ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Margrethe Vestager - Commissioner for Competition, European Union
Margrethe Vestager is in charge of regulating commercial activity across the European Union and enforcing the EU’s rules designed to keep the markets fair.

Why you should listen
Margrethe Vestager has been described as "the most powerful woman in Brussels" -- otherwise said, in European politics. As Commissioner for Competition for the European Union, Vestager is in charge of regulating commercial activity across the 28 member states and enforcing the EU's rules designed to keep the markets fair -- rules that, she believes, some big companies have been abusing. In 2016, Vestager ordered Apple to pay €13 bn (about US$15.3 bn) in back taxes. In June 2017, she fined Google €2.4 bn (US$2.8 bn) for manipulating search results in favor of its own services. Other antitrust cases are open against Google. Facebook, Amazon, Russian natural gas producer Gazprom, Italian carmaker Fiat and others are also on her radar screen.

Born in Denmark, Vestager held various ministerial posts in her country's government before being appointed to the European Commission in 2014. Her politics are liberal in the classic meaning of the term: free speech, free assembly and free trade -- but she argues that it can only happen if markets are free of undue influence and anti-competitive behaviors.
More profile about the speaker
Margrethe Vestager | Speaker | TED.com
TEDGlobal>NYC

Margrethe Vestager: The new age of corporate monopolies

Filmed:
1,553,513 views

Margrethe Vestager wants to keep European markets competitive -- which is why, on behalf of the EU, she's fined Google $2.8 billion for breaching antitrust rules, asked Apple for $15.3 billion in back taxes and investigated a range of companies, from Gazprom to Fiat, for anti-competitive practices. In an important talk about the state of the global business, she explains why markets need clear rules -- and how even the most innovative companies can become a problem when they become too dominant. "Real and fair competition has a vital role to play in building the trust we need to get the best of our societies," Vestager says. "And that starts with enforcing our rules."
- Commissioner for Competition, European Union
Margrethe Vestager is in charge of regulating commercial activity across the European Union and enforcing the EU’s rules designed to keep the markets fair. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Let's go back to 1957.
0
800
4200
00:18
Representatives
from six European countries
1
6680
4016
00:22
had come to Rome
2
10720
1736
00:24
to sign the treaty that was
to create the European Union.
3
12480
3280
00:29
Europe was destroyed.
4
17840
1440
00:32
A world war had emerged from Europe.
5
20560
3520
00:37
The human suffering was unbelievable
6
25280
2656
00:39
and unprecedented.
7
27960
1720
00:43
Those men
8
31720
1976
00:45
wanted to create a peaceful,
9
33720
4136
00:49
democratic Europe,
10
37880
2216
00:52
a Europe that works for its people.
11
40120
2160
00:55
And one of the many building blocks
12
43760
2816
00:58
in that peace project
13
46600
2256
01:00
was a common European market.
14
48880
2040
01:05
Already back then,
15
53080
2136
01:07
they saw how markets,
16
55240
1816
01:09
when left to themselves,
17
57080
2336
01:11
can sort of slip into being
just the private property
18
59440
5055
01:16
of big businesses and cartels,
19
64519
2721
01:20
meeting the needs of some businesses
20
68360
2200
01:23
and not the needs of customers.
21
71520
2760
01:27
So from our very first day,
22
75840
1920
01:30
in 1957,
23
78680
1640
01:33
the European Union had rules
24
81360
2856
01:36
to defend fair competition.
25
84240
2320
01:39
And that means competition on the merits,
26
87680
3296
01:43
that you compete
on the quality of your products,
27
91000
3216
01:46
the prices you can offer,
28
94240
1936
01:48
the services, the innovation
that you produce.
29
96200
3160
01:52
That's competition on the merits.
30
100400
2816
01:55
You have a fair chance
of making it on such a market.
31
103240
3280
01:59
And it's my job,
32
107320
2016
02:01
as Commissioner for Competition,
33
109360
2776
02:04
to make sure that companies
who do business in Europe
34
112160
3696
02:07
live by those rules.
