ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Karen Lloyd - Marine microbiologist
Karen Lloyd studies novel groups of microbes in Earth's deep surface biosphere, collecting them from disparate remote places such as Arctic fjords, volcanoes in Costa Rica, even deep in mud in the Marianas Trench

Why you should listen

Karen G. Lloyd applies molecular biological techniques to environmental samples to learn more about microbes that have thus far evaded attempts to be cultured in a laboratory. She has adapted novel techniques to quantify and characterize these mysterious microbes while requiring minimal changes to their natural conditions. Her work centers on deep oceanic subsurface sediments, deep-sea mud volcanoes and cold seeps, terrestrial volcanoes and hot springs, serpentinizing springs, Arctic marine fjord sediments and ancient permafrost. She is currently an Assistant Professor at the University of Tennessee. 

More profile about the speaker
Karen Lloyd | Speaker | TED.com
TED2019

Karen Lloyd: The mysterious microbes living deep inside the earth -- and how they could help humanity

Filmed:
1,779,249 views

The ground beneath your feet is home to a massive, mysterious world of microbes -- some of which have been in the earth's crust for hundreds of thousands of years. What's it like down there? Take a trip to the volcanoes and hot springs of Costa Rica as microbiologist Karen Lloyd shines a light on these subterranean organisms and shows how they could have a profound impact on life up here.
- Marine microbiologist
Karen Lloyd studies novel groups of microbes in Earth's deep surface biosphere, collecting them from disparate remote places such as Arctic fjords, volcanoes in Costa Rica, even deep in mud in the Marianas Trench Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
It may seem like we're all standing
on solid earth right now,
0
667
3286
00:15
but we're not.
1
3977
1373
00:17
The rocks and the dirt underneath us
are crisscrossed by tiny little fractures
2
5753
4397
00:22
and empty spaces.
3
10174
1399
00:23
And these empty spaces are filled
with astronomical quantities of microbes,
4
11597
4929
00:28
such as these ones.
5
16550
1267
00:30
The deepest that we found microbes
so far into the earth
6
18866
3363
00:34
is five kilometers down.
7
22253
1888
00:36
So like, if you pointed
yourself at the ground
8
24165
2156
00:38
and took off running into the ground,
9
26345
2319
00:40
you could run an entire 5K race
and microbes would line your whole path.
10
28688
3671
00:45
So you may not have ever thought
about these microbes
11
33044
2524
00:47
that are deep inside earth's crust,
12
35592
1690
00:49
but you probably thought
about the microbes living in our guts.
13
37306
2962
00:52
If you add up the gut microbiomes
14
40292
1817
00:54
of all the people
and all the animals on the planet,
15
42133
2841
00:56
collectively, this weighs
about 100,000 tons.
16
44998
3909
01:00
This is a huge biome that we carry
in our bellies every single day.
17
48931
4293
01:05
We should all be proud.
18
53907
1417
01:07
(Laughter)
19
55348
1106
01:08
But it pales in comparison
to the number of microbes
20
56478
3872
01:12
that are covering
the entire surface of the earth,
21
60374
2485
01:14
like in our soils,
our rivers and our oceans.
22
62883
2831
01:17
Collectively, these weigh
about two billion tons.
23
65738
3873
01:22
But it turns out that the majority
of microbes on earth
24
70174
2596
01:24
aren't even in oceans or our guts
or sewage treatment plants.
25
72794
3777
01:28
Most of them are actually
inside the earth's crust.
26
76595
2777
01:31
So collectively,
these weigh 40 billion tons.
27
79396
3849
01:35
This is one of the biggest
biomes on the planet,
28
83754
3291
01:39
and we didn't even know it existed
until a few decades ago.
29
87069
3436
01:42
So the possibilities
for what life is like down there,
30
90847
2695
01:45
or what it might do for humans,
31
93566
2545
01:48
are limitless.
32
96135
1700
01:50
This is a map showing a red dot
33
98367
1872
01:52
for every place where we've gotten
pretty good deep subsurface samples
34
100263
3358
01:55
with modern microbiological methods,
35
103645
1818
01:57
and you may be impressed
36
105487
1383
01:58
that we're getting a pretty good
global coverage,
37
106894
2310
02:01
but actually, if you remember
that these are the only places
38
109228
2857
02:04
that we have samples from,
it looks a little worse.
