ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Chuck Murry - Physician, scientist
Chuck Murry founded and currently directs the Institute for Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine at the University of Washington.

Why you should listen

Heart failure -- now the number one cause of death worldwide -- is the motivation behind Dr. Chuck Murry's specialized research into innovative treatments. Murry believes that it's not enough simply to help patients who are plagued with chronic disease survive. Instead, his pioneering work seeks to harness the potential of human stem cells to eliminate the disease from the body.

More profile about the speaker
Chuck Murry | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxSeattle

Chuck Murry: Can we regenerate heart muscle with stem cells?

Filmed:
1,853,632 views

The heart is one of the least regenerative organs in the human body -- a big factor in making heart failure the number one killer worldwide. What if we could help heart muscle regenerate after injury? Physician and scientist Chuck Murry shares his groundbreaking research into using stem cells to grow new heart cells -- an exciting step towards realizing the awesome promise of stem cells as medicine.
- Physician, scientist
Chuck Murry founded and currently directs the Institute for Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine at the University of Washington. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
I'd like to tell you
about a patient named Donna.
0
562
2945
00:16
In this photograph,
Donna was in her mid-70s,
1
4239
2465
00:18
a vigorous, healthy woman,
2
6728
1375
00:20
the matriarch of a large clan.
3
8127
1941
00:22
She had a family history
of heart disease, however,
4
10586
2405
00:25
and one day, she had the sudden onset
of crushing chest pain.
5
13015
3339
00:28
Now unfortunately, rather than
seeking medical attention,
6
16742
2668
00:31
Donna took to her bed for about 12 hours
until the pain passed.
7
19434
3916
00:35
The next time she went
to see her physician,
8
23374
2060
00:37
he performed an electrocardiogram,
9
25458
1637
00:39
and this showed that she'd had
a large heart attack,
10
27119
2444
00:41
or a "myocardial infarction"
in medical parlance.
11
29587
2964
00:45
After this heart attack,
Donna was never quite the same.
12
33496
3050
00:48
Her energy levels progressively waned,
13
36570
2622
00:51
she couldn't do a lot of the physical
activities she'd previously enjoyed.
14
39216
3658
00:54
It got to the point where she couldn't
keep up with her grandkids,
15
42898
3114
00:58
and it was even too much work
to go out to the end of the driveway
16
46036
3141
01:01
to pick up the mail.
17
49201
1151
01:02
One day, her granddaughter
came by to walk the dog,
18
50376
3053
01:05
and she found her grandmother
dead in the chair.
19
53453
2423
01:08
Doctors said it was a cardiac arrhythmia
that was secondary to heart failure.
20
56673
4347
01:13
But the last thing that I should tell you
21
61980
2004
01:16
is that Donna was not just
an ordinary patient.
22
64008
2870
01:18
Donna was my mother.
23
66902
1556
01:21
Stories like ours are,
unfortunately, far too common.
24
69445
3444
01:24
Heart disease is the number one killer
in the entire world.
25
72913
2959
01:27
In the United States,
26
75896
1159
01:29
it's the most common reason
patients are admitted to the hospital,
27
77079
3128
01:32
and it's our number one
health care expense.
28
80231
2058
01:34
We spend over a 100 billion dollars --
billion with a "B" --
29
82313
2928
01:37
in this country every year
30
85265
1262
01:38
on the treatment of heart disease.
31
86551
1832
01:40
Just for reference, that's more than
twice the annual budget
32
88407
2877
01:43
of the state of Washington.
33
91308
1317
01:45
What makes this disease so deadly?
34
93100
2157
01:47
Well, it all starts with the fact that
the heart is the least regenerative organ
35
95757
3886
01:51
in the human body.
36
99667
1336
01:53
Now, a heart attack happens when
a blood clot forms in a coronary artery
37
101502
3968
01:57
that feeds blood to the wall of the heart.
38
105494
2495
02:00
This plugs the blood flow,
39
108013
2098
02:02
and the heart muscle
is very metabolically active,
40
110135
2415
02:04
and so it dies very quickly,
41
112574
1348
02:05
within just a few hours
of having its blood flow interrupted.
42
113946
3788
02:10
Since the heart can't
grow back new muscle,
43
118446
2399
02:12
it heals by scar formation.
44
120869
