ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Bierut - Designer, critic
Michael Bierut is a partner in the New York office of Pentagram, a founder of Design Observer and a teacher at Yale School of Art and Yale School of Management.

Why you should listen

Michael Bierut studied graphic design at the University of Cincinnati's College of Design, Architecture, Art and Planning, graduating summa cum laude in 1980. Prior to joining Pentagram in 1990 as a partner in the firm's New York office, he worked for ten years at Vignelli Associates, ultimately as vice president of graphic design.

His projects at Pentagram have included work for the New York Times, Saks Fifth Avenue, The Cathedral of St. John the Divine, Harley-Davidson, The Museum of Arts and Design, Mastercard, the New York City Department of Transportation, the Robin Hood Foundation, Mohawk Paper Mills, New World Symphony, the New York Jets, the Brooklyn Academy of Music and MIT Media Lab. As a volunteer to Hillary for America, he created the ubiquitous H logo that was used throughout the 2016 presidential campaign.

He has won hundreds of design awards and his work is represented in the permanent collections of the Museum of Modern Art and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and the Musée des Arts Décoratifs, Montreal. He served as president of the New York Chapter of the American Institute of Graphic Arts (AIGA) from 1988 to 1990 and is president emeritus of AIGA National. Bierut was elected to the Alliance Graphique Internationale in 1989, to the Art Directors Club Hall of Fame in 2003, and was awarded the profession’s highest honor, the AIGA Medal, in 2006. In 2008, he was named winner in the Design Mind category of the Cooper-Hewitt National Design Awards. In spring 2016, Bierut was appointed the Henry Wolf Graphic Designer in Residence at the American Academy in Rome.

Bierut is a senior critic in graphic design at the Yale School of Art and a lecturer at the Yale School of Management. He writes frequently about design and is the co-editor of the five-volume series Looking Closer: Critical Writings on Graphic Design published by Allworth Press. In 2002, Bierut co-founded Design Observer, a blog of design and cultural criticism which now features podcasts on design, popular culture, and business.

Bierut's book 79 Short Essays on Design was published in 2007 by Princeton Architectural Press. A monograph on his work, How to use graphic design to sell things, explain things, make things look better, make people laugh, make people cry and (every once in a while) change the world, was published in 2015 by Thames & Hudson and Harper Collins. This accompanied the first retrospective exhibition of his work, part of the School of Visual Art's Masters Series, which was on view at the SVA Chelsea Gallery in New York City for five weeks in autumn 2015. His next book, Now You See It, is due out from Princeton Architectural Press this fall. 


