ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Melanie Nezer - Refugee and immigrants rights attorney
Melanie Nezer is a national leader in efforts to inform and educate individuals, institutions, elected officials and communities about refugees and asylum seekers.

Why you should listen

Melanie Nezer is Senior Vice President for Public Affairs for HIAS, the American Jewish community's international refugee agency. Founded in 1881, HIAS is the oldest refugee agency in the world and has helped refugees from all over the world find safety and freedom. In 17 years at HIAS, Nezer has shaped much of the agency's policy and advocacy agenda and its legal work. She previously served as HIAS's Vice President for Policy and Advocacy, as Migration Policy Counsel and as Director of HIAS's Employment Visa Program, representing at-risk Jewish professionals and religious workers seeking to work in the US during times of instability and crisis in their home countries.

Before joining HIAS, Nezer was the Immigration Policy Director for the organization now known as US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants, where -- in addition to conducting advocacy on immigration and asylum issues -- she was co-editor of Refugee Reports and a writer for the annual World Refugee Survey. Prior to her work in Washington DC, Nezer was in private legal practice in Miami, Florida, where she specialized in immigration law and criminal defense.

Learn more about Nezer's work by watching "The Ground Beneath My Children's Feet: Refugees and the Jewish Story," "'We Stand with You'": HIAS Responds to Synagogue Massacre with Message of Hope for Refugees," by listening to "HIAS Responds to Deadly Attack on Pittsburgh Synagogue," and by reading "Refugee Order Demystified, Q&A with Nezer of HIAS," and "The Global Plan for Dealing with Refugees Isn't Broken, It's Nearly Broke."

More profile about the speaker
Melanie Nezer | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxMidAtlantic

Melanie Nezer: The fundamental right to seek asylum

Filmed:
1,577,377 views

Refugee and immigrants rights attorney Melanie Nezer shares an urgently needed historical perspective on the crisis at the southern US border, showing how citizens can hold their governments accountable for protecting the vulnerable. "A country shows strength through compassion and pragmatism, not through force and through fear," she says.
- Refugee and immigrants rights attorney
Melanie Nezer is a national leader in efforts to inform and educate individuals, institutions, elected officials and communities about refugees and asylum seekers. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Last summer, I got a call
from a woman named Ellie.
0
852
3173
00:16
And she had heard about the family
separations at the southern border
1
4049
3240
00:19
and wanted to know
what she could do to help.
2
7313
2502
00:21
She told me the story
of her grandfather and his father.
3
9839
3949
00:26
When they were kids in Poland,
4
14285
2088
00:28
their father,
5
16397
1243
00:29
fearing for his son's safety,
6
17664
1904
00:31
gave them a little bit of money
and told them to walk west,
7
19592
3134
00:34
to just keep walking west across Europe.
8
22750
2360
00:37
And they did.
9
25134
1159
00:38
They walked all the way
west across Europe,
10
26317
2018
00:40
and they got on a boat
and they got to America.
11
28359
3026
00:44
Ellie said that when she heard
the stories of the teens
12
32159
4020
00:48
walking up across Mexico,
13
36203
2396
00:50
all she could think about
was her grandfather and his brother.
14
38623
4601
00:55
She said that for her, the stories
were exactly the same.
15
43248
3688
00:59
Those brothers were
the Hassenfeld Brothers --
16
47841
3591
01:03
the "Has" "bros" --
17
51456
1904
01:06
the Hasbro toy company,
18
54596
2173
01:08
which, of course, brought us
Mr. Potato Head.
19
56793
3151
01:13
But that is not actually why
I'm telling you this story.
20
61254
3127
01:17
I'm telling you this story
because it made me think
21
65302
3260
01:20
about whether I would have the faith,
22
68586
3217
01:23
the courage,
23
71827
1545
01:25
to send my teens --
and I have three of them --
24
73396
3419
01:28
on a journey like that.
25
76839
1328
01:31
Knowing that they wouldn't
be safe where we were,
26
79169
3407
01:34
would I be able to watch them go?
27
82600
2086
01:38
I started my career decades ago
at the southern US border,
28
86995
4879
01:43
working with Central American
asylum seekers.
29
91898
2519
01:46
And in the last 16 years,
I've been at HIAS,
30
94928
3566
01:50
the Jewish organization that fights
for refugee rights around the world,
31
98518
4101
01:54
as a lawyer and an advocate.
32
102643
1689
01:56
And one thing I've learned
is that, sometimes,
33
104919
3493
02:01
the things that we're told
make us safer and stronger
34
109229
3890
02:05
actually don't.
35
113143
1205
02:07
And, in fact, some of these policies
have the opposite of the intended results
36
115262
4939
02:12
and in the meantime, cause tremendous
and unnecessary suffering.
37
120225
5103
02:18
So why are people showing up
at our southern border?
38
126571
3137
02:21
Most of the immigrants and refugees
that are coming to our southern border
39
129732
3478
02:25
are fleeing three countries:
Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador.
40
133234
4114
02:29
These countries are consistently ranked
41
137952
2408
02:32
among the most violent
countries in the world.
42
140384
3311
02:35
It's very difficult to be safe
in these countries,
43
143719
2367
02:38
let alone build a future
for yourself and your family.
44
146110
3265
02:42
And violence against
women and girls is pervasive.
45
150180
2977
02:46
People have been fleeing Central America
46
154021
3270
02:49
for generations.
47
157315
1580
02:50
Generations of refugees
have been coming to our shores,
48
158919
2608
02:53
fleeing the civil wars of the 1980s,
49
161551
4761
02:58
in which the United States
was deeply involved.
50
166336
2232
03:01
This is nothing new.
51
169227
1357
03:03
What's new is that recently,
there's been a spike in families,
52
171169
4768
03:07
children and families,
showing up at checkpoints
53
175961
2794
03:10
and presenting themselves to seek asylum.
54
178779
2335
03:14
Now, this has been in the news lately,
55
182262
2166
03:16
so I want you to remember a few things
as you see those images.
56
184452
3318
03:19
One, this is not a historically high level
of interceptions at the southern border,
57
187794
6094
03:25
and, in fact, people are presenting
themselves at checkpoints.
58
193912
3111
03:29
Two, people are showing up
with the clothes on their backs;
59
197444
4871
03:34
some of them are literally in flip-flops.
60
202339
2342
03:36
And three, we're the most
powerful country in the world.
61
204705
2946
03:40
It's not a time to panic.
62
208204
1604
03:42
It's easy from the safety
of the destination country
63
210601
2526
03:45
to think in terms of absolutes:
64
213151
1871
03:47
Is it legal, or is it illegal?
65
215046
2299
03:49
But the people who are wrestling
with these questions
66
217734
2503
03:52
and making these decisions
about their families
67
220261
3815
03:56
are thinking about
very different questions:
68
224100
2564
03:58
How do I keep my daughter safe?
69
226688
1873
04:01
How do I protect my son?
70
229458
1442
04:04
And if you want absolutes,
71
232114
2260
04:06
it's absolutely legal to seek asylum.
72
234398
3013
04:09
It is a fundamental right in our own laws
and in international law.
73
237862
4887
04:14
And, in fact --
74
242773
1190
04:15
(Applause)
75
243987
6864
04:22
it stems from the 1951 Refugee Convention,
76
250875
3541
04:26
which was the world's response
to the Holocaust
77
254440
3072
04:29
and a way for countries to say never again
would we return people to countries
78
257536
3810
04:33
where they would harmed or killed.
79
261370
2204
04:36
There are several ways
refugees come to this country.
80
264306
2521
04:38
One is through the US Refugee
Admissions Program.
81
266851