2424
02:15
This leaves the patient with a deficit
45
123999
2114
02:18
in the amount of heart
muscle that they have.
46
126137
2306
02:20
And in too many people,
their illness progresses to the point
47
128467
2916
02:23
where the heart can no longer keep up
with the body's demand for blood flow.
48
131407
3858
02:27
This imbalance between supply and demand
is the crux of heart failure.
49
135289
5063
02:34
So when I talk to people
about this problem,
50
142877
3369
02:38
I often get a shrug
and a statement to the effect of,
51
146270
3809
02:42
"Well, you know, Chuck,
we've got to die of something."
52
150103
2737
02:44
(Laughter)
53
152864
3423
02:48
And yeah, but what this also tells me
54
156311
3357
02:51
is that we've resigned ourselves to this
as the status quo because we have to.
55
159692
5594
02:58
Or do we?
56
166801
1246
03:00
I think there's a better way,
57
168459
1693
03:02
and this better way involves the use
of stem cells as medicines.
58
170176
3503
03:06
So what, exactly, are stem cells?
59
174330
2021
03:08
If you look at them under the microscope,
there's not much going on.
60
176760
3237
03:12
They're just simple little round cells.
61
180021
1896
03:13
But that belies two remarkable attributes.
62
181941
2513
03:16
The first is they can divide like crazy.
63
184922
2315
03:19
So I can take a single cell,
and in a month's time,
64
187261
2834
03:22
I can grow this up to billions of cells.
65
190119
1968
03:24
The second is they can differentiate
or become more specialized,
66
192550
4801
03:29
so these simple little round cells
can turn into skin, can turn into brain,
67
197375
4145
03:33
can turn into kidney and so forth.
68
201544
2175
03:36
Now, some tissues in our bodies
are chock-full of stem cells.
69
204377
3086
03:39
Our bone marrow, for example, cranks out
billions of blood cells every day.
70
207487
3897
03:43
Other tissues like the heart
are quite stable,
71
211808
2434
03:46
and as far as we can tell,
the heart lacks stem cells entirely.
72
214266
4160
03:50
So for the heart, we're going to have
to bring stem cells in from the outside,
73
218450
3961
03:54
and for this, we turn to
the most potent stem cell type,
74
222435
2880
03:57
the pluripotent stem cell.
75
225339
2003
03:59
Pluripotent stem cells are so named
76
227366
1716
04:01
because they can turn into
any of the 240-some cell types
77
229106
3069
04:04
that make up the human body.
78
232199
1854
04:06
So this is my big idea:
79
234684
1983
04:08
I want to take human
pluripotent stem cells,
80
236691
2754
04:11
grow them up in large numbers,
81
239469
2127
04:13
differentiate them
into cardiac muscle cells
82
241620
2800
04:16
and then take them out of the dish
83
244444
1741
04:18
and transplant them into the hearts
of patients who have had heart attacks.
84
246209
3904
04:22
I think this is going to reseed the wall
with new muscle tissue,
85
250137
3519
04:25
and this will restore
contractile function to the heart.
86
253680
3592
04:29
(Applause)
87
257296
5655
04:36
Now, before you applaud too much,
this was my idea 20 years ago.
88
264490
3315
04:39
(Laughter)
89
267829
2039
04:41
And I was young,
I was full of it, and I thought,
90
269892
3900
04:45
five years in the lab,
and we'll crank this out,
91
273816
2325
04:48
and we'll have this into the clinic.
92
276165
2574
04:50
Let me tell you what really happened.
93
278763
2030
04:52
(Laughter)
94
280817
1119
04:53
We began with the quest to turn these
pluripotent stem cells into heart muscle.
95
281960
4705
04:58
And our first experiments worked, sort of.
96
286689
2516
05:01
We got these little clumps of beating
human heart muscle in the dish,
97
289229
3766
05:05
and that was cool,
because it said, in principle,
98
293019
2424
05:07
this should be able to be done.
99
295467
2262
05:09
But when we got around
to doing the cell counts,
100
297753
2275
05:12
we found that only one
out of 1,000 of our stem cells
101
300052
3031
05:15
were actually turning into heart muscle.
102
303107
2418
05:17
The rest was just a gemisch
of brain and skin and cartilage
103
305937
5520
05:23
and intestine.
104
311481
1785
05:25
So how do you coax a cell
that can become anything
105
313824
3329
05:29
into becoming just a heart muscle cell?
106
317177
2279
05:32
Well, for this we turned
to the world of embryology.
107
320243
2595
05:34
For over a century, the embryologists
had been pondering
108
322862
2698
05:37
the mysteries of heart development.
109
325584
1682
05:39
