ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Peter Singer - Philosopher, ethicist
Sometimes controversial, always practical ethicist Peter Singer stirs public debate about morality, from animal welfare to global poverty.

Why you should listen

Peter Singer may be, as The New Yorker calls him, the planet’s “most influential living philosopher.” The Australian academic specializes in applied ethics, to which he takes a secular, utilitarian approach -- minimize suffering, maximize well-being. He gained recognition in the 1970s with his groundbreaking book Animal Liberation: A New Ethics for Our Treatment of Animals, which questions society’s tendency to put human needs above those of members of other species. And he draws fire from critics who object to his fascinating argument in favor of an obligation to help the global poor that sets the bar so high that it means we are almost all living unethically. His defense of euthanasia and infanticide, in some circumstances, has led to protests against his lectures and to teaching position at Princeton.

But Singer’s collective body of work is more acclaimed than controversial. He has written the classic text Practical Ethics and many other books, with more in progress. He lectures at Princeton, where he is professor of bioethics, and the University of Melbourne, where he is a laureate professor. You can find dozens of brief, brilliant essays at Project Syndicate, where Singer examines the philosophical questions surrounding current topics like Obamacare, computer piracy and obesity.

More profile about the speaker
Peter Singer | Speaker | TED.com
TED2013

Peter Singer: The why and how of effective altruism

Filmed:
1,880,611 views

If you're lucky enough to live without want, it's a natural impulse to be altruistic to others. But, asks philosopher Peter Singer, what's the most effective way to give? He talks through some surprising thought experiments to help you balance emotion and practicality -- and make the biggest impact with whatever you can share. NOTE: Starting at 0:30, this talk contains 30 seconds of graphic footage.
- Philosopher, ethicist
Sometimes controversial, always practical ethicist Peter Singer stirs public debate about morality, from animal welfare to global poverty. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
There's something that I'd like you to see.
0
868
3605
00:16
(Video) Reporter: It's a story that's deeply unsettled
1
4473
2484
00:18
millions in China:
2
6957
2054
00:21
footage of a two-year-old girl
3
9011
1880
00:22
hit by a van and left bleeding in the street by passersby,
4
10891
4552
00:27
footage too graphic to be shown.
5
15443
3240
00:30
The entire accident is caught on camera.
6
18683
2680
00:33
The driver pauses after hitting the child,
7
21363
2808
00:36
his back wheels seen resting on her for over a second.
8
24171
3912
00:40
Within two minutes, three people pass two-year-old Wang Yue by.
9
28083
3945
00:44
The first walks around the badly injured toddler completely.
10
32028
3684
00:47
Others look at her before moving off.
11
35712
3323
00:53
Peter Singer: There were other people
12
41540
1267
00:54
who walked past Wang Yue,
13
42807
2327
00:57
and a second van ran over her legs
14
45134
1719
00:58
before a street cleaner raised the alarm.
15
46853
3216
01:02
She was rushed to hospital, but it was too late. She died.
16
50069
5201
01:07
I wonder how many of you, looking at that,
17
55270
3808
01:11
said to yourselves just now, "I would not have done that.
18
59078
3683
01:14
I would have stopped to help."
19
62761
2204
01:16
Raise your hands if that thought occurred to you.
20
64965
3900
01:20
As I thought, that's most of you.
21
68865
2876
01:23
And I believe you. I'm sure you're right.
22
71741
1967
01:25
But before you give yourself too much credit,
23
73708
3239
01:28
look at this.
24
76947
1662
01:30
UNICEF reports that in 2011,
25
78609
4176
01:34
6.9 million children under five
26
82785
3949
01:38
died from preventable, poverty-related diseases.
27
86734
5452
01:44
UNICEF thinks that that's good news
28
92186
2262
01:46
because the figure has been steadily coming down
29
94448
3178
01:49
from 12 million in 1990. That is good.