35
115880
2040
02:12
But let's take a step back.
36
120360
2000
02:16
Why do we need rules
on competition at all?
37
124320
3640
02:20
Why not just let businesses compete?
38
128880
2800
02:24
Isn't that also the best for us
39
132600
2696
02:27
if they compete freely,
40
135320
2296
02:29
since more competition
41
137640
2256
02:31
drives more quality,
42
139920
2176
02:34
lower prices, more innovation?
43
142120
2520
02:39
Well, mostly it is.
44
147080
2200
02:43
But the problem is
that sometimes, for businesses,
45
151520
4776
02:48
competition can be inconvenient,
46
156320
3920
02:55
because competition means
that the race is never over,
47
163120
3680
02:59
the game is never won.
48
167760
1520
03:02
No matter how well
you were doing in the past,
49
170400
2656
03:05
there's always someone
50
173080
1816
03:06
who are out there
wanting to take your place.
51
174920
3280
03:12
So the temptation to avoid competition
52
180360
3176
03:15
is powerful.
53
183560
1200
03:18
It's rooted in motives
as old as Adam and Eve:
54
186320
4240
03:23
in greed for yet more money,
55
191800
2760
03:27
in fear of losing
your position in the market
56
195640
3456
03:31
and all the benefits it brings.
57
199120
2640
03:35
And when greed and fear
58
203960
2936
03:38
are linked to power,
59
206920
1856
03:40
you have a dangerous mix.
60
208800
1560
03:44
We see that in political life.
61
212280
1800
03:47
In part of the world,
62
215360
1856
03:49
the mix of greed and fear
63
217240
2376
03:51
means that those who get power
64
219640
2616
03:54
become reluctant to give it back.
65
222280
4440
04:00
One of the many things
66
228920
1536
04:02
I like and admire in our democracies
67
230480
4736
04:07
are the norms
68
235240
1816
04:09
that make our leaders hand over power
69
237080
3176
04:12
when voters tell them to.
70
240280
1600
04:16
And competition rules
can do a similar thing in the market,
71
244720
3120
04:20
making sure that greed and fear
doesn't overcome fairness.
72
248920
4840
04:27
Because those rules mean
73
255600
1536
04:29
that companies cannot misuse their power
to undermine competition.
74
257160
4840
04:36
Think for a moment about your car.
75
264040
2600
04:40
It has thousands of parts,
76
268720
3536
04:44
from the foam that makes the seats
77
272280
3376
04:47
to the electrical wiring
to the light bulbs.
78
275680
3120
04:51
And for many of those parts,
79
279680
2296
04:54
the world's carmakers,
80
282000
1576
04:55
they are dependent
on only a few suppliers.
81
283600
3040
05:01
So it's hardly surprising
82
289120
2536
05:03
that it is kind of tempting
for those suppliers
83
291680
4056
05:07
to come together and fix prices.
84
295760
2440
05:11
But just imagine what that could do
85
299920
1896
05:13
to the final price
of your new car in the market.
86
301840
4920
05:20
Except, it's not imaginary.
87
308520
2440
05:24
The European Commission
88
312400
2176
05:26
has dealt with already
seven different car parts cartels,
89
314600
5856
05:32
and we're still investigating some.
90
320480
2080
05:36
Here, the Department of Justice
91
324320
3176
05:39
are also looking
into the market for car parts,
92
327520
2640
05:42
and it has called it
the biggest criminal investigation
93
330920
3536
05:46
it has ever pursued.
94
334480
1720
05:49
But without competition rules,
95
337320
2416
05:51
there would be no investigation,
96
339760
2456
05:54
and there would be nothing
to stop this collusion from happening
97
342240
3896
05:58
and the prices of your car to go up.
98
346160
2640
06:03
Yet it's not only companies
99
351600
2336
06:05
who can undermine fair competition.
100
353960
1800
06:08
Governments can do it, too.
101
356960
1520
06:11
And governments do that
when they hand out subsidies
102
359720
4176
06:15
to just the favorite few, the selected.