And they had given us
what was essentially a Google Map
110
327290
3357
05:42
for how to go from a single fertilized egg
111
330671
2480
05:45
all the way over to a human
cardiovascular system.
112
333175
3101
05:48
So we shamelessly absconded
all of this information
113
336656
3731
05:52
and tried to make human cardiovascular
development happen in a dish.
114
340411
4148
05:57
It took us about five years, but nowadays,
115
345105
2466
05:59
we can get 90 percent of our stem cells
to turn into cardiac muscle --
116
347595
3591
06:03
a 900-fold improvement.
117
351210
2073
06:05
So this was quite exciting.
118
353671
1500
06:08
This slide shows you
our current cellular product.
119
356112
2910
06:11
We grow our heart muscle cells
in little three-dimensional clumps
120
359466
3289
06:14
called cardiac organoids.
121
362779
1510
06:16
Each of them has 500 to 1,000
heart muscle cells in it.
122
364313
3143
06:20
If you look closely, you can see these
little organoids are actually twitching;
123
368003
3807
06:23
each one is beating independently.
124
371834
1807
06:26
But they've got another trick
up their sleeve.
125
374094
2143
06:28
We took a gene from jellyfish
that live in the Pacific Northwest,
126
376793
3171
06:31
and we used a technique
called genome editing
127
379988
2400
06:34
to splice this gene into the stem cells.
128
382412
3014
06:37
And this makes our heart muscle cells
flash green every time they beat.
129
385450
4425
06:41
OK, so now we were finally ready
to begin animal experiments.
130
389899
3689
06:45
We took our cardiac muscle cells
131
393612
2361
06:47
and we transplanted them
into the hearts of rats
132
395997
2274
06:50
that had been given
experimental heart attacks.
133
398295
2222
06:52
A month later, I peered anxiously
down through my microscope
134
400541
3552
06:56
to see what we had grown,
135
404117
1891
06:58
and I saw ...
136
406032
1305
06:59
nothing.
137
407807
1165
07:01
Everything had died.
138
409616
1767
07:03
But we persevered on this,
and we came up with a biochemical cocktail
139
411407
3948
07:07
that we called
our "pro-survival cocktail,"
140
415379
2304
07:09
and this was enough to allow
our cells to survive
141
417707
2623
07:12
through the stressful process
of transplantation.
142
420354
3078
07:15
And now when I looked
through the microscope,
143
423456
2150
07:17
I could see this fresh, young,
human heart muscle
144
425630
2515
07:20
growing back in the injured wall
of this rat's heart.
145
428169
3049
07:23
So this was getting quite exciting.
146
431750
1793
07:25
The next question was:
147
433567
1539
07:27
Will this new muscle beat in synchrony
with the rest of the heart?
148
435130
3617
07:31
So to answer that,
149
439453
1161
07:32
we returned to the cells that had
that jellyfish gene in them.
150
440638
4026
07:37
We used these cells essentially
like a space probe
151
445330
3127
07:40
that we could launch
into a foreign environment
152
448481
2240
07:42
and then have that flashing
report back to us
153
450745
2320
07:45
about their biological activity.
154
453089
2058
07:47
What you're seeing here
is a zoomed-in view,
155
455171
2081
07:49
a black-and-white image
of a guinea pig's heart
156
457276
2222
07:51
that was injured and then received
three grafts of our human cardiac muscle.
157
459522
3601
07:55
So you see those sort of diagonally
running white lines.
158
463147
2642
07:57
Each of those is a needle track
159
465813
1486
07:59
that contains a couple of million
human cardiac muscle cells in it.
160
467323
3696
08:03
And when I start the video,
you can see what we saw
161
471713
2754
08:06
when we looked through the microscope.
162
474491
2020
08:09
Our cells are flashing,
163
477011
1563
08:10
and they're flashing in synchrony,
164
478598
2025
08:12
back through the walls
of the injured heart.
165
480647
2089
08:15
What does this mean?
166
483117
1151
08:16
It means the cells are alive,
167
484292
1484
08:17
they're well, they're beating,
168
485800
2148
08:19
and they've managed
to connect with one another
169
487972
2229
08:22
so that they're beating in synchrony.
170
490225
2072
08:24
But it gets even more
interesting than this.
171
492321
2115
08:26
If you look at that tracing
that's along the bottom,
172
494460
2443
08:28
that's the electrocardiogram
from the guinea pig's own heart.
173
496927
3345
08:32
And if you line up the flashing
with the heartbeat
174
500296
3153
08:35
that's shown on the bottom,
175
503473
1300
08:36
what you can see is there's a perfect