30
97626
4053
01:53
But still, 6.9 million
31
101679
3104
01:56
is 19,000 children dying every day.
32
104783
5324
02:02
Does it really matter
33
110107
2786
02:04
that we're not walking past them in the street?
34
112893
2905
02:07
Does it really matter that they're far away?
35
115798
5218
02:13
I don't think it does make a morally relevant difference.
36
121016
3418
02:16
The fact that they're not right in front of us,
37
124434
2408
02:18
the fact, of course, that they're of a different nationality
38
126842
2161
02:21
or race, none of that seems morally relevant to me.
39
129003
3975
02:24
What is really important is,
40
132978
1520
02:26
can we reduce that death toll? Can we save
41
134498
4265
02:30
some of those 19,000 children dying every day?
42
138763
4966
02:35
And the answer is, yes we can.
43
143729
3618
02:39
Each of us spends money
44
147347
2543
02:41
on things that we do not really need.
45
149890
2181
02:44
You can think what your own habit is,
46
152071
1932
02:46
whether it's a new car, a vacation
47
154003
2565
02:48
or just something like buying bottled water
48
156568
2680
02:51
when the water that comes out of the tap
49
159248
2023
02:53
is perfectly safe to drink.
50
161271
2530
02:55
You could take the money you're spending
51
163801
1647
02:57
on those unnecessary things
52
165448
1895
02:59
and give it to this organization,
53
167343
2366
03:01
the Against Malaria Foundation,
54
169709
2927
03:04
which would take the money you had given
55
172636
2572
03:07
and use it to buy nets like this one
56
175208
3703
03:10
to protect children like this one,
57
178911
3539
03:14
and we know reliably that if we provide nets,
58
182450
4296
03:18
they're used, and they reduce the number of children
59
186746
3402
03:22
dying from malaria,
60
190148
2456
03:24
just one of the many preventable diseases
61
192604
2808
03:27
that are responsible for some of those 19,000 children
62
195412
3952
03:31
dying every day.
63
199364
3648
03:35
Fortunately, more and more people
64
203012
2184
03:37
are understanding this idea,
65
205196
2514
03:39
and the result is a growing movement:
66
207710
3318
03:43
effective altruism.
67
211028
2656
03:45
It's important because it combines both the heart and the head.
68
213684
4384
03:50
The heart, of course, you felt.
69
218068
1711
03:51
You felt the empathy for that child.
70
219779
3143
03:54
But it's really important to use the head as well
71
222922
4034
03:58
to make sure that what you do is effective and well-directed,
72
226956
4793
04:03
and not only that, but also I think reason helps us
73
231749
4334
04:08
to understand that other people, wherever they are,
74
236083
3769
04:11
are like us, that they can suffer as we can,
75
239852
3591
04:15
that parents grieve for the deaths of their children,
76
243443
2673
04:18
as we do,
77
246116
1803
04:19
and that just as our lives and our well-being matter to us,
78
247919
4218
04:24
it matters just as much to all of these people.
79
252137
3243
04:27
So I think reason is not just some neutral tool
80
255380
3068
04:30
to help you get whatever you want.
81
258448
1495
04:31
It does help us to put perspective on our situation.
82
259943
4630
04:36
And I think that's why
83
264573
1879
04:38
many of the most significant people in effective altruism
84
266452
5006
04:43
have been people who have had backgrounds
85
271458
2384
04:45
in philosophy or economics or math.
86
273842
4738
04:50
And that might seem surprising,
87
278580
1465
04:52
because a lot of people think,
88
280045
1333
04:53
"Philosophy is remote from the real world;
89
281378
3813
04:57
economics, we're told, just makes us more selfish,
90
285191
3943
05:01
and we know that math is for nerds."
91
289134
3531
05:04
But in fact it does make a difference,
92
292665
2758
05:07
and in fact there's one particular nerd
93
295423
1936
05:09
who has been a particularly effective altruist
94
297359
4220
05:13
because he got this.
95
301579
1917
05:15
This is the website of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation,
96
303496
3279
05:18
and if you look at the words on the top right-hand side,
97
306775
3796
05:22
it says, "All lives have equal value."