More profile about the speaker
Michael Bierut | Speaker | TED.com
TEDNYC

Michael Bierut: How to design a library that makes kids want to read

Filmed:
1,850,983 views

When Michael Bierut was tapped to design a logo for public school libraries, he had no idea that he was embarking on a years-long passion project. In this often hilarious talk, he recalls his obsessive quest to bring energy, learning, art and graphics into these magical spaces where school librarians can inspire new generations of readers and thinkers.
- Designer, critic
Michael Bierut is a partner in the New York office of Pentagram, a founder of Design Observer and a teacher at Yale School of Art and Yale School of Management. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
So there's this thing called
the law of unintended consequences.
0
920
4456
00:17
I thought it was just like a saying,
1
5400
1736
00:19
but it actually exists, I guess.
2
7160
1576
00:20
There's, like, academic papers about it.
3
8760
1920
00:23
And I'm a designer.
4
11120
1256
00:24
I don't like unintended consequences.
5
12400
2856
00:27
People hire me because they have
consequences that they really intend,
6
15280
4576
00:31
and what they intend is for me
to help them achieve those consequences.
7
19880
3856
00:35
So I live in fear
of unintended consequences.
8
23760
3016
00:38
And so this is a story about
consequences intended and unintended.
9
26800
4680
00:44
I got called by an organization
called Robin Hood
10
32080
3136
00:47
to do a favor for them.
11
35240
1576
00:48
Robin Hood is based in New York,
a wonderful philanthropic organization
12
36840
3416
00:52
that does what it says in the name.
13
40280
1736
00:54
They take from rich people,
give it to poor people.
14
42040
2776
00:56
In this case, what they wanted to benefit
was the New York City school system,
15
44840
4896
01:01
a huge enterprise that educates
more than a million students at a time,
16
49760
5336
01:07
and in buildings that are like this one,
17
55120
2336
01:09
old buildings, big buildings,
18
57480
1896
01:11
drafty buildings, sometimes buildings
that are in disrepair,
19
59400
3136
01:14
certainly buildings
that could use a renovation.
20
62560
2536
01:17
Robin Hood had this ambition
to improve these buildings in some way,
21
65120
3256
01:20
but what they realized was
22
68400
1456
01:21
to fix the buildings would be
too expensive and impractical.
23
69880
4536
01:26
So instead they tried to figure out
what one room they could go into
24
74440
4376
01:30
in each of these buildings,
in as many buildings that they could,
25
78840
3056
01:33
and fix that one room
26
81920
2656
01:36
so that they could improve
the lives of the children inside
27
84600
2816
01:39
as they were studying.
28
87440
1216
01:40
And what they came up with
was the school library,
29
88680
2416
01:43
and they came up with this idea
called the Library Initiative.
30
91120
2936
01:46
All the students
have to pass through the library.
31
94080
2376
01:48
That's where the books are.
32
96480
1336
01:49
That's where the heart
and soul of the school is.
33
97840
2336
01:52
So let's fix these libraries.
34
100200
1416
01:53
So they did this wonderful thing
where they brought in
35
101640
2536
01:56
first 10, then 20, then more architects,
36
104200
3096
01:59
each one of whom was assigned a library
to rethink what a library was.
37
107320
3736
02:03
They trained special librarians.
38
111080
2056
02:05
So they started this mighty enterprise
39
113160
2056
02:07
to reform public schools
by improving these libraries.
40
115240
3016
02:10
Then they called me up and they said,
"Could you make a little contribution?"
41
118280
3656
02:13
I said, "Sure, what do you want me to do?"
42
121960
2016
02:16
And they said, "Well, we want you
to be the graphic designer
43
124000
2856
02:18
in charge of the whole thing."
44
126880
1456
02:20
And so I thought, I know what that means.
That means I get to design a logo.
45
128360
3576
02:23
I know how to design that. I design logos.
46
131960
2016
02:26
That's what people come to me for.
47
134000
1656
02:27
So OK, let's design a logo for this thing.
48
135680
2096
02:29
Easy to do, actually,
compared with architecture
49
137800
2256
02:32
and being a librarian.
50
140080
1256
02:33
Just do a logo, make a contribution,
and then you're out,
51
141360
2736
02:36
and you feel really good about yourself.
52
144120
1936
02:38
And I'm a great guy and I like to feel
good about myself when I do these favors.
53
146080
3776
02:41
So I thought, let's overdeliver.
54
149880
1576
02:43
I'm going to give you three logos,
all based on this one idea.
55
151480
2936
02:46
So you have three options,
pick any of the three.
56
154440
2336
02:48
They're all great, I said.
57
156800
1296
02:50
So the basic idea was
these would be new school libraries
58
158120
3216
02:53
for New York schools,
59
161360
1536
02:54
and so the idea is that it's a new thing,
a new idea that needs a new name.
60
162920
3856
02:58
