ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Paula Johnson - Women's-health expert
Dr. Paula Johnson is a pioneer in looking at health from a woman's perspective.

Why you should listen

Ever think you were having a heart attack? It turns out that many of the well-known early symptoms, such as chest pain and pressure from left arm to jaw, are more typically experienced by men. Women are more likely to experience shortness of breath, unusual perspiration and abdominal discomfort. Dr. Paula Johnson was one of the first to ask big questions about women's experience of cardiac care -- and their access to care that meets their needs.

Johnson and her team at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston focus on mentoring, measuring and bringing together expertise from practicing clinicians and academics to improve women's health. She says: "One of our core responsibilities will be to address critical questions ... such as, 'How do sex and gender impact health and health outcomes?' and 'How can health disparities among different groups of women be eliminated?'"

More profile about the speaker
Paula Johnson | Speaker | TED.com
TEDWomen 2013

Paula Johnson: His and hers ... health care

Filmed:
1,178,652 views

Every cell in the human body has a sex, which means that men and women are different right down to the cellular level. Yet too often, research and medicine ignore this insight -- and the often startlingly different ways in which the two sexes respond to disease or treatment. As pioneering doctor Paula Johnson describes in this thought-provoking talk, lumping everyone in together means we essentially leave women's health to chance. It's time to rethink.
- Women's-health expert
Dr. Paula Johnson is a pioneer in looking at health from a woman's perspective. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Some of my most wonderful memories of childhood
0
706
2711
00:15
are of spending time with my grandmother, Mamar,
1
3417
3551
00:18
in our four-family home in Brooklyn, New York.
2
6968
3800
00:22
Her apartment was an oasis.
3
10768
3075
00:25
It was a place where I could sneak a cup of coffee,
4
13843
2045
00:27
which was really warm milk
with just a touch of caffeine.
5
15888
3881
00:31
She loved life.
6
19769
2534
00:34
And although she worked in a factory,
7
22303
2495
00:36
she saved her pennies and she traveled to Europe.
8
24798
3172
00:39
And I remember poring over those pictures with her
9
27970
3329
00:43
and then dancing with her to her favorite music.
10
31299
4112
00:47
And then, when I was eight and she was 60,
11
35411
4622
00:52
something changed.
12
40033
2053
00:54
She no longer worked or traveled.
13
42086
2354
00:56
She no longer danced.
14
44440
1691
00:58
There were no more coffee times.
15
46131
2753
01:00
My mother missed work and took her to doctors
16
48884
2184
01:03
who couldn't make a diagnosis.
17
51068
2386
01:05
And my father, who worked at night,
would spend every afternoon with her,
18
53454
5337
01:10
just to make sure she ate.
19
58791
3085
01:13
Her care became all-consuming for our family.
20
61876
4700
01:18
And by the time a diagnosis was made,
21
66576
1647
01:20
she was in a deep spiral.
22
68223
2705
01:22
Now many of you will recognize her symptoms.
23
70928
3561
01:26
My grandmother had depression.
24
74489
2663
01:29
A deep, life-altering depression,
25
77152
3320
01:32
from which she never recovered.
26
80472
3090
01:35
And back then, so little
was known about depression.
27
83562
3691
01:39
But even today, 50 years later,
28
87253
3405
01:42
there's still so much more to learn.
29
90658
3274
01:45
Today, we know that women
are 70 percent more likely
30
93932
4908
01:50
to experience depression over their lifetimes
31
98840
2991
01:53
compared with men.
32
101831
2281
01:56
And even with this high prevalence,
33
104112
2840
01:58
women are misdiagnosed between
30 and 50 percent of the time.
34
106952
6287
02:05
Now we know that women are more likely
35
113239
2933
02:08
to experience the symptoms
of fatigue, sleep disturbance,
36
116172
5388
02:13
pain and anxiety compared with men.
37
121560
2545
02:16
And these symptoms are often overlooked
38
124105
2699
02:18
as symptoms of depression.
39
126804
2963
02:21
And it isn't only depression in which
these sex differences occur,
40
129767
3783
02:25
but they occur across so many diseases.
41
133550
4519
02:30
So it's my grandmother's struggles
42
138069
1995
02:32
that have really led me on a lifelong quest.
43
140064
3733
02:35
And today, I lead a center in which the mission
44
143797
3228
02:39
is to discover why these sex differences occur
45
147025
3779
02:42
and to use that knowledge
46
150804
2102
02:44
to improve the health of women.
47
152906
2959
02:47
Today, we know that every cell has a sex.
48
155865
4133
02:51