39
112109
2381
02:06
If we were all in an alien spaceship,
40
114514
1809
02:08
trying to reconstruct a map of the globe
from only these samples,
41
116347
3659
02:12
we'd never be able to do it.
42
120030
2322
02:15
So people sometimes say to me,
43
123218
2301
02:17
"Yeah, there's a lot of microbes
in the subsurface, but ...
44
125543
3516
02:21
aren't they just kind of dormant?"
45
129083
1650
02:23
This is a good point.
46
131710
1517
02:25
Relative to a ficus plant or the measles
or my kid's guinea pigs,
47
133251
4850
02:30
these microbes probably
aren't doing much of anything at all.
48
138125
3031
02:33
We know that they have to be slow,
because there's so many of them.
49
141180
3826
02:37
If they all started dividing
at the rate of E. coli,
50
145030
2690
02:39
then they would double the entire
weight of the earth, rocks included,
51
147744
3317
02:43
over a single night.
52
151085
1476
02:45
In fact, many of them probably haven't
even undergone a single cell division
53
153046
4533
02:49
since the time of ancient Egypt.
54
157603
2133
02:52
Which is just crazy.
55
160180
1460
02:53
Like, how do you wrap your head
around things that are so long-lived?
56
161664
5578
02:59
But I thought of an analogy
that I really love,
57
167266
3144
03:02
but it's weird and it's complicated.
58
170434
1821
03:04
So I hope that you can all
go there with me.
59
172279
2171
03:06
Alright, let's try it.
60
174474
1246
03:08
It's like trying to figure out
the life cycle of a tree ...
61
176299
2849
03:11
if you only lived for a day.
62
179172
1945
03:13
So like if human life span was only a day,
and we lived in winter,
63
181141
4381
03:17
then you would go your entire life
64
185546
1625
03:19
without ever seeing a tree
with a leaf on it.
65
187195
2573
03:21
And there would be so many
human generations
66
189792
2055
03:23
that would pass by within a single winter
67
191871
2024
03:25
that you may not even have access
to a history book
68
193919
2396
03:28
that says anything other than the fact
that trees are always lifeless sticks
69
196339
3802
03:32
that don't do anything.
70
200165
1531
03:33
Of course, this is ridiculous.
71
201720
1659
03:35
We know that trees
are just waiting for summer
72
203403
2150
03:37
so they can reactivate.
73
205577
1349
03:38
But if the human life span
74
206950
2175
03:41
were significantly shorter
than that of trees,
75
209149
3079
03:44
we might be completely oblivious
to this totally mundane fact.
76
212252
3855
03:48
So when we say that these deep
subsurface microbes are just dormant,
77
216879
4928
03:53
are we like people who die after a day,
trying to figure out how trees work?
78
221831
4172
03:58
What if these deep subsurface organisms
79
226601
1890
04:00
are just waiting
for their version of summer,
80
228515
2307
04:02
but our lives are too short
for us to see it?
81
230846
3067
04:06
If you take E. coli
and seal it up in a test tube,
82
234784
3540
04:10
with no food or nutrients,
83
238348
1342
04:11
and leave it there for months to years,
84
239714
2468
04:14
most of the cells die off, of course,
because they're starving.
85
242206
3016
04:17
But a few of the cells survive.
86
245246
2306
04:19
If you take these old surviving cells
87
247576
2190
04:21
and compete them,
also under starvation conditions,
88
249790
2867
04:24
against a new, fast-growing
culture of E. coli,
89
252681
3174
04:27
the grizzled old tough guys
beat out the squeaky clean upstarts
90
255879
3739
04:31
every single time.
91
259642
1348
04:33
So this is evidence there's actually
an evolutionary payoff
92
261339
4603
04:37
to being extraordinarily slow.
93
265966
2214
04:40
So it's possible
94
268736
1889
04:42
that maybe we should not equate
being slow with being unimportant.
95
270649
6740
04:50
Maybe these out-of-sight,
out-of-mind microbes
96
278402
2682
04:53
could actually be helpful to humanity.
97
281108
2207
04:56
OK, so as far as we know,
98
284125
1282
04:57
there are two ways to do
subsurface living.
99
285431
2106
04:59
The first is to wait for food
to trickle down from the surface world,
100
287871
3642
05:03
like trying to eat the leftovers
of a picnic that happened 1,000 years ago.
101
291537
4508
05:08
Which is a crazy way to live,
102
296069
2024
05:10
but shockingly seems to work out
for a lot of microbes in earth.
103
298117
3158
05:13
The other possibility
is for a microbe to just say,
104
301698
3421
05:17