98
310571
3927
05:26
That's the understanding,
99
314498
1869
05:28
the rational understanding of our situation in the world
100
316367
3622
05:31
that has led to these people
101
319989
2261
05:34
being the most effective altruists in history,
102
322250
4681
05:38
Bill and Melinda Gates and Warren Buffett.
103
326931
2672
05:41
(Applause)
104
329603
6133
05:47
No one, not Andrew Carnegie, not John D. Rockefeller,
105
335736
4169
05:51
has ever given as much to charity
106
339905
2658
05:54
as each one of these three,
107
342563
3248
05:57
and they have used their intelligence
108
345811
2752
06:00
to make sure that it is highly effective.
109
348563
4080
06:04
According to one estimate, the Gates Foundation
110
352643
3088
06:07
has already saved 5.8 million lives
111
355731
3808
06:11
and many millions more, people, getting diseases
112
359539
3158
06:14
that would have made them very sick,
113
362697
1527
06:16
even if eventually they survived.
114
364224
3251
06:19
Over the coming years, undoubtably the Gates Foundation
115
367475
2600
06:22
is going to give a lot more,
116
370075
2664
06:24
is going to save a lot more lives.
117
372739
3975
06:28
Well, you might say, that's fine if you're a billionaire,
118
376714
4242
06:32
you can have that kind of impact.
119
380956
2424
06:35
But if I'm not, what can I do?
120
383380
2948
06:38
So I'm going to look at four questions that people ask
121
386328
3324
06:41
that maybe stand in the way of them giving.
122
389652
3448
06:45
They worry how much of a difference they can make.
123
393100
2367
06:47
But you don't have to be a billionaire.
124
395467
3225
06:50
This is Toby Ord. He's a research fellow in philosophy
125
398692
3664
06:54
at the University of Oxford.
126
402356
2026
06:56
He became an effective altruist when he calculated
127
404382
3588
06:59
that with the money that he was likely to earn
128
407970
2275
07:02
throughout his career, an academic career,
129
410245
2400
07:04
he could give enough to cure 80,000 people of blindness
130
412645
6667
07:11
in developing countries
131
419312
2046
07:13
and still have enough left
132
421358
2273
07:15
for a perfectly adequate standard of living.
133
423631
4724
07:20
So Toby founded an organization
134
428355
1997
07:22
called Giving What We Can to spread this information,
135
430352
4086
07:26
to unite people who want to share some of their income,
136
434438
3926
07:30
and to ask people to pledge to give 10 percent
137
438364
2713
07:33
of what they earn over their lifetime
138
441077
2111
07:35
to fighting global poverty.
139
443188
3321
07:38
Toby himself does better than that.
140
446509
2439
07:40
He's pledged to live on 18,000 pounds a year --
141
448948
4400
07:45
that's less than 30,000 dollars --
142
453348
2744
07:48
and to give the rest to those organizations.
143
456092
3400
07:51
And yes, Toby is married and he does have a mortgage.
144
459492
5574
07:57
This is a couple at a later stage of life,
145
465066
3645
08:00
Charlie Bresler and Diana Schott,
146
468711
2996
08:03
who, when they were young, when they met,
147
471707
1527
08:05
were activists against the Vietnam War,
148
473234
3154
08:08
fought for social justice,
149
476388
1979
08:10
and then moved into careers, as most people do,
150
478367
2884
08:13
didn't really do anything very active about those values,
151
481251
3609
08:16
although they didn't abandon them.
152
484860
2839
08:19
And then, as they got to the age at which many people
153
487699
2379
08:22
start to think of retirement, they returned to them,
154
490078
3406
08:25
and they've decided to cut back on their spending,
155
493484
3164
08:28
to live modestly, and to give both money and time
156
496648
5145
08:33
to helping to fight global poverty.
157
501793
4878
08:38
Now, mentioning time might lead you to think,
158
506671
3042
08:41
"Well, should I abandon my career and put all of my time
159
509713
3624
08:45
into saving some of these 19,000 lives
160
513337
3205
08:48
that are lost every day?"
161
516542
1663
08:50
One person who's thought quite a bit about this issue
162
518205
2702
08:52
of how you can have a career that will have
163
520907
2823