What I wanted to do was dispel the idea
that these were musty old libraries,
61
166800
5016
03:03
the kind of places
that everyone is bored with,
62
171840
3616
03:07
you know, not your grandparents' library.
63
175480
1976
03:09
Don't worry about that at all.
64
177480
1456
03:10
This is going to this new, exciting thing,
65
178960
2016
03:13
not a boring library.
66
181000
1256
03:14
So option number one:
67
182280
1656
03:15
so instead of thinking of it as a library,
68
183960
2016
03:18
think of it as a place where it is like:
do talk, do make loud noises.
69
186000
4176
03:22
Right? So no shushing,
it's like a shush-free zone.
70
190200
4016
03:26
We're going to call it the Reading Room.
71
194240
2176
03:28
That was option number one.
OK, option number two.
72
196440
3376
03:31
Option number two was, wait for it,
73
199840
3416
03:35
OWL.
74
203280
1256
03:36
I'll meet you at OWL.
75
204560
1336
03:37
I'm getting my book from the OWL.
Meet you after school down at OWL.
76
205920
3296
03:41
I like that, right?
Now, what does OWL stand for?
77
209240
2336
03:43
Well, it could be One World Library,
78
211600
1896
03:45
or it could be Open. Wonder. Learn.
79
213520
2616
03:48
Or it could be -- and I figure librarians
could figure out other things it could be
80
216160
4496
03:52
because they know about words.
81
220680
1456
03:54
So other things, right?
82
222160
1216
03:55
And then look at this.
It's like the eye of the owl.
83
223400
2456
03:57
This is irresistible in my opinion.
84
225880
1696
03:59
But there's even another idea.
85
227600
1456
04:01
Option number three.
86
229080
1216
04:02
Option number three
was based actually on language.
87
230320
2616
04:04
It's the idea that "read"
is the past tense of "read,"
88
232960
3296
04:08
and they're both spelled the same way.
89
236280
1856
04:10
So why don't we call
this place The Red Zone?
90
238160
2936
04:13
I'll meet you at the Red Zone.
91
241120
1429
04:14
Are you Red? Get Red.
92
242573
2560
04:17
I'm well Red.
93
245880
1216
04:19
(Laughter)
94
247120
1216
04:20
I really loved this idea,
95
248360
1336
04:21
and I somehow was not focused on the idea
96
249720
2336
04:24
that librarians as a class are sort of
interested in spelling and I don't know.
97
252080
5896
04:30
(Laughter)
98
258000
1935
04:31
But sometimes cleverness
is more important than spelling,
99
259959
3497
04:35
and I thought this would be
one of those instances.
100
263480
2416
04:37
So usually when I make these presentations
101
265920
2016
04:39
I say there's just one question
and the question should be,
102
267960
2776
04:42
"How can I thank you, Mike?"
103
270760
1376
04:44
But in this case,
the question was more like,
104
272160
2616
04:46
"Um, are you kidding?"
105
274800
2416
04:49
Because, they said,
106
277240
1696
04:50
the premise of all this work
107
278960
1376
04:52
was that kids were bored
with old libraries, musty old libraries.
108
280360
4136
04:56
They were tired of them.
109
284520
1216
04:57
And instead, they said, these kids
have never really seen a library.
110
285760
3336
05:01
The school libraries in these schools
111
289120
1816
05:02
are really so dilapidated,
if they're there at all,
112
290960
3416
05:06
that they haven't bored anyone.
113
294400
1936
05:08
They haven't even been there
to bore anyone at all.
114
296360
2976
05:11
So the idea was, just forget
about giving it a new name.
115
299360
3416
05:14
Just call it, one last try, a library.
116
302800
4056
05:18
Right? OK.
117
306880
1216
05:20
So I thought, OK, give it a little oomph?
118
308120
2856
05:23
Exclamation point?
119
311000
1216
05:24
Then -- this is because I'm clever --
120
312240
1976
05:26
move that into the "i,"
121
314240
2536
05:28
make it red,
122
316800
1256
05:30
and there you have it,
the Library Initiative.
123
318080
2176
05:32
So I thought, mission accomplished,
there's your logo.
124
320280
2536
05:34
So what's interesting about this logo,
an unintended consequence,
125
322840
3056
05:37
was that it turned out that
they didn't really even need my design
126
325920
3136
05:41
because you could type it any font,
you could write it by hand,
127
329080
2976
05:44
and when they started
sending emails around,
128
332080
2096
05:46
they just would use Shift and 1,
129
334200
1576
05:47
they'd get their own logo
just right out of the thing.
130
335800
2576
05:50
And I thought, well, that's fine.
131
338400
1736
05:52
Feel free to use that logo.
132
340160
1776
05:53
And then I embarked
on the real rollout of this thing --
133
341960
2896
05:56
working with every one of the architects
134
344880
1936
05:58
to put this logo on the front door
of their own library. Right?
135
346840
3000
06:02
So here's the big rollout.
136
350360
1376
06:03
Basically I'd work
with different architects.
137
351760
2256
06:06
First Robin Hood was my client.
Now these architects were my client.
138
354040
3216
06:09
I'd say, "Here's your logo.
Put it on the door."
139
357280
2239
06:11
"Here's your logo. Put it on both doors."
140