"Nah, I don't need the surface world.
105
305143
2475
05:19
I'm good down here."
106
307642
1453
05:21
For microbes that go this route,
107
309119
1672
05:22
they have to get everything
that they need in order to survive
108
310815
3643
05:26
from inside the earth.
109
314482
1817
05:30
Some things are actually
easier for them to get.
110
318205
2456
05:32
They're more abundant inside the earth,
111
320685
1868
05:34
like water or nutrients,
like nitrogen and iron and phosphorus,
112
322577
3818
05:38
or places to live.
113
326419
1173
05:39
These are things that we literally
kill each other to get ahold of
114
327616
3160
05:42
up at the surface world.
115
330800
1214
05:44
But in the subsurface,
the problem is finding enough energy.
116
332038
3531
05:48
Up at the surface,
117
336101
1190
05:49
plants can chemically knit together
carbon dioxide molecules into yummy sugars
118
337315
4088
05:53
as fast as the sun's photons
hit their leaves.
119
341427
2976
05:56
But in the subsurface, of course,
there's no sunlight,
120
344427
2528
05:58
so this ecosystem has to solve the problem
121
346979
2714
06:01
of who is going to make the food
for everybody else.
122
349717
3265
06:05
The subsurface needs something
that's like a plant
123
353416
3875
06:09
but it breathes rocks.
124
357315
1787
06:11
Luckily, such a thing exists,
125
359641
3135
06:14
and it's called a chemolithoautotroph.
126
362800
2324
06:17
(Laughter)
127
365148
1008
06:18
Which is a microbe
that uses chemicals -- "chemo,"
128
366180
4024
06:22
from rocks -- "litho,"
129
370228
2230
06:24
to make food -- "autotroph."
130
372482
2762
06:27
And they can do this
with a ton of different elements.
131
375268
2658
06:29
They can do this with sulphur,
iron, manganese, nitrogen, carbon,
132
377950
3833
06:33
some of them can use
pure electrons, straight up.
133
381807
3230
06:37
Like, if you cut the end
off of an electrical cord,
134
385530
2412
06:39
they could breathe it like a snorkel.
135
387966
1909
06:41
(Laughter)
136
389899
1312
06:43
These chemolithoautotrophs
137
391235
1501
06:44
take the energy that they get
from these processes
138
392760
2635
06:47
and use it to make food, like plants do.
139
395419
2412
06:49
But we know that plants do more
than just make food.
140
397855
2803
06:53
They also make a waste product, oxygen,
141
401103
2316
06:55
which we are 100 percent dependent upon.
142
403443
2028
06:57
But the waste product
that these chemolithoautotrophs make
143
405992
3285
07:01
is often in the form of minerals,
144
409301
1967
07:03
like rust or pyrite, like fool's gold,
145
411292
4579
07:07
or carminites, like limestone.
146
415895
2000
07:10
So what we have are microbes
that are really, really slow, like rocks,
147
418680
6603
07:18
that get their energy from rocks,
148
426243
3406
07:21
that make as their waste
product other rocks.
149
429673
3197
07:25
So am I talking about biology,
or am I talking about geology?
150
433268
3821
07:29
This stuff really blurs the lines.
151
437466
2143
07:31
(Laughter)
152
439633
1004
07:32
So if I'm going to do this thing,
153
440661
2146
07:34
and I'm going to be a biologist
who studies microbes
154
442831
3318
07:38
that kind of act like rocks,
155
446173
2205
07:40
then I should probably
start studying geology.
156
448402
3374
07:43
And what's the coolest part of geology?
157
451800
3110
07:47
Volcanoes.
158
455292
1168
07:48
(Laughter)
159
456484
1251
07:49
This is looking inside the crater
of Poás Volcano in Costa Rica.
160
457759
3721
07:53
Many volcanoes on earth arise
because an oceanic tectonic plate
161
461854
3778
07:57
crashes into a continental plate.
162
465656
1810
07:59
As this oceanic plate subducts
163
467490
1913
08:01
or gets moved underneath
this continental plate,
164
469427
2365
08:03
things like water and carbon dioxide
and other materials
165
471816
2841
08:06
get squeezed out of it,
166
474681
1235
08:07
like ringing a wet washcloth.
167
475940
1726
08:10
So in this way, subduction zones
are like portals into the deep earth,
168
478382
3682
08:14
where materials are exchanged between
the surface and the subsurface world.
169
482088
3761
08:17
So I was recently invited
by some of my colleagues in Costa Rica
170
485873
3028
08:20
to come and work with them
on some of the volcanoes.
171
488925
3103
08:24
And of course I said yes,
because, I mean, Costa Rica is beautiful,
172
492052
4598
08:28
but also because it sits on top