08:55
the biggest impact for good in the world is Will Crouch.
164
523730
3721
08:59
He's a graduate student in philosophy,
165
527451
2656
09:02
and he's set up a website called 80,000 Hours,
166
530107
4352
09:06
the number of hours he estimates
167
534459
1674
09:08
most people spend on their career,
168
536133
2372
09:10
to advise people on how to have the best,
169
538505
2212
09:12
most effective career.
170
540717
1980
09:14
But you might be surprised to know
171
542697
2214
09:16
that one of the careers that he encourages people to consider,
172
544911
3021
09:19
if they have the right abilities and character,
173
547932
2265
09:22
is to go into banking or finance.
174
550197
4667
09:26
Why? Because if you earn a lot of money,
175
554864
3811
09:30
you can give away a lot of money,
176
558675
2339
09:33
and if you're successful in that career,
177
561014
2046
09:35
you could give enough to an aid organization
178
563060
2614
09:37
so that it could employ, let's say, five aid workers
179
565674
4930
09:42
in developing countries, and each one of them
180
570604
3292
09:45
would probably do about as much good
181
573896
1844
09:47
as you would have done.
182
575740
1534
09:49
So you can quintuple the impact
183
577274
3010
09:52
by leading that kind of career.
184
580284
4121
09:56
Here's one young man who's taken this advice.
185
584405
2520
09:58
His name is Matt Weiger.
186
586925
1341
10:00
He was a student at Princeton in philosophy and math,
187
588266
3762
10:04
actually won the prize for the best undergraduate philosophy thesis
188
592028
3719
10:07
last year when he graduated.
189
595747
2379
10:10
But he's gone into finance in New York.
190
598126
3226
10:13
He's already earning enough
191
601352
1605
10:14
so that he's giving a six-figure sum to effective charities
192
602957
4266
10:19
and still leaving himself with enough to live on.
193
607223
3729
10:22
Matt has also helped me to set up an organization
194
610952
3871
10:26
that I'm working with that has the name taken
195
614823
3053
10:29
from the title of a book I wrote,
196
617876
1627
10:31
"The Life You Can Save,"
197
619503
1898
10:33
which is trying to change our culture
198
621401
2741
10:36
so that more people think that
199
624142
3733
10:39
if we're going to live an ethical life,
200
627875
1717
10:41
it's not enough just to follow the thou-shalt-nots
201
629592
3831
10:45
and not cheat, steal, maim, kill,
202
633423
2380
10:47
but that if we have enough, we have to share some of that
203
635803
2887
10:50
with people who have so little.
204
638690
3353
10:54
And the organization draws together people
205
642043
2779
10:56
of different generations,
206
644822
1684
10:58
like Holly Morgan, who's an undergraduate,
207
646506
1845
11:00
who's pledged to give 10 percent
208
648351
1517
11:01
of the little amount that she has,
209
649868
1949
11:03
and on the right, Ada Wan,
210
651817
2053
11:05
who has worked directly for the poor, but has now
211
653870
2727
11:08
gone to Yale to do an MBA to have more to give.
212
656597
4502
11:13
Many people will think, though,
213
661099
1525
11:14
that charities aren't really all that effective.
214
662624
3982
11:18
So let's talk about effectiveness.
215
666606
1793
11:20
Toby Ord is very concerned about this,
216
668399
1990
11:22
and he's calculated that some charities
217
670389
2887
11:25
are hundreds or even thousands of times
218
673276
2789
11:28
more effective than others,
219
676065
2058
11:30
so it's very important to find the effective ones.
220
678123
2836
11:32
Take, for example, providing a guide dog for a blind person.
221
680959
5031
11:37
That's a good thing to do, right?
222
685990
2812
11:40
Well, right, it is a good thing to do,
223
688802
2022
11:42
but you have to think what else you could do with the resources.
224
690824
2917
11:45
It costs about 40,000 dollars to train a guide dog
225
693741
4244
11:49
and train the recipient so that the guide dog
226
697985
2496
11:52
can be an effective help to a blind person.
227
700481
3384
11:55
It costs somewhere between 20 and 50 dollars
228
703865
4272
12:00
to cure a blind person in a developing country
229
708137
3006
12:03