Now, that's a term coined
by the Institute of Medicine.
49
159998
3953
02:55
And what it means is that
men and women are different
50
163951
3761
02:59
down to the cellular and molecular levels.
51
167712
4442
03:04
It means that we're different
across all of our organs.
52
172154
4940
03:09
From our brains to our hearts, our lungs, our joints.
53
177094
5495
03:14
Now, it was only 20 years ago
54
182589
3884
03:18
that we hardly had any data on women's health
55
186473
3827
03:22
beyond our reproductive functions.
56
190300
2883
03:25
But then in 1993,
57
193183
2901
03:28
the NIH Revitalization Act was signed into law.
58
196084
4612
03:32
And what this law did was it mandated
59
200696
2603
03:35
that women and minorities
be included in clinical trials
60
203299
4473
03:39
that were funded by the National Institutes of Health.
61
207772
4051
03:43
And in many ways, the law has worked.
62
211823
2927
03:46
Women are now routinely
included in clinical studies,
63
214750
3670
03:50
and we've learned that there are major differences
64
218420
2251
03:52
in the ways that women and men
65
220671
2093
03:54
experience disease.
66
222764
2536
03:57
But remarkably,
67
225300
2165
03:59
what we have learned about these
differences is often overlooked.
68
227465
5094
04:04
So, we have to ask ourselves the question:
69
232559
3825
04:08
Why leave women's health to chance?
70
236384
4513
04:12
And we're leaving it to chance in two ways.
71
240897
2643
04:15
The first is that there is so much more to learn
72
243540
3697
04:19
and we're not making the investment
73
247237
2409
04:21
in fully understanding the extent
of these sex differences.
74
249646
4168
04:25
And the second is that we aren't
taking what we have learned,
75
253814
4722
04:30
and routinely applying it in clinical care.
76
258536
3704
04:34
We are just not doing enough.
77
262240
3989
04:38
So, I'm going to share with you three examples
78
266229
2259
04:40
of where sex differences have
impacted the health of women,
79
268488
3706
04:44
and where we need to do more.
80
272194
2670
04:46
Let's start with heart disease.
81
274864
2012
04:48
It's the number one killer of women
in the United States today.
82
276876
5202
04:54
This is the face of heart disease.
83
282078
2896
04:56
Linda is a middle-aged woman,
84
284974
2281
04:59
who had a stent placed in one of the arteries
85
287255
2585
05:01
going to her heart.
86
289840
2100
05:03
When she had recurring symptoms
she went back to her doctor.
87
291940
3251
05:07
Her doctor did the gold standard test:
88
295191
2638
05:09
a cardiac catheterization.
89
297829
2287
05:12
It showed no blockages.
90
300116
2417
05:14
Linda's symptoms continued.
91
302533
2072
05:16
She had to stop working.
92
304605
2473
05:19
And that's when she found us.
93
307078
2752
05:21
When Linda came to us, we did
another cardiac catheterization
94
309830
4148
05:25
and this time, we found clues.
95
313978
3417
05:29
But we needed another test
96
317395
2474
05:31
to make the diagnosis.
97
319869
2594
05:34
So we did a test called an intracoronary ultrasound,
98
322463
4580
05:39
where you use soundwaves to look at the artery
99
327043
2305
05:41
from the inside out.
100
329348
2731
05:44
And what we found
101
332079
1938
05:46
was that Linda's disease didn't look like
102
334017
2451
05:48
the typical male disease.
103
336468
3070
05:51
The typical male disease looks like this.
104
339538
3196
05:54
There's a discrete blockage or stenosis.
105
342734
3312
05:58
Linda's disease, like the disease of so many women,
106
346046
4301
06:02
looks like this.
107
350347
1842
06:04
The plaque is laid down more evenly, more diffusely
108
352189
3537
06:07
along the artery, and it's harder to see.
109
355726
3972
06:11
So for Linda, and for so many women,
110
359698
3406
06:15
the gold standard test wasn't gold.
111
363104
3692
06:18
Now, Linda received the right treatment.
112
366796
2987
06:21
She went back to her life and, fortunately, today
113
369783
2178
06:23
she is doing well.
114
371961
1752
06:25
But Linda was lucky.
115
373713
1606
06:27
She found us, we found her disease.
116
375319
2626
06:29
But for too many women, that's not the case.
117
377945
2911
06:32
We have the tools.
118
380856
2315
06:35
We have the technology to make the diagnosis.
119
383171
3681
06:38
But it's all too often that these sex diffferences
120
386852
3397
06:42
are overlooked.
121
390249
2304
06:44
So what about treatment?
122
392553
2173
06:46
A landmark study that was published two years ago
123
394726
2710
06:49
asked the very important question:
124
397436
2422
06:51
What are the most effective treatments
for heart disease in women?
125
399858
5055
06:56
The authors looked at papers
written over a 10-year period,
126
404913
3659
07:00
and hundreds had to be thrown out.
127
408572
2478
07:03