of one of these subduction zones.
173
496674
3280
08:32
We wanted to ask
the very specific question:
174
500478
2794
08:35
Why is it that the carbon dioxide
175
503296
2388
08:37
that comes out of this deeply buried
oceanic tectonic plate
176
505708
2976
08:40
is only coming out of the volcanoes?
177
508708
2107
08:42
Why don't we see it distributed
throughout the entire subduction zone?
178
510839
3294
08:46
Do the microbes have something
to do with that?
179
514157
2483
08:48
So this is a picture of me
inside Poás Volcano,
180
516664
3623
08:52
along with my colleague
Donato Giovannelli.
181
520311
2184
08:54
That lake that we're standing next to
is made of pure battery acid.
182
522519
3602
08:58
I know this because we were measuring
the pH when this picture was taken.
183
526145
3722
09:02
And at some point while
we were working inside the crater,
184
530362
2731
09:05
I turned to my Costa Rican colleague
Carlos Ramírez and I said,
185
533117
4579
09:09
"Alright, if this thing
starts erupting right now,
186
537720
3367
09:13
what's our exit strategy?"
187
541111
1733
09:15
And he said, "Oh, yeah,
great question, it's totally easy.
188
543269
3143
09:18
Just turn around and enjoy the view."
189
546436
3078
09:21
(Laughter)
190
549538
1293
09:22
"Because it will be your last."
191
550855
1547
09:24
(Laughter)
192
552426
1135
09:25
And it may sound like
he was being overly dramatic,
193
553585
3445
09:29
but 54 days after I was standing
next to that lake,
194
557054
4753
09:33
this happened.
195
561831
1421
09:35
Audience: Oh!
196
563276
1158
09:37
Freaking terrifying, right?
197
565204
1650
09:38
(Laughs)
198
566878
1150
09:40
This was the biggest eruption
this volcano had had in 60-some-odd years,
199
568934
4353
09:45
and not long after this video ends,
200
573311
2484
09:47
the camera that was taking
the video is obliterated
201
575819
2643
09:50
and the entire lake
that we had been sampling
202
578486
2420
09:52
vaporizes completely.
203
580930
1400
09:54
But I also want to be clear
204
582815
1802
09:56
that we were pretty sure
this was not going to happen
205
584641
2500
09:59
on the day that we were
actually in the volcano,
206
587165
2253
10:01
because Costa Rica monitors
its volcanoes very carefully
207
589442
2633
10:04
through the OVSICORI Institute,
208
592099
1563
10:05
and we had scientists from that institute
with us on that day.
209
593686
3206
10:08
But the fact that it erupted
illustrates perfectly
210
596916
3090
10:12
that if you want to look
for where carbon dioxide gas
211
600030
2508
10:14
is coming out of this oceanic plate,
212
602562
1864
10:16
then you should look no further
than the volcanoes themselves.
213
604450
3103
10:19
But if you go to Costa Rica,
214
607577
2269
10:21
you may notice that in addition
to these volcanoes
215
609870
2460
10:24
there are tons of cozy little hot springs
all over the place.
216
612354
3244
10:28
Some of the water in these hot springs
is actually bubbling up
217
616069
3270
10:31
from this deeply buried oceanic plate.
218
619363
2301
10:33
And our hypothesis was
that there should be carbon dioxide
219
621688
3496
10:37
bubbling up with it,
220
625208
1179
10:38
but something deep underground
was filtering it out.
221
626411
3182
10:41
So we spent two weeks
driving all around Costa Rica,
222
629617
4182
10:45
sampling every hot spring we could find --
223
633823
2897
10:48
it was awful, let me tell you.
224
636744
1674
10:50
And then we spent the next two years
measuring and analyzing data.
225
638442
5636
10:56
And if you're not a scientist, I'll just
let you know that the big discoveries
226
644102
3809
10:59
don't really happen
when you're at a beautiful hot spring
227
647935
2833
11:02
or on a public stage;
228
650792
1151
11:03
they happen when you're hunched
over a messy computer
229
651967
2523
11:06
or you're troubleshooting
a difficult instrument,
230
654514
2317
11:08
or you're Skyping your colleagues
231
656855
1738
11:10
because you are completely
confused about your data.
232
658617
2595
11:13
Scientific discoveries,
kind of like deep subsurface microbes,
233
661236
3331
11:16
can be very, very slow.
234
664591
1768
11:19
But in our case,
this really paid off this one time.
235
667267
3349
11:22
We discovered that literally
tons of carbon dioxide
236
670640
4278
11:26
were coming out of this
deeply buried oceanic plate.
237
674942
3183
11:30
And the thing that was keeping
them underground