if they have trachoma.
230
711143
2010
12:05
So you do the sums, and you get something like that.
231
713153
3071
12:08
You could provide one guide dog
232
716224
1746
12:09
for one blind American,
233
717970
2345
12:12
or you could cure between 400
234
720315
2876
12:15
and 2,000 people of blindness.
235
723191
3771
12:18
I think it's clear what's the better thing to do.
236
726962
3597
12:22
But if you want to look for effective charities,
237
730559
3515
12:26
this is a good website to go to.
238
734074
2232
12:28
GiveWell exists to really assess the impact of charities,
239
736306
4884
12:33
not just whether they're well-run,
240
741190
1965
12:35
and it's screened hundreds of charities
241
743155
2300
12:37
and currently is recommending only three,
242
745455
3299
12:40
of which the Against Malaria Foundation is number one.
243
748754
4233
12:44
So it's very tough. If you want to look for other recommendations,
244
752987
2623
12:47
thelifeyoucansave.com and Giving What We Can
245
755610
3010
12:50
both have a somewhat broader list,
246
758620
2366
12:52
but you can find effective organizations,
247
760986
3336
12:56
and not just in the area of saving lives from the poor.
248
764322
4176
13:00
I'm pleased to say that there is now also a website
249
768498
2576
13:03
looking at effective animal organizations.
250
771074
3432
13:06
That's another cause that I've been concerned about
251
774506
2004
13:08
all my life, the immense amount of suffering
252
776510
2604
13:11
that humans inflict
253
779114
1526
13:12
on literally tens of billions of animals every year.
254
780640
4257
13:16
So if you want to look for effective organizations
255
784897
2326
13:19
to reduce that suffering,
256
787223
2073
13:21
you can go to Effective Animal Activism.
257
789296
3001
13:24
And some effective altruists think it's very important
258
792297
3039
13:27
to make sure that our species survives at all.
259
795336
3757
13:31
So they're looking at ways to reduce the risk of extinction.
260
799093
3430
13:34
Here's one risk of extinction that we all became aware of
261
802523
2643
13:37
recently, when an asteroid passed close to our planet.
262
805166
4157
13:41
Possibly research could help us not only to predict
263
809323
3006
13:44
the path of asteroids that might collide with us,
264
812329
1971
13:46
but actually to deflect them.
265
814300
2792
13:49
So some people think that would be a good thing to give to.
266
817092
2664
13:51
There's many possibilities.
267
819756
2242
13:53
My final question is,
268
821998
1711
13:55
some people will think it's a burden to give.
269
823709
3031
13:58
I don't really believe it is.
270
826740
1633
14:00
I've enjoyed giving all of my life
271
828373
2180
14:02
since I was a graduate student.
272
830553
1318
14:03
It's been something fulfilling to me.
273
831871
2833
14:06
Charlie Bresler said to me that he's not an altruist.
274
834704
2431
14:09
He thinks that the life he's saving is his own.
275
837135
3374
14:12
And Holly Morgan told me that she used to battle depression
276
840509
3927
14:16
until she got involved with effective altruism,
277
844436
2232
14:18
and now is one of the happiest people she knows.
278
846668
3546
14:22
I think one of the reasons for this
279
850214
1773
14:23
is that being an effective altruist helps to overcome
280
851987
3267
14:27
what I call the Sisyphus problem.
281
855254
2871
14:30
Here's Sisyphus as portrayed by Titian,
282
858125
3193
14:33
condemned by the gods to push a huge boulder
283
861318
3023
14:36
up to the top of the hill.
284
864341
1679
14:38
Just as he gets there, the effort becomes too much,
285
866020
3050
14:41
the boulder escapes, rolls all the way down the hill,
286
869070
3241
14:44
he has to trudge back down to push it up again,
287
872311
3304
14:47
and the same thing happens again and again
288
875615
2419
14:50
for all eternity.
289
878034
2382
14:52
Does that remind you of a consumer lifestyle,
290
880416
3015
14:55
where you work hard to get money,
291
883431
2682
14:58
you spend that money on consumer goods
292
886113
2245
15:00
which you hope you'll enjoy using?
293
888358
3572
15:03
But then the money's gone, you have to work hard