And what they found out was that
of those that were tossed out,
128
411050
4773
07:07
65 percent were excluded
129
415823
3654
07:11
because even though women
were included in the studies,
130
419477
4364
07:15
the analysis didn't differentiate
between women and men.
131
423841
6356
07:22
What a lost opportunity.
132
430197
3221
07:25
The money had been spent
133
433418
2031
07:27
and we didn't learn how women fared.
134
435449
2147
07:29
And these studies could not contribute one iota
135
437596
2801
07:32
to the very, very important question,
136
440397
2417
07:34
what are the most effective treatments
137
442814
2391
07:37
for heart disease in women?
138
445205
2895
07:40
I want to introduce you to
Hortense, my godmother,
139
448100
5492
07:45
Hung Wei, a relative of a colleague,
140
453592
3443
07:49
and somebody you may recognize --
141
457035
2191
07:51
Dana, Christopher Reeve's wife.
142
459226
3647
07:54
All three women have something
very important in common.
143
462873
4360
07:59
All three were diagnosed with lung cancer,
144
467233
3575
08:02
the number one cancer killer of women
145
470808
2929
08:05
in the United States today.
146
473737
2701
08:08
All three were nonsmokers.
147
476438
3876
08:12
Sadly, Dana and Hung Wei died of their disease.
148
480314
5166
08:17
Today, what we know is that women who are
nonsmokers are three times more likely
149
485480
6140
08:23
to be diagnosed with lung cancer than are men
150
491620
2737
08:26
who are nonsmokers.
151
494357
1986
08:28
Now interestingly, when women are
diagnosed with lung cancer,
152
496343
3690
08:32
their survival tends to be better than that of men.
153
500033
3179
08:35
Now, here are some clues.
154
503212
1875
08:37
Our investigators have found that there are
155
505087
2399
08:39
certain genes in the lung tumor
cells of both women and men.
156
507486
4672
08:44
And these genes are activated
157
512158
2192
08:46
mainly by estrogen.
158
514350
2090
08:48
And when these genes are over-expressed,
159
516440
2818
08:51
it's associated with improved survival
160
519258
2731
08:53
only in young women.
161
521989
2667
08:56
Now this is a very early finding
162
524656
1674
08:58
and we don't yet know whether it has relevance
163
526330
3643
09:01
to clinical care.
164
529973
2441
09:04
But it's findings like this that may provide hope
165
532414
3859
09:08
and may provide an opportunity to save lives
166
536273
2767
09:11
of both women and men.
167
539040
2547
09:13
Now, let me share with you an example
168
541587
1381
09:14
of when we do consider sex differences,
it can drive the science.
169
542968
3978
09:18
Several years ago a new lung cancer drug
170
546946
2328
09:21
was being evaluated,
171
549274
1646
09:22
and when the authors looked
at whose tumors shrank,
172
550920
4372
09:27
they found that 82 percent were women.
173
555292
3433
09:30
This led them to ask the question: Well, why?
174
558725
2963
09:33
And what they found
175
561688
1555
09:35
was that the genetic mutations
that the drug targeted
176
563243
3480
09:38
were far more common in women.
177
566723
2727
09:41
And what this has led to
178
569450
1699
09:43
is a more personalized approach
179
571149
2182
09:45
to the treatment of lung cancer
that also includes sex.
180
573331
4154
09:49
This is what we can accomplish
181
577485
2095
09:51
when we don't leave women's health to chance.
182
579580
3826
09:55
We know that when you invest in research,
183
583406
3208
09:58
you get results.
184
586614
1526
10:00
Take a look at the death rate
from breast cancer over time.
185
588140
4508
10:04
And now take a look at the death rates
186
592648
1925
10:06
from lung cancer in women over time.
187
594573
3332
10:09
Now let's look at the dollars
invested in breast cancer --
188
597905
3610
10:13
these are the dollars invested per death --
189
601515
2969
10:16
and the dollars invested in lung cancer.
190
604484
4228
10:20
Now, it's clear that our investment in breast cancer
191
608712
4921
10:25
has produced results.
192
613633
1789
10:27
They may not be fast enough,
193
615422
2333
10:29
but it has produced results.
194
617755
2226
10:31
We can do the same
195
619981
1804
10:33
for lung cancer and for every other disease.
196
621785
4991
10:38
So let's go back to depression.
197
626776
3326
10:42
Depression is the number one cause
198
630102
2310
10:44
of disability in women in the world today.
199
632412
4592
10:49
Our investigators have found
200
637004
2135
10:51
that there are differences in the brains
201
639139
1816
10:52
of women and men
202
640955
1477
10:54
in the areas that are connected with mood.
203
642432
3119
10:57
And when you put men and women
204
645551
2073
10:59
in a functional MRI scanner --
205
647624
1875
11:01
that's the kind of scanner that shows how the brain is functioning when it's activated --
206
649499