359543
1953
06:13
"Here's your logo.
Put it off to the side."
141
361520
2016
06:15
"Here's your logo
repeated all over to the top."
142
363560
2256
06:17
So everything was going swimmingly.
143
365840
1696
06:19
I just was saying,
"Here's your logo. Here's your logo."
144
367560
2656
06:22
Then I got a call
from one of the architects,
145
370240
2136
06:24
a guy named Richard Lewis,
and he says, "I've got a problem.
146
372400
2856
06:27
You're the graphics guy.
Can you solve it?"
147
375280
2016
06:29
And I said, OK, sure."
148
377320
1216
06:30
And he said, "The problem is
that there's a space
149
378560
2576
06:33
between the shelf and the ceiling."
150
381160
1816
06:35
So that sounds like
an architectural issue to me,
151
383000
2336
06:37
not a graphic design issue,
so I'm, "Go on."
152
385360
2096
06:39
And Richard says, "Well,
the top shelf has to be low enough
153
387480
3656
06:43
for the kid to reach it,
154
391160
1216
06:44
but I'm in a big old building,
and the ceilings are really high,
155
392400
3000
06:47
so actually I've got
all this space up there
156
395424
2072
06:49
and I need something like a mural."
157
397520
1696
06:51
And I'm like, "Whoa,
you know, I'm a logo designer.
158
399240
2936
06:54
I'm not Diego Rivera or something.
159
402200
2136
06:56
I'm not a muralist."
160
404360
1616
06:58
And so he said, "But can't you
think of anything?"
161
406000
2376
07:00
So I said, "OK, what if we just
took pictures of the kids in the school
162
408400
5376
07:05
and just put them around
the top of the thing,
163
413800
2456
07:08
and maybe that could work."
164
416280
1336
07:09
And my wife is a photographer,
165
417640
1856
07:11
and I said, "Dorothy, there's no budget,
166
419520
1936
07:13
can you come to this school
in east New York, take these pictures?"
167
421480
3176
07:16
And she did,
168
424680
1216
07:17
and if you go in Richard's library,
169
425920
1976
07:19
which is one of the first that opened,
170
427920
1856
07:21
it has this glorious frieze
of, like, the heroes of the school,
171
429800
3096
07:24
oversized, looking down
172
432920
1696
07:26
into the little dollhouse
of the real library, right?
173
434640
3016
07:29
And the kids were great,
hand-selected by the principals
174
437680
2816
07:32
and the librarian.
175
440520
1776
07:34
It just kind of created
this heroic atmosphere in this library,
176
442320
3256
07:37
this very dignified setting below
and the joy of the children above.
177
445600
3496
07:41
So naturally all the other librarians
in the other schools see this
178
449120
4336
07:45
and they said, well, we want murals too.
179
453480
1936
07:47
And I'm like, OK.
180
455440
1296
07:48
So then I think, well,
it can't be the same mural every time,
181
456760
2896
07:51
so Dorothy did another one,
and then she did another one,
182
459680
3056
07:54
but then we needed more help,
183
462760
1616
07:56
so I called an illustrator I knew
named Lynn Pauley,
184
464400
2856
07:59
and Lynn did these beautiful
paintings of the kids.
185
467280
2936
08:02
Then I called a guy named Charles Wilkin
at a place called Automatic Design.
186
470240
4336
08:06
He did these amazing collages.
187
474600
1800
08:08
We had Rafael Esquer
188
476960
2336
08:11
do these great silhouettes.
189
479320
1856
08:13
He would work with the kids,
asking for words,
190
481200
2176
08:15
and then based on those prompts,
191
483400
1576
08:17
come up with this little,
delirious kind of constellation
192
485000
2696
08:19
of silhouettes
of things that are in books.
193
487720
2056
08:21
Peter Arkle interviewed the kids
194
489800
1576
08:23
and had them talk
about their favorite books
195
491400
2096
08:25
and he put their testimony
as a frieze up there.
196
493520
2256
08:27
Stefan Sagmeister worked with Yuko Shimizu
197
495800
2256
08:30
and they did this amazing
manga-style statement,
198
498080
2296
08:32
"Everyone who is honest is interesting,"
199
500400
2456
08:34
that goes all the way around.
200
502880
1856
08:36
Christoph Niemann, brilliant illustrator,
201
504760
2376
08:39
did a whole series of things
202
507160
1376
08:40
where he embedded books
into the faces and characters
203
508560
3016
08:43
and images and places
that you find in the books.
204
511600
3136
08:46
And then even Maira Kalman
205
514760
2039
08:48
did this amazing cryptic installation
of objects and words
206
516840
3815
08:52
that kind of go all around
and will fascinate students
207
520679
3177
08:55
for as long as it's up there.
208
523880
1576
08:57
So this was really satisfying,
209
525480
1656
08:59
and basically my role here was reading
a series of dimensions to these artists,
210
527160
5896
09:05
and I would say,
211
533080
1256
09:06
"Three feet by 15 feet, whatever you want.
212
534360
2696
09:09
Let me know if you have
any problem with that."
213
537080
2216
09:11
And they would go and install these.
It just was the greatest thing.
214
539320
3216
09:14
But the greatest thing, actually, was --
215
542560
2296
09:16