294
891930
2731
15:06
to get more, spend more, and to maintain
295
894661
2900
15:09
the same level of happiness, it's kind of a hedonic treadmill.
296
897561
3007
15:12
You never get off, and you never really feel satisfied.
297
900568
3366
15:15
Becoming an effective altruist gives you
298
903934
2992
15:18
that meaning and fulfillment.
299
906926
1490
15:20
It enables you to have a solid basis for self-esteem
300
908416
4191
15:24
on which you can feel your life was really worth living.
301
912607
4125
15:28
I'm going to conclude by telling you
302
916732
2556
15:31
about an email that I received
303
919288
2133
15:33
while I was writing this talk just a month or so ago.
304
921421
4924
15:38
It's from a man named Chris Croy, who I'd never heard of.
305
926345
3027
15:41
This is a picture of him showing him recovering from surgery.
306
929372
4419
15:45
Why was he recovering from surgery?
307
933791
2534
15:48
The email began, "Last Tuesday,
308
936325
3557
15:51
I anonymously donated my right kidney to a stranger.
309
939882
3858
15:55
That started a kidney chain
310
943740
2085
15:57
which enabled four people to receive kidneys."
311
945825
4669
16:02
There's about 100 people each year in the U.S.
312
950494
2439
16:04
and more in other countries who do that.
313
952933
2718
16:07
I was pleased to read it. Chris went on to say
314
955651
2164
16:09
that he'd been influenced by my writings in what he did.
315
957815
3372
16:13
Well, I have to admit, I'm also somewhat embarrassed by that,
316
961187
3423
16:16
because I still have two kidneys.
317
964610
6262
16:22
But Chris went on to say that he didn't think
318
970872
2266
16:25
that what he'd done was all that amazing,
319
973138
2680
16:27
because he calculated that the number of life-years
320
975818
3507
16:31
that he had added to people, the extension of life,
321
979325
2548
16:33
was about the same that you could achieve
322
981873
2809
16:36
if you gave 5,000 dollars to the Against Malaria Foundation.
323
984682
5836
16:42
And that did make me feel a little bit better,
324
990518
4076
16:46
because I have given more than 5,000 dollars
325
994594
3554
16:50
to the Against Malaria Foundation
326
998148
2847
16:52
and to various other effective charities.
327
1000995
4903
16:57
So if you're feeling bad
328
1005898
1434
16:59
because you still have two kidneys as well,
329
1007332
4082
17:03
there's a way for you to get off the hook.
330
1011414
2634
17:06
Thank you.
331
1014048
1200
17:07
(Applause)
332
1015248
6154
Translated by Joseph Geni
Reviewed by Morton Bast

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Peter Singer - Philosopher, ethicist
Sometimes controversial, always practical ethicist Peter Singer stirs public debate about morality, from animal welfare to global poverty.

Why you should listen

Peter Singer may be, as The New Yorker calls him, the planet’s “most influential living philosopher.” The Australian academic specializes in applied ethics, to which he takes a secular, utilitarian approach -- minimize suffering, maximize well-being. He gained recognition in the 1970s with his groundbreaking book Animal Liberation: A New Ethics for Our Treatment of Animals, which questions society’s tendency to put human needs above those of members of other species. And he draws fire from critics who object to his fascinating argument in favor of an obligation to help the global poor that sets the bar so high that it means we are almost all living unethically. His defense of euthanasia and infanticide, in some circumstances, has led to protests against his lectures and to teaching position at Princeton.

But Singer’s collective body of work is more acclaimed than controversial. He has written the classic text Practical Ethics and many other books, with more in progress. He lectures at Princeton, where he is professor of bioethics, and the University of Melbourne, where he is a laureate professor. You can find dozens of brief, brilliant essays at Project Syndicate, where Singer examines the philosophical questions surrounding current topics like Obamacare, computer piracy and obesity.

More profile about the speaker
Peter Singer | Speaker | TED.com