:16
Life is everywhere, absolutely everywhere.
185
604511
3122
10:19
Everything you see in this picture
is a living organism.
186
607633
3320
10:22
Maybe not so the diver,
but everything else.
187
610953
3493
10:27
But this picture is very deceiving.
188
615626
3227
10:30
Life is abundant in those lakes,
189
618853
2670
10:33
but like in many places on Earth
right now and due to climate change,
190
621523
4107
10:37
there is a huge loss in biodiversity.
191
625630
2694
10:40
In the samples that we took back home,
192
628744
2996
10:43
36 percent of the bacteria in those lakes
were composed of three species,
193
631740
5816
10:49
and those three species are the ones
that have survived so far.
194
637556
3819
10:53
Here's another lake,
right next to the first one.
195
641375
2787
10:56
The red color you see here
is not due to minerals.
196
644162
3668
10:59
It's actually due to the presence
of a tiny algae.
197
647830
3321
11:03
In this region, the U.V. radiation
is really nasty.
198
651151
4509
11:07
Anywhere on Earth, 11
is considered to be extreme.
199
655660
3469
11:11
During U.V. storms there,
the U.V. Index reaches 43.
200
659129
4031
11:15
SPF 30 is not going to do anything
to you over there,
201
663730
4246
11:19
and the water is so
transparent in those lakes
202
667976
3366
11:23
that the algae has
nowhere to hide, really,
203
671342
3333
11:26
and so they are developing
their own sunscreen,
204
674675
2290
11:28
and this is the red color you see.
205
676965
1784
11:30
But they can adapt only so far,
206
678749
2561
11:33
and then when all the water
is gone from the surface,
207
681310
2478
11:35
microbes have only one solution left:
208
683788
2600
11:38
They go underground.
209
686388
1858
11:40
And those microbes, the rocks
you see in that slide here,
210
688246
2925
11:43
well, they are actually
living inside rocks
211
691171
3220
11:46
and they are using the protection
of the translucence of the rocks
212
694391
3194
11:49
to get the good part of the U.V.
213
697585
1797
11:51
and discard the part that could
actually damage their DNA.
214
699382
3744
11:55
And this is why we are taking our rover
215
703126
2275
11:57
to train them to search
for life on Mars in these areas,
216
705401
3576
12:00
because if there was life on Mars
three and a half billion years ago,
217
708977
3737
12:04
it had to use the same strategy
to actually protect itself.
218
712714
4360
12:09
Now, it is pretty obvious
219
717864
2378
12:12
that going to extreme environments
is helping us very much
220
720242
3528
12:15
for the exploration of Mars
and to prepare missions.
221
723770
3991
12:19
So far, it has helped us to understand
the geology of Mars.
222
727761
4339
12:24
It has helped to understand the past
climate of Mars and its evolution,
223
732100
4121
12:28
but also its habitability potential.
224
736221
2987
12:31
Our most recent rover on Mars
has discovered traces of organics.
225
739208
5539
12:36
Yeah, there are organics
at the surface of Mars.
226
744747
2959
12:39
And it also discovered traces of methane.
227
747706
3901
12:43
And we don't know yet
if the methane in question
228
751607
2545
12:46
is really from geology or biology.
229
754152
3838
12:49
Regardless, what we know is
that because of the discovery,
230
757990
4869
12:54
the hypothesis that there is still
life present on Mars today
231
762859
3241
12:58
remains a viable one.
232
766100
2355
13:00
So by now, I think I have convinced you
that Mars is very special to us,
233
768455
5197
13:05
but it would be a mistake to think
that Mars is the only place
234
773652
2976
13:08
in the solar system that is interesting
to find potential microbial life.
235
776628
4946
13:14
And the reason is because
Mars and the Earth
236
782434
3918
13:18
could have a common root
to their tree of life,
237
786352
2791
13:21
but when you go beyond Mars,
it's not that easy.
238
789143
4147
13:25
Celestial mechanics
is not making it so easy
239
793290
2610
13:27
for an exchange
of material between planets,
240
795900
2415
13:30
and so if we were to discover
life on those planets,
241
798315
4040
13:34
it would be different from us.
242
802355
1857
13:36
It would be a different type of life.
243
804212
1838
13:38
But in the end, it might be just us,
244
806050
2853
13:40
it might be us and Mars,
245
808903
1996
13:42
or it can be many trees of life
in the solar system.
246
810899
3483
13:46
I don't know the answer yet,
but I can tell you something:
247
814382
3728
13:50
No matter what the result is,
no matter what that magic number is,
248
818110
4432
13:54
it is going to give us a standard
249
822542
2011
13:56
by which we are going to be able
to measure the life potential,
250
824553
4528
14:01
abundance and diversity
beyond our own solar system.
251
829081
3110
14:04
And this can be achieved
by our generation.
252
832191
2560
14:06
This can be our legacy,
but only if we dare to explore.
253
834751
3863
14:11
Now, finally,
254
839654
2086
14:13
if somebody tells you that looking
for alien microbes is not cool
255
841740
3968
14:17
because you cannot have
a philosophical conversation with them,
256
845708
3430
14:21
let me show you why and how
you can tell them they're wrong.
257
849138
5876
14:27
Well, organic material
is going to tell you
258
855804
2768
14:30
about environment, about complexity
and about diversity.
259
858572
5659
14:36
DNA, or any information carrier,
is going to tell you about adaptation,
260
864231
6119
14:42
about evolution, about survival,
about planetary changes
261
870350
5021
14:47
and about the transfer of information.
262
875371
2848
14:50
All together, they are telling us
263
878219
3088
14:53
what started as a microbial pathway,
264
881307
3901
14:57
and why what started
as a microbial pathway
265
885208
3018
15:00
sometimes ends up as a civilization
266
888226
3460
15:03
or sometimes ends up as a dead end.
267
891686
3622
15:07
Look at the solar system,
and look at the Earth.
268
895308
3416
15:10
On Earth, there are many
intelligent species,
269
898724
2807
15:13
but only one has achieved technology.
270
901531
3367
15:16
Right here in the journey
of our own solar system,
271
904898
3297
15:20
there is a very, very powerful message
272
908195
2739
15:22
that says here's how we should look
for alien life, small and big.
273
910934
5386
15:28
So yeah, microbes are talking
and we are listening,
274
916320
3298
15:31
and they are taking us,
275
919618
1719
15:33
one planet at a time
and one moon at a time,
276
921337
2554
15:35
towards their big brothers out there.
277
923891
2879
15:38
And they are telling us about diversity,
278
926770
2716
15:41
they are telling us about
abundance of life,
279
929486
2624
15:44
and they are telling us
how this life has survived thus far
280
932110
4040
15:48
to reach civilization,
281
936150
3042
15:51
intelligence, technology
and, indeed, philosophy.
282
939192
4982
15:56
Thank you.
283
944174
1705
15:57
(Applause)
284
945879
3236

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Nathalie Cabrol - Planetary explorer
To determine how life might persist on Mars, Nathalie Cabrol explores one of Earth’s most extreme environments: high-elevation Andean lakes and deserts.

Why you should listen

While hunting for life in the fragile biomes of the Andes, Nathalie Cabrol has braved earthquakes, set a diving record and gathered data on the threats faced by mountain ecosystems in the face of climate change.

But Cabrol’s eyes are always fixed on Mars, which may have once had a climate similar to Earth’s mountain deserts. As a science team member for NASA, Cabrol helps design interplanetary experiments for the Martian Spirit rover, and researches new technologies for future missions to Mars and beyond.

More profile about the speaker
Nathalie Cabrol | Speaker | TED.com