one-to-one correspondence.
176
504797
3187
08:40
In other words, the guinea pig's
natural pacemaker is calling the shots,
177
508008
4466
08:44
and the human heart muscle cells
are following in lockstep
178
512498
2984
08:47
like good soldiers.
179
515506
1488
08:49
(Applause)
180
517922
4616
08:56
Our current studies have moved into
what I think is going to be
181
524017
3000
08:59
the best possible predictor
of a human patient,
182
527041
2661
09:01
and that's into macaque monkeys.
183
529726
2117
09:05
This next slide shows you
a microscopic image
184
533350
3096
09:08
from the heart of a macaque that was given
an experimental heart attack
185
536470
4442
09:12
and then treated with a saline injection.
186
540936
2079
09:15
This is essentially like
a placebo treatment
187
543039
2233
09:17
to show the natural history
of the disease.
188
545296
2165
09:19
The macaque heart muscle is shown in red,
189
547485
2268
09:21
and in blue, you see the scar tissue
that results from the heart attack.
190
549777
3504
09:25
So as you look as this, you can see how
there's a big deficiency in the muscle
191
553305
3882
09:29
in part of the wall of the heart.
192
557211
1918
09:31
And it's not hard to imagine
how this heart would have a tough time
193
559153
3243
09:34
generating much force.
194
562420
1468
09:37
Now in contrast, this is one
of the stem-cell-treated hearts.
195
565105
3376
09:41
Again, you can see
the monkey's heart muscle in red,
196
569290
3935
09:45
but it's very hard to even see
the blue scar tissue,
197
573249
2707
09:47
and that's because we've
been able to repopulate it
198
575980
3120
09:51
with the human heart muscle,
199
579124
1864
09:53
and so we've got this nice, plump wall.
200
581012
2182
09:55
OK, let's just take a second and recap.
201
583218
2118
09:57
I've showed you
that we can take our stem cells
202
585678
2534
10:00
and differentiate them
into cardiac muscle.
203
588236
2512
10:02
We've learned how to keep them alive
after transplantation,
204
590772
3200
10:05
we've showed that they beat
in synchrony with the rest of the heart,
205
593996
3255
10:09
and we've shown that we can scale them up
206
597275
1995
10:11
into an animal that is the best possible
predictor of a human's response.
207
599294
4350
10:16
You'd think that we hit all the roadblocks
that lay in our path, right?
208
604592
5763
10:23
Turns out, not.
209
611141
1190
10:24
These macaque studies also taught us
210
612982
2395
10:27
that our human heart muscle cells created
a period of electrical instability.
211
615401
4703
10:32
They caused ventricular arrhythmias,
or irregular heartbeats,
212
620128
3581
10:35
for several weeks after
we transplanted them.
213
623733
2264
10:39
This was quite unexpected, because
we hadn't seen this in smaller animals.
214
627038
3577
10:43
We've studied it extensively,
215
631266
1787
10:45
and it turns out that it results
from the fact that our cellular graphs
216
633077
3988
10:49
are quite immature,
217
637089
1538
10:50
and immature heart muscle cells
all act like pacemakers.
218
638651
3582
10:54
So what happens is,
we put them into the heart,
219
642257
2395
10:56
and there starts to be a competition
with the heart's natural pacemaker
220
644676
3445
11:00
over who gets to call the shots.
221
648145
1619
11:02
It would be sort of like
222
650502
1163
11:03
if you brought a whole gaggle of teenagers
into your orderly household all at once,
223
651689
4617
11:08
and they don't want to follow the rules
and the rhythms of the way you run things,
224
656330
4137
11:12
and it takes a while to rein everybody in
225
660491
1972
11:14
and get people working
in a coordinated fashion.
226
662487
2477
11:17
So our plans at the moment
227
665471
1249
11:18
are to make the cells go through
this troubled adolescence period
228
666744
3143
11:21
while they're still in the dish,
229
669911
1982
11:23
and then we'll transplant them in
in the post-adolescent phase,
230
671917
4421
11:28
where they should be much more orderly
231
676362
1970
11:30
and be ready to listen
to their marching orders.
232
678356
2730
11:33
In the meantime, it turns out
we can actually do quite well
233
681110
2804
11:35
by treating with
anti-arrhythmia drugs as well.
234
683938
2404
11:39
So one big question still remains,
235
687064
2590
11:41
and that is, of course, the whole purpose
that we set out to do this:
236
689678
3289
11:44
Can we actually restore function
to the injured heart?
237
692991
3322