Every once in a while,
216
544880
1216
09:18
I'd get, like, an invitation in the mail
made of construction paper,
217
546120
3216
09:21
and it would say, "You are invited
to the opening of our new library."
218
549360
3296
09:24
So you'd go to the library,
say, you'd go to PS10,
219
552680
2376
09:27
and you'd go inside.
220
555080
1216
09:28
There'd be balloons,
there'd be a student ambassador,
221
556320
2776
09:31
there'd be speeches that were read,
222
559120
2136
09:33
poetry that was written
specifically for the opening,
223
561280
2896
09:36
dignitaries would present people
with certificates,
224
564200
2936
09:39
and the whole thing
was just a delirious, fun party.
225
567160
2616
09:41
So I loved going to these things.
226
569800
1616
09:43
I would stand there dressed like this,
obviously not belonging,
227
571440
2976
09:46
and someone would say,
"What are you doing here, mister?"
228
574440
2667
09:49
And I'd say, "Well, I'm part of the team
that designed this place."
229
577131
3165
09:52
And they'd said, "You do these shelves?"
230
580320
1905
09:54
And I said, "No."
"You took the pictures up above."
231
582249
2407
09:56
"No."
232
584680
1216
09:57
"Well, what did you do?"
233
585920
1216
09:59
"You know when you came in?
The sign over the door?"
234
587160
2456
10:01
"The sign that says library?"
235
589640
1416
10:03
(Laughter)
236
591080
1016
10:04
"Yeah, I did that!"
237
592120
1216
10:05
And then they'd sort of go,
"OK. Nice work if you can get it."
238
593360
4120
10:10
So it was so satisfying
going to these little openings
239
598200
4096
10:14
despite the fact that I was
kind of largely ignored or humiliated,
240
602320
3736
10:18
but it was actually fun
going to the openings,
241
606080
2176
10:20
so I decided that I wanted
to get the people in my office
242
608280
2696
10:23
who had worked on these projects,
get the illustrators and photographers,
243
611000
3456
10:26
and I said, why don't we rent a van
244
614480
1696
10:28
and drive around
the five boroughs of New York
245
616200
2376
10:30
and see how many we could hit at one time.
246
618600
2016
10:32
And eventually there were
going to be 60 of these libraries,
247
620640
2856
10:35
so we probably got to see
maybe half a dozen in one long day.
248
623520
3776
10:39
And the best thing of all
was meeting these librarians
249
627320
2936
10:42
who kind of were running these,
took possession of these places
250
630280
3576
10:45
like their private stage
upon which they were invited
251
633880
2576
10:48
to mesmerize their students
and bring the books to life,
252
636480
3936
10:52
and it was just
this really exciting experience
253
640440
2536
10:55
for all of us to actually
see these things in action.
254
643000
2816
10:57
So we spent a long day doing this
255
645840
2536
11:00
and we were in the very last library.
256
648400
1816
11:02
It was still winter,
because it got dark early,
257
650240
2816
11:05
and the librarian says,
258
653080
1216
11:06
"I'm about to close down.
So really nice having you here.
259
654320
2696
11:09
Hey, wait a second, do you want to see
how I turn off the lights?"
260
657040
3136
11:12
I'm like, "OK."
261
660200
1296
11:13
And she said, "I have
this special way that I do it."
262
661520
2496
11:16
And then she showed me.
263
664040
1256
11:17
What she did was she turned out
every light one by one by one by one,
264
665320
3456
11:20
and the last light she left on
265
668800
2056
11:22
was the light that illuminated
the kids' faces,
266
670880
2896
11:25
and she said, "That's the last light
I turn off every night,
267
673800
2856
11:28
because I like to remind myself
why I come to work."
268
676680
2576
11:31
So when I started this whole thing,
269
679280
2856
11:34
remember, it was just
about designing that logo
270
682160
2191
11:36
and being clever, come up with a new name?
271
684375
2001
11:38
The unintended consequence here,
272
686400
1576
11:40
which I would like to take credit for
273
688000
1816
11:41
and like to think I can think through
the experience to that extent,
274
689840
3216
11:45
but I can't.
275
693080
1216
11:46
I was just focused on a foot ahead of me,
as far as I could reach with my own hands.
276
694320
3976
11:50
Instead, way off in the distance
277
698320
2576
11:52
was a librarian
278
700920
1256
11:54
who was going to find
the chain of consequences
279
702200
2936
11:57
that we had set in motion,
280
705160
1416
11:58
a source of inspiration
281
706600
1496
12:00
so that she in this case
could do her work really well.
282
708120
3376
12:03
40,000 kids a year
are affected by these libraries.
283
711520
3376
12:06
They've been happening
for more than 10 years now,
284
714920
2456
12:09
so those librarians have kind of turned on
a generation of children to books
285
717400
4536
12:13
and so it's been a thrill to find out
286
721960
2496
12:16
that sometimes unintended consequences
are the best consequences.
287
724480
3736
12:20
Thank you very much.
288
728240
1216
12:21
(Applause)
289
729480
3880

