ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Monique W. Morris - Author, social justice scholar
As Monique W. Morris writes: "I believe in a justice not associated with any form of oppression. I work for it and I write about it."

Why you should listen

Monique W. Morris, EdD, founded and leads the National Black Women's Justice Institute, an organization that works to transform public discourses on the criminalization of Black women, girls and their families. For three decades, she has been involved in social justice advocacy and scholarship, working with research and academic institutions, civil rights organizations, nonprofits, public agencies and activists to advance policies and practices that promote racial and gender equity. She's the author of Pushout: The Criminalization of Black Girls in Schools and other books, publications and articles.

As Morris writes: "My work is ultimately about using research and narratives to challenge actions and structures of oppression. I do this using the tools I have available to me as a researcher, educator, public intellectual, visual artist, writer -- and most recently, filmmaker. I am the author of several academic publications and four books, each of them very different. From a street novel about prostitution to a statistical narrative about African Americans in the 21st century to a book about the criminalization of Black girls in schools, I try to meet people where they are on this journey toward freedom. My latest project, a dive into the pedagogical practices that make education freedom work, explores how schools might become locations of healing for Black and Brown girls. And I love Prince. Always have, always will."

More profile about the speaker
Monique W. Morris | Speaker | TED.com
TEDWomen 2018

Monique W. Morris: Why black girls are targeted for punishment at school -- and how to change that