103
363920
3560
06:21
They may do that
when they hand out subsidies --
104
369240
3056
06:24
and, of course,
all financed by taxpayers --
105
372320
3240
06:28
to companies.
106
376680
1200
06:30
That may be in the form
of special tax treatments,
107
378760
4936
06:35
like the tax benefits
108
383720
1416
06:37
that firms like Fiat,
Starbucks and Apple got
109
385160
4896
06:42
from some governments in Europe.
110
390080
1840
06:46
Those subsidies stop companies
from competing on equal terms.
111
394120
3560
06:51
They can mean that
the companies that succeed,
112
399240
3576
06:54
well, they are the companies
that got the most subsidy,
113
402840
2600
06:58
the ones that are the best-connected,
114
406400
2296
07:00
and not, as it should be,
115
408720
2136
07:02
the companies that serve
consumers the best.
116
410880
2600
07:07
So there are times when we need to step in
117
415560
2200
07:10
to make sure that competition
works the way it should.
118
418720
3200
07:15
By doing that, we help
the market to work fairly,
119
423160
3200
07:19
because competition gives consumers
the power to demand a fair deal.
120
427720
4680
07:25
It means that companies know
that if they cannot offer good prices
121
433840
4496
07:30
or the service that's expected,
122
438360
2576
07:32
well, the customers
will go somewhere else.
123
440960
3400
07:38
And that sort of fairness
is more important
124
446680
2656
07:41
than we may sometimes realize.
125
449360
2160
07:47
Very few people think
about politics all the time.
126
455560
2480
07:51
Some even skip it at election time.
127
459600
2160
07:55
But we are all in the market.
128
463880
2496
07:58
Every day, we are in the market.
129
466400
2480
08:02
And we don't want businesses
to agree on prices in the back office.
130
470280
4240
08:07
We don't want them
to divide the market between them.
131
475520
2720
08:11
We don't want one big company
132
479640
1896
08:13
just to shut out competitors
133
481560
2656
08:16
from ever showing us what they can do.
134
484240
2160
08:20
If that happens,
135
488440
1360
08:22
well, obviously, we feel
that someone has cheated us,
136
490760
3376
08:26
that we are being ignored
or taken for granted by the market.
137
494160
4120
08:31
And that may undermine
not only our trust in the market
138
499680
3576
08:35
but also our trust in the society.
139
503280
2680
08:39
In a recent survey,
140
507680
1936
08:41
more than two-thirds of Europeans
141
509640
2416
08:44
said that they had felt
the effects of lack of competition:
142
512080
4680
08:49
that the price
for electricity was too high,
143
517880
2360
08:53
that the price for the medicines
they needed was too high,
144
521280
3200
08:57
that they had no real choice
145
525560
1496
08:59
if they wanted to travel
by bus or by plane,
146
527080
3336
09:02
or they got poor service
from their internet provider.
147
530440
2800
09:06
In short, they found that the market
didn't treat them fairly.
148
534240
3440
09:11
And that might seem
like very small things,
149
539000
3040
09:16
but they can give you this sense
150
544000
2560
09:19
that the world isn't really fair.
151
547720
2200
09:23
And they see the market,
which was supposed to serve everyone,
152
551720
4856
09:28
become more like the private property
of a few powerful companies.
153
556600
5040
09:35
The market is not the society.
154
563680
1680
09:38
Our societies are, of course,
much, much more than the market.
155
566080
4160
09:43
But lack of trust in the market
156
571720
2656
09:46
can rub off on society
157
574400
2856
09:49
so we lose trust in our society as well.
158
577280
2880
09:55
And it may be the most important
thing we have, trust.
159
583480
4120
10:01
We can trust each other
if we are treated as equals.
160
589880
4240
10:08
If we are all to have the same chances,
161
596080
4416
10:12
well, we all have to follow
the same fundamental rules.
162
600520
3680
10:17
Of course, some people and some businesses
are more successful than others,
163
605560
4680
10:23
but we do not trust in a society
164
611360
2616
10:26
if the prizes are handed out
165
614000
2056
10:28
even before the contest begins.