4547
11:06
so you put them in the scanner
and you expose them to stress.
207
654046
4043
11:10
You can actually see the difference.
208
658089
3887
11:13
And it's findings like this
209
661976
2529
11:16
that we believe hold some of the clues
210
664505
2981
11:19
for why we see these very significant sex differences
211
667486
3753
11:23
in depression.
212
671239
2254
11:25
But even though we know
213
673493
1558
11:27
that these differences occur,
214
675051
2867
11:29
66 percent
215
677918
2653
11:32
of the brain research that begins in animals
216
680571
3996
11:36
is done in either male animals
217
684567
2326
11:38
or animals in whom the sex is not identified.
218
686893
4347
11:43
So, I think we have to ask again the question:
219
691240
3619
11:46
Why leave women's health to chance?
220
694859
4802
11:51
And this is a question that haunts those of us
221
699661
2828
11:54
in science and medicine
222
702489
1811
11:56
who believe that we are on the verge
of being able to dramatically improve
223
704300
6359
12:02
the health of women.
224
710659
1676
12:04
We know that every cell has a sex.
225
712335
2486
12:06
We know that these differences
are often overlooked.
226
714821
2942
12:09
And therefore we know that women
are not getting the full benefit
227
717763
4288
12:14
of modern science and medicine today.
228
722051
3899
12:17
We have the tools
229
725950
1651
12:19
but we lack the collective will and momentum.
230
727601
3882
12:23
Women's health is an equal rights issue
231
731483
2744
12:26
as important as equal pay.
232
734227
3554
12:29
And it's an issue of the quality
233
737781
2184
12:31
and the integrity of science and medicine.
234
739965
3155
12:35
(Applause)
235
743120
7463
12:42
So imagine the momentum we could achieve
236
750583
4545
12:47
in advancing the health of women
237
755128
2111
12:49
if we considered whether these
sex differences were present
238
757239
2859
12:52
at the very beginning of designing research.
239
760098
3589
12:55
Or if we analyzed our data by sex.
240
763687
3879
12:59
So, people often ask me:
241
767566
1948
13:01
What can I do?
242
769514
1771
13:03
And here's what I suggest:
243
771285
2334
13:05
First, I suggest that you think about women's health
244
773619
4173
13:09
in the same way
245
777792
1743
13:11
that you think and care about other
causes that are important to you.
246
779535
6045
13:17
And second, and equally as important,
247
785580
3182
13:20
that as a woman,
248
788762
2212
13:22
you have to ask your doctor
249
790974
2641
13:25
and the doctors who are caring
for those who you love:
250
793615
4412
13:30
Is this disease or treatment different in women?
251
798027
4876
13:34
Now, this is a profound question
because the answer is likely yes,
252
802903
3588
13:38
but your doctor may not know
the answer, at least not yet.
253
806491
3697
13:42
But if you ask the question,
your doctor will very likely
254
810188
4376
13:46
go looking for the answer.
255
814564
2282
13:48
And this is so important,
256
816846
2337
13:51
not only for ourselves,
257
819183
2162
13:53
but for all of those whom we love.
258
821345
2653
13:55
Whether it be a mother, a daughter, a sister,
259
823998
4484
14:00
a friend or a grandmother.
260
828482
3697
14:04
It was my grandmother's suffering
261
832179
2143
14:06
that inspired my work
262
834322
1933
14:08
to improve the health of women.
263
836255
2985
14:11
That's her legacy.
264
839240
2350
14:13
Our legacy can be to improve the health of women
265
841590
4669
14:18
for this generation
266
846259
2139
14:20
and for generations to come.
267
848398
3022
14:23
Thank you.
268
851420
2149
14:25
(Applause)
269
853569
3282

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Paula Johnson - Women's-health expert
Dr. Paula Johnson is a pioneer in looking at health from a woman's perspective.

Why you should listen

Ever think you were having a heart attack? It turns out that many of the well-known early symptoms, such as chest pain and pressure from left arm to jaw, are more typically experienced by men. Women are more likely to experience shortness of breath, unusual perspiration and abdominal discomfort. Dr. Paula Johnson was one of the first to ask big questions about women's experience of cardiac care -- and their access to care that meets their needs.

Johnson and her team at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston focus on mentoring, measuring and bringing together expertise from practicing clinicians and academics to improve women's health. She says: "One of our core responsibilities will be to address critical questions ... such as, 'How do sex and gender impact health and health outcomes?' and 'How can health disparities among different groups of women be eliminated?'"

More profile about the speaker
Paula Johnson | Speaker | TED.com