Filmed:
1,712,241 views

Around the world, black girls are being pushed out of schools because of policies that target them for punishment, says author and social justice scholar Monique W. Morris. The result: countless girls are forced into unsafe futures with restricted opportunities. How can we put an end to this crisis? In an impassioned talk, Morris uncovers the causes of "pushout" and shows how we can work to turn all schools into spaces where black girls can heal and thrive.
- Author, social justice scholar
As Monique W. Morris writes: "I believe in a justice not associated with any form of oppression. I work for it and I write about it." Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
When I was in the sixth grade,
I got into a fight at school.
0
680
3280
00:16
It wasn't the first time
I'd been in a fight,
1
4880
2256
00:19
but it was the first time
one happened at school.
2
7160
2480
00:22
It was with a boy who was
about a foot taller than me,
3
10320
3536
00:25
who was physically stronger than me
4
13880
1936
00:27
and who'd been taunting me for weeks.
5
15840
2240
00:31
One day in PE, he stepped on my shoe
and refused to apologize.
6
19000
4816
00:35
So, filled with anger, I grabbed him
and I threw him to the ground.
7
23840
4456
00:40
I'd had some previous judo training.
8
28320
1736
00:42
(Laughter)
9
30080
2880
00:46
Our fight lasted less than two minutes,
10
34920
3016
00:49
but it was a perfect
reflection of the hurricane
11
37960
2256
00:52
that was building inside of me
12
40240
1896
00:54
as a young survivor of sexual assault
13
42160
2056
00:56
and as a girl who was grappling
with abandonment
14
44240
2376
00:58
and exposure to violence
in other spaces in my life.
15
46640
3096
01:01
I was fighting him,
16
49760
1536
01:03
but I was also fighting the men
and boys that had assaulted my body
17
51320
3816
01:07
and the culture that told me
I had to be silent about it.
18
55160
3200
01:11
A teacher broke up the fight
19
59240
1576
01:12
and my principle called me in her office.
20
60840
2536
01:15
But she didn't say,
"Monique, what's wrong with you?"
21
63400
2480
01:19
She gave me a moment to collect my breath
22
67480
3136
01:22
and asked, "What happened?"
23
70640
1960
01:26
The educators working with me
led with empathy.
24
74440
2976
01:29
They knew me.
25
77440
1216
01:30
They knew I loved to read,
they knew I loved to draw,
26
78680
3296
01:34
they knew I adored Prince.
27
82000
1800
01:37
And they used that information
to help me understand
28
85040
2816
01:39
why my actions, and those
of my classmate, were disruptive
29
87880
2816
01:42
to the learning community
they were leading.
30
90720
2080
01:45
They didn't place me on suspension;
31
93760
2536
01:48
they didn't call the police.
32
96320
1560
01:50
My fight didn't keep me
from going to school the next day.
33
98680
2720
01:54
It didn't keep me from graduating;
it didn't keep me from teaching.
34
102520
3400
02:00
But unfortunately, that's not a story
that's shared by many black girls
35
108120
3816
02:03
in the US and around the world today.
36
111960
1800
02:06
We're living through a crisis
in which black girls
37
114640
2376
02:09
are being disproportionately pushed
away from schools ---
38
117040
2736
02:11
not because of an imminent threat
they pose to the safety of a school,
39
119800
3576
02:15
but because they're often
experiencing schools
40
123400
2176
02:17
as locations for punishment
and marginalization.
41
125600
2800
02:21
That's something that I hear
from black girls around the country.
42
129160
4496
02:25
But it's not insurmountable.
43
133680
1976
02:27
We can shift this narrative.
44
135680
1560
02:30
Let's start with some data.
45
138640
1640
02:33
According to a National Black Women's
Justice Institute analysis
46
141400
3056
02:36
of civil rights data
47
144480
1216
02:37
collected by the US
Department of Education,
48
145720
2976
02:40
black girls are the only group of girls
who are overrepresented
49
148720
2976
02:43
along the entire continuum
of discipline in schools.
50
151720
2440
02:47
That doesn't mean that other girls aren't
experiencing exclusionary discipline
51
155360
4096
02:51
and it doesn't mean that other girls
aren't overrepresented
52
159480
3616
02:55
at other parts along that continuum.
53
163120
2296
02:57
But black girls
are the only group of girls
54
165440
2016
02:59
who are overrepresented all along the way.
55
167480
2000
03:02
Black girls are seven times more likely
than their white counterparts
56
170960
4136
03:07
to experience one or more
out-of-school suspensions
57
175120
2696
03:09
and they're nearly three times more likely
than their white and Latinx counterparts
58
177840
4096
03:13
to be referred to the juvenile court.
59
181960
2040
03:16
A recent study by the Georgetown
Center on Poverty and Inequality
60
184720
3976
03:20
partially explained
why this disparity is taking place
61
188720
3136
03:23
when they confirmed
that black girls experience
62
191880
2256
03:26
a specific type of age compression,
63
194160
2376
03:28
where they're seen as more adult-like
than their white peers.
64
196560
3120
03:32
Among other things, the study found
65
200640
2016
03:34
that people perceive black girls
to need less nurturing,
66
202680
4056
03:38
less protection, to know more about sex
67
206760
3016
03:41
and to be more independent
than their white peers.
68
209800
3000
03:46
The study also found
69
214120
1696
03:47
that the perception disparity begins
when girls are as young as five years old.
70
215840
5736
03:53
And that this perception
and the disparity increases over time
71
221600
4216
03:57
and peaks when girls are
between the ages of 10 and 14.
72
225840
3080
04:01
This is not without consequence.
73
229920
1800
04:05
Believing that a girl is older than she is
can lead to harsher treatment,
74
233000
4456
04:09
immediate censure when she makes a mistake
75
237480
2616
04:12
and victim blaming when she's harmed.
76
240120
2160
04:15
It can also lead a girl to think
that something is wrong with her,
77
243200
3296
04:18
rather than the conditions
in which she finds herself.
78
246520
2560
04:22
Black girls are routinely seen
as too loud, too aggressive,
79
250880
3896
04:26