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Bierut - Designer, critic
Michael Bierut is a partner in the New York office of Pentagram, a founder of Design Observer and a teacher at Yale School of Art and Yale School of Management.

Why you should listen

Michael Bierut studied graphic design at the University of Cincinnati's College of Design, Architecture, Art and Planning, graduating summa cum laude in 1980. Prior to joining Pentagram in 1990 as a partner in the firm's New York office, he worked for ten years at Vignelli Associates, ultimately as vice president of graphic design.

His projects at Pentagram have included work for the New York Times, Saks Fifth Avenue, The Cathedral of St. John the Divine, Harley-Davidson, The Museum of Arts and Design, Mastercard, the New York City Department of Transportation, the Robin Hood Foundation, Mohawk Paper Mills, New World Symphony, the New York Jets, the Brooklyn Academy of Music and MIT Media Lab. As a volunteer to Hillary for America, he created the ubiquitous H logo that was used throughout the 2016 presidential campaign.

He has won hundreds of design awards and his work is represented in the permanent collections of the Museum of Modern Art and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and the Musée des Arts Décoratifs, Montreal. He served as president of the New York Chapter of the American Institute of Graphic Arts (AIGA) from 1988 to 1990 and is president emeritus of AIGA National. Bierut was elected to the Alliance Graphique Internationale in 1989, to the Art Directors Club Hall of Fame in 2003, and was awarded the profession’s highest honor, the AIGA Medal, in 2006. In 2008, he was named winner in the Design Mind category of the Cooper-Hewitt National Design Awards. In spring 2016, Bierut was appointed the Henry Wolf Graphic Designer in Residence at the American Academy in Rome.

Bierut is a senior critic in graphic design at the Yale School of Art and a lecturer at the Yale School of Management. He writes frequently about design and is the co-editor of the five-volume series Looking Closer: Critical Writings on Graphic Design published by Allworth Press. In 2002, Bierut co-founded Design Observer, a blog of design and cultural criticism which now features podcasts on design, popular culture, and business.

Bierut's book 79 Short Essays on Design was published in 2007 by Princeton Architectural Press. A monograph on his work, How to use graphic design to sell things, explain things, make things look better, make people laugh, make people cry and (every once in a while) change the world, was published in 2015 by Thames & Hudson and Harper Collins. This accompanied the first retrospective exhibition of his work, part of the School of Visual Art's Masters Series, which was on view at the SVA Chelsea Gallery in New York City for five weeks in autumn 2015. His next book, Now You See It, is due out from Princeton Architectural Press this fall. 


More profile about the speaker
Michael Bierut | Speaker | TED.com