166
616080
2720
10:33
And this is where
competition rules come in,
167
621280
2400
10:37
because when we make sure
that markets work fairly,
168
625160
3496
10:40
then businesses compete on the merits,
169
628680
3216
10:43
and that helps to build the trust
that we need as citizens
170
631920
5256
10:49
to feel comfortable and in control,
171
637200
3656
10:52
and the trust that allows
our society to work.
172
640880
3600
10:58
Because without trust,
everything becomes harder.
173
646000
3240
11:02
Just to live our daily lives,
we need to trust in strangers,
174
650640
3240
11:07
to trust the banks who keep our money,
175
655000
2720
11:10
the builders who build our home,
176
658800
1720
11:14
the electrician
who comes to fix the wiring,
177
662200
3056
11:17
the doctor who treats us when we're ill,
178
665280
2336
11:19
not to mention
the other drivers on the road,
179
667640
2816
11:22
and everyone knows that they are crazy.
180
670480
1920
11:26
And yet, we have to trust them
181
674000
3096
11:29
to do the right thing.
182
677120
1360
11:32
And the thing is
that the more our societies grow,
183
680120
3040
11:36
the more important trust becomes
184
684880
3016
11:39
and the harder it is to build.
185
687920
3296
11:43
And that is a paradox of modern societies.
186
691240
3720
11:48
And this is especially true
187
696960
2336
11:51
when technology changes
the way that we interact.
188
699320
2800
11:55
Of course, to some degree,
technology can help us
189
703840
2336
11:58
to build trust in one another
with ratings systems and other systems
190
706200
4336
12:02
that enable the sharing economy.
191
710560
2040
12:06
But technology also creates
completely new challenges
192
714360
3776
12:10
when they ask us
not to trust in other people
193
718160
2400
12:14
but to trust in algorithms and computers.
194
722120
3720
12:19
Of course, we all see
and share and appreciate
195
727920
3856
12:23
all the good that
new technology can do us.
196
731800
3976
12:27
It's a lot of good.
197
735800
1360
12:30
Autonomous cars can give people
with disabilities new independence.
198
738240
5136
12:35
It can save us all time,
199
743400
1416
12:36
and it can make a much, much
better use of resources.
200
744840
2680
12:41
Algorithms that rely on crunching
enormous amounts of data
201
749240
4936
12:46
can enable our doctors
to give us a much better treatment,
202
754200
4056
12:50
and many other things.
203
758280
1640
12:54
But no one is going
to hand over their medical data
204
762440
4080
12:59
or step into a car
that's driven by an algorithm
205
767720
3080
13:03
unless they trust the companies
that they are dealing with.
206
771880
3560
13:09
And that trust isn't always there.
207
777560
2360
13:13
Today, for example,
less than a quarter of Europeans
208
781240
4176
13:17
trust online businesses
to protect their personal information.
209
785440
4640
13:24
But what if people knew
210
792720
1600
13:27
that they could rely
on technology companies
211
795440
3336
13:30
to treat them fairly?
212
798800
1320
13:34
What if they knew that those companies
213
802280
2416
13:36
respond to competition
by trying to do better,
214
804720
3600
13:41
by trying to serve consumers better,
215
809400
2280
13:45
not by using their power
216
813120
2336
13:47
to shut out competitors,
217
815480
2376
13:49
say, by pushing their services
218
817880
2376
13:52
far, far down the list of search results
219
820280
3736
13:56
and promoting themselves?
220
824040
1760
13:59
What if they knew
that compliance with the rules
221
827920
4256
14:04
was built into the algorithms by design,
222
832200
3680
14:09
that the algorithm had to go
to competition rules school
223
837080
2896
14:12
before they were ever allowed to work,
224
840000
1960
14:16
that those algorithms were designed
225
844120
2736
14:18
in a way that meant
that they couldn't collude,
226
846880
3616
14:22
that they couldn't form
their own little cartel
227
850520
3016
14:25
in the black box they're working in?