too angry, too visible.
80
254800
1880
04:29
Qualities that are often measured
in relation to nonblack girls
81
257560
3456
04:33
and which don't take into consideration
what's going on in this girl's life
82
261040
3936
04:37
or her cultural norms.
83
265000
2016
04:39
And it's not just in the US.
84
267040
1976
04:41
In South Africa,
85
269040
1576
04:42
black girls at the Pretoria
Girls High School
86
270640
2136
04:44
were discouraged from attending school
with their hair in its natural state,
87
272800
3616
04:48
without chemical processing.
88
276440
1816
04:50
What did those girls do?
89
278280
1616
04:51
They protested.
90
279920
1320
04:54
And it was a beautiful thing to see
the global community for the most part
91
282080
3496
04:57
wrap its arms around girls
as they stood in their truths.
92
285600
2920
05:01
But there were those
who saw them as disruptive,
93
289320
2336
05:03
largely because they dared
to ask the question,
94
291680
2656
05:06
"Where can we be black
if we can't be black in Africa?"
95
294360
3016
05:09
(Laughter)
96
297400
1856
05:11
(Applause)
97
299280
2336
05:13
It's a good question.
98
301640
1440
05:16
Around the world,
99
304400
2176
05:18
black girls are grappling
with this question.
100
306600
2120
05:21
And around the world,
101
309520
1816
05:23
black girls are struggling to be seen,
working to be free
102
311360
3496
05:26
and fighting to be included
103
314880
1616
05:28
in the landscape of promise
that a safe space to learn provides.
104
316520
3400
05:32
In the US, little girls,
just past their toddler years,
105
320800
3256
05:36
are being arrested in classrooms
for having a tantrum.
106
324080
2720
05:39
Middle school girls are being
turned away from school
107
327520
2976
05:42
because of the way
they wear their hair naturally
108
330520
2776
05:45
or because of the way
the clothes fit their bodies.
109
333320
2400
05:48
High school girls
are experiencing violence
110
336520
2056
05:50
at the hands of police
officers in schools.
111
338600
2480
05:53
Where can black girls be black
without reprimand or punishment?
112
341760
4320
06:00
And it's not just these incidents.
113
348120
2616
06:02
In my work as a researcher and educator,
114
350760
2056
06:04
I've had an opportunity
to work with girls like Stacy,
115
352840
3376
06:08
a girl who I profile in my book "Pushout,"
116
356240
2536
06:10
who struggles with
her participation in violence.
117
358800
2960
06:15
She bypasses the neuroscientific
and structural analyses
118
363360
4776
06:20
that science has to offer
119
368160
1416
06:21
about how her adverse
childhood experiences inform
120
369600
3416
06:25
why she's participating in violence
121
373040
2056
06:27
and goes straight to describing herself
as a "problem child,"
122
375120
3256
06:30
largely because that's the language
that educators were using
123
378400
2896
06:33
as they routinely suspended her.
124
381320
1880
06:37
But here's the thing.
125
385360
1616
06:39
Disconnection and the internalization
of harm grow stronger in isolation.
126
387000
5216
06:44
So when girls get in trouble,
we shouldn't be pushing them away,
127
392240
3056
06:47
we should be bringing them in closer.
128
395320
1800
06:50
Education is a critical protective factor
129
398520
2216
06:52
against contact
with the criminal legal system.
130
400760
2560
06:56
So we should be building
out policies and practices
131
404400
2416
06:58
that keep girls connected
to their learning,
132
406840
2096
07:00
rather than pushing them away from it.
133
408960
1856
07:02
It's one of the reasons I like to say
that education is freedom work.
134
410840
3960
07:08
When girls feel safe, they can learn.
135
416680
2480
07:12
When they don't feel safe, they fight,
136
420280
2616
07:14
they protest, they argue,
they flee, they freeze.
137
422920
5000
07:21
The human brain is wired
to protect us when we feel a threat.
138
429120
3216
07:24
And so long as school feels like a threat,
139
432360
2056
07:26
or part of the tapestry of harm
in a girl's life,
140
434440
2736
07:29
she'll be inclined to resist.
141
437200
1960
07:31
But when schools become
locations for healing,
142
439920
3216
07:35
they can also become
locations for learning.
143
443160
2240
07:38
So what does this mean for a school
to become a location for healing?
144
446720
3736
07:42
Well, for one thing, it means
that we have to immediately discontinue
145
450480
3256
07:45
the policies and practices that target
black girls for their hairstyles or dress.
146
453760
4376
07:50
(Applause)
147
458160
5936
07:56
Let's focus on how
and what a girl learns
148
464120
4056
08:00
rather than policing her body
in ways that facilitate rape culture
149
468200
3856
08:04
or punish children for the conditions
in which they were born.
150
472080
3000
08:08
This is where parents and the community
of concerned adults can enter this work.
151
476960
3800
08:13
Start a conversation with the school
152
481680
1816
08:15
and encourage them
to address their dress code
153
483520
2696
08:18
and other conduct-related policies
as a collaborative project,
154
486240
3136
08:21
with parents and students,
155
489400
1936
08:23
so as to intentionally avoid
bias and discrimination.
156
491360
3200
08:27
Keep in mind, though,
157
495480
1216
08:28
that some of the practices
that harm black girls most are unwritten.
158
496720
3216
08:31
So we have to continue to do the deep,
internal work to address the biases
159
499960
4296
08:36
that inform how, when and whether we see
black girls for who they actually are,
160
504280
4656
08:40
or what we've been told they are.
161
508960
1600
08:44
Volunteer at a school
162
512159
2097
08:46
and establish culturally competent
and gender responsive discussion groups
163
514280
4816
08:51
with black girls,
Latinas, indigenous girls
164
519120
2976
08:54
and other students who experience
marginalization in schools
165
522120
3456
08:57
to give them a safe space
166
525600
1256
08:58
to process their identities
and experiences in schools.
167
526880
3040
09:03
And if schools are to become
locations for healing,
168
531000
2736
09:05
we have to remove police officers
169
533760
2176
09:07
and increase the number
of counselors in schools.
170