238
678149
2349
11:32
and keeping it from being released
out into the atmosphere
239
680522
2995
11:35
was that deep underground,
240
683541
1560
11:37
underneath all the adorable sloths
and toucans of Costa Rica,
241
685125
3984
11:41
were chemolithoautotrophs.
242
689133
1800
11:43
These microbes and the chemical processes
that were happening around them
243
691338
3501
11:46
were converting this carbon dioxide
into carbonate mineral
244
694863
2752
11:49
and locking it up underground.
245
697639
1928
11:51
Which makes you wonder:
246
699591
2294
11:53
If these subsurface processes
are so good at sucking up
247
701909
3501
11:57
all the carbon dioxide
coming from below them,
248
705434
2581
12:00
could they also help us
with a little carbon problem
249
708039
2460
12:02
we've got going on up at the surface?
250
710523
2165
12:05
Humans are releasing enough
carbon dioxide into our atmosphere
251
713006
4325
12:09
that we are decreasing
the ability of our planet
252
717355
2974
12:12
to support life as we know it.
253
720353
2000
12:14
And scientists and engineers
and entrepreneurs
254
722704
2432
12:17
are working on methods
to pull carbon dioxide
255
725160
2504
12:19
out of these point sources,
256
727688
1293
12:21
so that they're not released
into the atmosphere.
257
729005
2318
12:23
And they need to put it somewhere.
258
731347
1651
12:25
So for this reason,
259
733022
1177
12:26
we need to keep studying places
where this carbon might be stored,
260
734223
3338
12:29
possibly in the subsurface,
261
737585
2294
12:31
to know what's going to happen to it
when it goes there.
262
739903
2643
12:34
Will these deep subsurface microbes
be a problem because they're too slow
263
742570
3467
12:38
to actually keep anything down there?
264
746061
1881
12:39
Or will they be helpful
265
747966
1408
12:41
because they'll help convert this stuff
to solid carbonate minerals?
266
749398
3790
12:45
If we can make such a big breakthrough
267
753712
2420
12:48
just from one study
that we did in Costa Rica,
268
756156
2386
12:50
then imagine what else
is waiting to be discovered down there.
269
758566
2967
12:53
This new field of geo-bio-chemistry,
or deep subsurface biology,
270
761891
5665
12:59
or whatever you want to call it,
271
767580
1541
13:01
is going to have huge implications,
272
769145
1837
13:03
not just for mitigating climate change,
273
771006
2373
13:05
but possibly for understanding
how life and earth have coevolved,
274
773403
3872
13:09
or finding new products that are useful
for industrial or medical applications.
275
777613
4698
13:14
Maybe even predicting earthquakes
276
782335
2262
13:16
or finding life outside our planet.
277
784621
2198
13:18
It could even help us understand
the origin of life itself.
278
786843
3126
13:22
Fortunately, I don't have
to do this by myself.
279
790827
2825
13:25
I have amazing colleagues
all over the world
280
793962
3325
13:29
who are cracking into the mysteries
of this deep subsurface world.
281
797311
3292
13:33
And it may seem like life
buried deep within the earth's crust
282
801831
4810
13:38
is so far away from our daily experiences
that it's kind of irrelevant.
283
806665
3974
13:43
But the truth is
that this weird, slow life
284
811363
3688
13:47
may actually have the answers
to some of the greatest mysteries
285
815075
3525
13:50
of life on earth.
286
818624
1150
13:52
Thank you.
287
820225
1151
13:53
(Applause)
288
821400
5044

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Karen Lloyd - Marine microbiologist
Karen Lloyd studies novel groups of microbes in Earth's deep surface biosphere, collecting them from disparate remote places such as Arctic fjords, volcanoes in Costa Rica, even deep in mud in the Marianas Trench

Why you should listen

Karen G. Lloyd applies molecular biological techniques to environmental samples to learn more about microbes that have thus far evaded attempts to be cultured in a laboratory. She has adapted novel techniques to quantify and characterize these mysterious microbes while requiring minimal changes to their natural conditions. Her work centers on deep oceanic subsurface sediments, deep-sea mud volcanoes and cold seeps, terrestrial volcanoes and hot springs, serpentinizing springs, Arctic marine fjord sediments and ancient permafrost. She is currently an Assistant Professor at the University of Tennessee. 

More profile about the speaker
Karen Lloyd | Speaker | TED.com