228
853560
1880
14:29
Together with regulation,
229
857480
1800
14:32
competition rules can do that.
230
860280
1960
14:35
They can help us to make sure
231
863240
1776
14:37
that new technology treats people fairly
232
865040
3480
14:41
and that everyone can compete
on a level playing field.
233
869680
3480
14:46
And that can help us build the trust
234
874800
3256
14:50
that we need for real innovation
235
878080
2416
14:52
to flourish
236
880520
1296
14:53
and for societies to develop for citizens.
237
881840
3600
14:59
Because trust cannot be imposed.
238
887920
2240
15:03
It has to be earned.
239
891000
1480
15:06
Since the very first days
of the European Union,
240
894280
3976
15:10
60 years ago,
241
898280
1320
15:12
our competition rules have helped
242
900800
2936
15:15
to build that trust.
243
903760
1480
15:19
A lot of things have changed.
244
907120
1600
15:22
It's hard to say
what those six representatives
245
910440
3336
15:25
would have made of a smartphone.
246
913800
1524
15:29
But in today's world,
247
917000
1616
15:30
as well as in their world,
248
918640
2616
15:33
competition makes the market
work for everyone.
249
921280
3120
15:38
And that is why I am convinced
250
926000
2256
15:40
that real and fair competition
251
928280
3176
15:43
has a vital role to play
252
931480
2056
15:45
in building the trust we need
253
933560
2176
15:47
to get the best of our societies,
254
935760
3120
15:52
and that starts with enforcing our rules,
255
940000
4976
15:57
actually just to make
the market work for everyone.
256
945000
3816
16:00
Thank you.
257
948840
1376
16:02
(Applause)
258
950240
3440
16:07
Bruno Giussani: Thank you.
259
955760
1280
16:11
Thank you, Commissioner.
260
959360
1256
16:12
Margrethe Vestager: It was a pleasure.
261
960640
1856
16:14
BG: I want to ask you two questions.
262
962520
1736
16:16
The first one is about data,
because I have the impression
263
964280
2736
16:19
that technology and data are changing
the way competition takes place
264
967040
3416
16:22
and the way competition regulation
is designed and enforced.
265
970480
4656
16:27
Can you maybe comment on that?
266
975160
1656
16:28
MV: Well, yes, it is
definitely challenging us,
267
976840
3336
16:32
because we both have to sharpen our tools
268
980200
3216
16:35
but also to develop new tools.
269
983440
1840
16:38
When we were going through
the Google responses
270
986120
2856
16:41
to our statement of objection,
271
989000
2736
16:43
we were going through
5.2 terabytes of data.
272
991760
4200
16:49
It's quite a lot.
273
997080
1520
16:51
So we had to set up new systems.
274
999320
3296
16:54
We had to figure out how to do this,
275
1002640
2616
16:57
because you cannot work
the way you did just a few years ago.
276
1005280
4096
17:01
So we are definitely
sharpening up our working methods.
277
1009400
3880
17:05
The other thing is
that we try to distinguish
278
1013880
2136
17:08
between different kinds of data,
279
1016040
1696
17:09
because some data is extremely valuable
280
1017760
2576
17:12
and they will form, like,
a barrier to entry in a market.
281
1020360
3256
17:15
Other things you can just --
it loses its value tomorrow.
282
1023640
4040
17:20
So we try to make sure
283
1028560
1536
17:22
that we never, ever underestimate the fact
284
1030119
3457
17:25
that data works
as a currency in the market
285
1033599
3977
17:29
and as an asset that can be
a real barrier for competition.
286
1037599
5041
17:35
BG: Google. You fined them
2.8 billion euros a few months ago.
287
1043560
4536
17:40
MV: No, that was dollars.
It's not so strong these days.
288
1048119
2657
17:42
BG: Ah, well, depends on the --
289
1050800
1496
17:44
(Laughter)
290
1052320
1016
17:45
Google appealed the case.
The case is going to court.