535960
2576
09:10
(Applause)
171
538560
6080
09:18
Education is freedom work.
172
546520
2400
09:22
And whatever our point of entry is,
we all have to be freedom fighters.
173
550160
3840
09:27
The good news is that there are schools
174
555160
1896
09:29
that are actively working
to establish themselves
175
557080
2576
09:31
as locations for girls
to see themselves as sacred and loved.
176
559680
3720
09:36
The Columbus City Prep School for Girls
in Columbus, Ohio, is an example of this.
177
564360
5136
09:41
They became an example
the moment their principal declared
178
569520
2736
09:44
that they were no longer going to punish
girls for having "a bad attitude."
179
572280
3560
09:49
In addition to building --
180
577320
2456
09:51
Essentially, what they did
is they built out a robust continuum
181
579800
2976
09:54
of alternatives to suspension,
expulsion and arrest.
182
582800
3456
09:58
In addition to establishing
a restorative justice program,
183
586280
4056
10:02
they improved their
student and teacher relationships
184
590360
2496
10:04
by ensuring that every girl
has at least one adult on campus
185
592880
2936
10:07
that she can go to
when she's in a moment of crisis.
186
595840
2896
10:10
They built out spaces along the corridors
of the school and in classrooms
187
598760
3456
10:14
for girls to regroup,
if they need a minute to do so.
188
602240
2480
10:17
And they established an advisory program
that provides girls with an opportunity
189
605400
3816
10:21
to start every single day
with the promotion of self-worth,
190
609240
4216
10:25
communication skills and goal setting.
191
613480
2160
10:28
At this school,
192
616440
1256
10:29
they're trying to respond
to a girl's adverse childhood experiences
193
617720
3616
10:33
rather than ignore them.
194
621360
1496
10:34
They bring them in closer;
they don't push them away.
195
622880
2840
10:38
And as a result, their truancy
and suspension rates have improved,
196
626520
3376
10:41
and girls are arriving at school
increasingly ready to learn
197
629920
3016
10:44
because they know the teachers
there care about them.
198
632960
2736
10:47
That matters.
199
635720
1200
10:49
Schools that integrate the arts
and sports into their curriculum
200
637960
3336
10:53
or that are building out
tranformative programming,
201
641320
2776
10:56
such as restorative justice,
mindfulness and meditation,
202
644120
3736
10:59
are providing an opportunity for girls
to repair their relationships with others,
203
647880
4736
11:04
but also with themselves.
204
652640
1880
11:07
Responding to the lived,
complex and historical trauma
205
655360
3536
11:10
that our students face
206
658920
1496
11:12
requires all of us who believe
in the promise of children and adolescents
207
660440
4536
11:17
to build relationships,
learning materials,
208
665000
3136
11:20
human and financial resources
and other tools
209
668160
3576
11:23
that provide children with an opportunity
to heal, so that they can learn.
210
671760
4360
11:30
Our schools should be places where
we respond to our most vulnerable girls
211
678360
4536
11:34
as essential to the creation
of a positive school culture.
212
682920
3600
11:40
Our ability to see her promise
should be at its sharpest
213
688080
3616
11:43
when she's in the throws
of poverty and addiction;
214
691720
2856
11:46
when she's reeling
from having been sex-trafficked
215
694600
2376
11:49
or survived other forms of violence;
216
697000
2576
11:51
when she's at her loudest,
217
699600
2656
11:54
or her quietest.
218
702280
1200
11:57
We should be able
to support her intellectual
219
705280
2496
11:59
and social-emotional well-being
220
707800
2016
12:01
whether her shorts reach her knees
or stop mid-thigh or higher.
221
709840
3960
12:08
It might seem like a tall order in a world
222
716680
2376
12:11
so deeply entrenched
in the politics of fear
223
719080
2456
12:13
to radically imagine schools as locations
where girls can heal and thrive,
224
721560
4776
12:18
but we have to be bold enough
to set this as our intention.
225
726360
2800
12:22
If we commit to this notion
of education as freedom work,
226
730400
3896
12:26
we can shift educational conditions
227
734320
2296
12:28
so that no girl, even the most
vulnerable among us,
228
736640
3656
12:32
will get pushed out of school.
229
740320
1696
12:34
And that's a win for all of us.
230
742040
2576
12:36
Thank you.
231
744640
1256
12:37
(Applause)
232
745920
5840

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Monique W. Morris - Author, social justice scholar
As Monique W. Morris writes: "I believe in a justice not associated with any form of oppression. I work for it and I write about it."

Why you should listen

Monique W. Morris, EdD, founded and leads the National Black Women's Justice Institute, an organization that works to transform public discourses on the criminalization of Black women, girls and their families. For three decades, she has been involved in social justice advocacy and scholarship, working with research and academic institutions, civil rights organizations, nonprofits, public agencies and activists to advance policies and practices that promote racial and gender equity. She's the author of Pushout: The Criminalization of Black Girls in Schools and other books, publications and articles.

As Morris writes: "My work is ultimately about using research and narratives to challenge actions and structures of oppression. I do this using the tools I have available to me as a researcher, educator, public intellectual, visual artist, writer -- and most recently, filmmaker. I am the author of several academic publications and four books, each of them very different. From a street novel about prostitution to a statistical narrative about African Americans in the 21st century to a book about the criminalization of Black girls in schools, I try to meet people where they are on this journey toward freedom. My latest project, a dive into the pedagogical practices that make education freedom work, explores how schools might become locations of healing for Black and Brown girls. And I love Prince. Always have, always will."

More profile about the speaker
Monique W. Morris | Speaker | TED.com