11:49
To answer this question,
238
697218
1260
11:50
we went to something that's called
"left ventricular ejection fraction."
239
698502
3766
11:54
Ejection fraction is simply
the amount of blood
240
702292
2330
11:56
that is squeezed
out of the chamber of the heart
241
704646
2366
11:59
with each beat.
242
707036
1172
12:00
Now, in healthy macaques,
like in healthy people,
243
708232
2459
12:02
ejection fractions are about 65 percent.
244
710715
2470
12:05
After a heart attack, ejection fraction
drops down to about 40 percent,
245
713748
4120
12:09
so these animals are
well on their way to heart failure.
246
717892
2834
12:12
In the animals that receive
a placebo injection,
247
720750
2275
12:15
when we scan them a month later,
248
723049
1575
12:16
we see that ejection
fraction is unchanged,
249
724648
2289
12:18
because the heart, of course,
doesn't spontaneously recover.
250
726961
2861
12:22
But in every one of the animals
that received a graft
251
730489
2783
12:25
of human cardiac muscle cells,
252
733296
1711
12:27
we see a substantial improvement
in cardiac function.
253
735031
2998
12:30
This averaged eight points,
so from 40 to 48 percent.
254
738053
3934
12:34
What I can tell you
is that eight points is better
255
742011
3056
12:37
than anything that's
on the market right now
256
745091
2328
12:39
for treating patients with heart attacks.
257
747443
2011
12:41
It's better than everything
we have put together.
258
749478
2729
12:44
So if we could do
eight points in the clinic,
259
752231
2153
12:46
I think this would be a big deal
that would make a large impact
260
754408
3011
12:49
on human health.
261
757443
1186
12:51
But it gets more exciting.
262
759137
3581
12:54
That was just four weeks
after transplantation.
263
762742
2679
12:57
If we extend these studies
out to three months,
264
765445
2900
13:00
we get a full 22-point gain
in ejection fraction.
265
768369
4062
13:04
(Applause)
266
772455
3998
13:11
Function in these
treated hearts is so good
267
779874
2450
13:14
that if we didn't know up front
that these animals had had a heart attack,
268
782348
3830
13:18
we would never be able to tell
from their functional studies.
269
786202
5476
13:24
Going forward, our plan
is to start phase one,
270
792757
3654
13:28
first in human trials here at
the University of Washington in 2020 --
271
796435
3645
13:32
two short years from now.
272
800104
1992
13:34
Presuming these studies
are safe and effective,
273
802834
3068
13:37
which I think they're going to be,
274
805926
1946
13:39
our plan is to scale this up
and ship these cells all around the world
275
807896
4141
13:44
for the treatment of patients
with heart disease.
276
812061
2300
13:46
Given the global burden of this illness,
277
814996
1962
13:48
I could easily imagine this treating
a million or more patients a year.
278
816982
3548
13:52
So I envision a time,
maybe a decade from now,
279
820916
2656
13:55
where a patient like my mother
will have actual treatments
280
823596
3209
13:58
that can address the root cause
and not just manage her symptoms.
281
826829
4114
14:02
This all comes from the fact
that stem cells give us the ability
282
830967
3072
14:06
to repair the human body
283
834063
1699
14:07
from its component parts.
284
835786
2210
14:10
In the not-too-distant future,
285
838774
2091
14:12
repairing humans is going to go
286
840889
3087
14:16
from something that is
far-fetched science fiction
287
844000
3220
14:19
into common medical practice.
288
847244
2267
14:22
And when this happens,
289
850043
1329
14:23
it's going to have
a transformational effect
290
851396
2078
14:25
that rivals the development
of vaccinations and antibiotics.
291
853498
3769
14:30
Thank you for your attention.
292
858148
1447
14:31
(Applause)
293
859619
2613

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Chuck Murry - Physician, scientist
Chuck Murry founded and currently directs the Institute for Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine at the University of Washington.

Why you should listen

Heart failure -- now the number one cause of death worldwide -- is the motivation behind Dr. Chuck Murry's specialized research into innovative treatments. Murry believes that it's not enough simply to help patients who are plagued with chronic disease survive. Instead, his pioneering work seeks to harness the potential of human stem cells to eliminate the disease from the body.

More profile about the speaker
Chuck Murry | Speaker | TED.com