291
1053360
2496
17:47
It will last a while.
292
1055880
1560
17:50
Earlier, last year, you asked Apple
to pay 13 billion in back taxes,
293
1058240
4736
17:55
and you have also
investigated other companies,
294
1063000
3136
17:58
including European and Russian companies,
295
1066160
2056
18:00
not only American companies, by far.
296
1068240
2096
18:02
Yet the investigations
against the American companies
297
1070360
4296
18:06
are the ones that have attracted
the most attention
298
1074680
2416
18:09
and they have also attracted
some accusations.
299
1077120
3016
18:12
You have been accused, essentially,
of protectionism, of jealousy,
300
1080160
3136
18:15
or using legislation
to hit back at American companies
301
1083320
2896
18:18
that have conquered European markets.
302
1086240
2296
18:20
"The Economist" just this week
on the front page writes,
303
1088560
3456
18:24
"Vestager Versus The Valley."
304
1092040
1896
18:25
How do you react to that?
305
1093960
1320
18:28
MV: Well, first of all,
I take it very seriously,
306
1096600
3216
18:31
because bias has no room
in law enforcement.
307
1099840
5320
18:38
We have to prove our cases
with the evidence and the facts
308
1106160
3176
18:41
and the jurisprudence
309
1109360
2016
18:43
in order also to present it to the courts.
310
1111400
2040
18:46
The second thing is
that Europe is open for business,
311
1114760
3936
18:50
but not for tax evasion.
312
1118720
1736
18:52
(Applause)
313
1120480
3680
18:58
The thing is that we are changing,
314
1126800
3736
19:02
and for instance,
when I ask my daughters --
315
1130560
2216
19:04
they use Google as well --
316
1132800
1536
19:06
"Why do you do that?"
317
1134360
1496
19:07
They say, "Well, because it works.
It's a very good product."
318
1135880
2976
19:10
They would never, ever,
come up with the answer,
319
1138880
2456
19:13
"It's because it's a US product."
320
1141360
1720
19:15
It's just because it works.
321
1143960
1856
19:17
And that is of course how it should be.
322
1145840
2056
19:19
But just the same, it is important
that someone is looking after to say,
323
1147920
3416
19:23
"Well, we congratulate you
324
1151360
2336
19:25
while you grow and grow and grow,
325
1153720
2536
19:28
but congratulation stops
326
1156280
1736
19:30
if we find that you're
misusing your position
327
1158040
2280
19:34
to harm competitors
so that they cannot serve consumers."
328
1162000
4216
19:38
BG: It will be
a fascinating case to follow.
329
1166240
2096
19:40
Thank you for coming to TED.
330
1168360
1376
19:41
MV: It was a pleasure. Thanks a lot.
331
1169760
1736
19:43
(Applause)
332
1171520
3760

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Margrethe Vestager - Commissioner for Competition, European Union
Margrethe Vestager is in charge of regulating commercial activity across the European Union and enforcing the EU’s rules designed to keep the markets fair.

Why you should listen
Margrethe Vestager has been described as "the most powerful woman in Brussels" -- otherwise said, in European politics. As Commissioner for Competition for the European Union, Vestager is in charge of regulating commercial activity across the 28 member states and enforcing the EU's rules designed to keep the markets fair -- rules that, she believes, some big companies have been abusing. In 2016, Vestager ordered Apple to pay €13 bn (about US$15.3 bn) in back taxes. In June 2017, she fined Google €2.4 bn (US$2.8 bn) for manipulating search results in favor of its own services. Other antitrust cases are open against Google. Facebook, Amazon, Russian natural gas producer Gazprom, Italian carmaker Fiat and others are also on her radar screen.

Born in Denmark, Vestager held various ministerial posts in her country's government before being appointed to the European Commission in 2014. Her politics are liberal in the classic meaning of the term: free speech, free assembly and free trade -- but she argues that it can only happen if markets are free of undue influence and anti-competitive behaviors.
More profile about the speaker
Margrethe Vestager | Speaker | TED.com