2804
04:41
Through that program, the US identifies
and selects refugees abroad
82
269679
4130
04:45
and brings them to the United States.
83
273833
2056
04:48
Last year, the US resettled fewer refugees
84
276527
3642
04:52
than at any time since
the program began in 1980.
85
280193
3681
04:55
And this year, it'll probably be less.
86
283898
1958
04:58
And this is at a time when we have
more refugees in the world
87
286800
2963
05:01
than at any other time
in recorded history,
88
289787
2055
05:03
even since World War II.
89
291866
1389
05:06
Another way that refugees
come to this country is by seeking asylum.
90
294020
3767
05:09
Asylum seekers are people
who present themselves at a border
91
297811
3285
05:13
and say that they'll be persecuted
if they're sent back home.
92
301120
3304
05:16
An asylum seeker is simply somebody
who's going through the process
93
304448
3214
05:19
in the United States
94
307686
1159
05:20
to prove that they meet
the refugee definition.
95
308869
2538
05:25
And it's never been
more difficult to seek asylum.
96
313407
3436
05:28
Border guards are telling people
when they show up at our borders
97
316867
3078
05:31
that our country's full,
that they simply can't apply.
98
319969
2549
05:34
This is unprecedented and illegal.
99
322542
1811
05:36
Under a new program,
100
324828
2240
05:39
with the kind of Orwellian title
"Migrant Protection Protocols,"
101
327092
4166
05:44
refugees are told
they have to wait in Mexico
102
332472
2656
05:47
while their cases make their way
through the courts in the United States,
103
335152
3478
05:50
and this can take months or years.
104
338654
1656
05:52
Meanwhile, they're not safe,
105
340334
1819
05:54
and they have no access to lawyers.
106
342177
2023
05:57
Our country, our government,
has detained over 3,000 children,
107
345830
4360
06:02
separating them from their parents' arms,
108
350214
2577
06:04
as a deterrent from seeking asylum.
109
352815
2086
06:07
Many were toddlers,
110
355723
1409
06:09
and at least one was
a six-year-old blind girl.
111
357913
2644
06:12
And this is still going on.
112
360581
1481
06:14
We spend billions to detain people
in what are virtually prisons
113
362812
3868
06:18
who have committed no crime.
114
366704
1537
06:22
And family separation has become
the hallmark of our immigration system.
115
370799
5431
06:28
That's a far cry from a shining city
on a hill or a beacon of hope
116
376603
5058
06:33
or all of the other ways we like to talk
about ourselves and our values.
117
381685
3839
06:38
Migration has always been with us,
and it always will be.
118
386137
3248
06:41
The reasons why people flee --
persecution, war, violence,
119
389899
3679
06:45
climate change
120
393602
1513
06:47
and the ability now to see on your phone
what life is like in other places --
121
395139
4290
06:51
those pressures are only growing.
122
399453
1816
06:54
But there are ways that we can have
policies that reflect our values
123
402602
5677
07:00
and actually make sense,
given the reality in the world.
124
408303
2915
07:03
The first thing we need to do
is dial back the toxic rhetoric
125
411980
6083
07:10
that has been the basis of our national
debate on this issue for too long.
126
418087
4691
07:15
(Applause)
127
423437
5114
07:22
I am not an immigrant or a refugee myself,
128
430702
3144
07:25
but I take these attacks personally,
because my grandparents were.
129
433870
4000
07:31
My great-grandmother Rose
didn't see her kids for seven years,
130
439211
4548
07:35
as she tried to bring them
from Poland to New York.
131
443783
2462
07:38
She left my grandfather
when he was seven
132
446269
1931
07:40
and didn't see him again
until he was 14.
133
448224
2021
07:42
On the other side of my family,
134
450269
1596
07:43
my grandmother Aliza
left Poland in the 1930s
135
451889
3637
07:47
and left for what was then
the British Mandate of Palestine,
136
455550
2873
07:50
and she never saw
her family and friends again.
137
458447
2246
07:53
Global cooperation as a response
to global migration and displacement
138
461741
5054
07:58
would go a long way towards making
migration something that isn't a crisis
139
466819
4485
08:03
but something that just is,
140
471328
1353
08:04
and that we deal with
as a global community.
141
472705
2548
08:08
Humanitarian aid is also critical.
142
476488
2405
08:10
The amount of support we provide
to countries in Central America
143
478917
3001
08:13
that are sending refugees and migrants
144
481942
2429
08:16
is a tiny fraction of the amount
we spend on enforcement and detention.
145
484395
5195
08:22
And we can absolutely
have an asylum system that works.
146
490756
3769
08:27
For a tiny fraction of the cost of a wall,
147
495460
2720
08:30
we could hire more judges,
148
498204
1381
08:31
make sure asylum seekers have lawyers
149
499609
2230
08:33
and commit to a humane asylum system.
150
501863
2521
08:36
(Applause)
151
504955
4666
08:45
And we could resettle more refugees.
152
513090
2566
08:48
To give you a sense of the decline
in the refugee program:
153
516118
3173
08:51
three years ago, the US resettled
15,000 Syrian refugees
154
519315
4259
08:55
in response to the largest
refugee crisis on earth.
155
523598
2639
08:58
A year later, that number was 3,000.
156
526261
3117
09:01
And last year, that number was 62 people.
157
529402
3435
09:06
62 people.
158
534109
1731
09:08
Despite the harsh rhetoric
and efforts to block immigration,
159
536819
3900
09:12
keep refugees out of the country,
160
540743
1937
09:14
support for refugees and immigrants
in this country, according to polls,
161
542704
3381
09:18
has never been higher.
162
546109
1243
09:19
Organizations like HIAS, where I work,
163
547376
1941
09:21
and other humanitarian
and faith-based organizations,
164
549341
2508
09:23
make it easy for you to take a stand
165
551873
2147
09:26
when there's a law that's worth opposing
166
554044
2570
09:28
or a law that's worth supporting
or a policy that needs oversight.
167
556638
3377
09:32
If you have a phone,
168
560485
1351
09:33
you can do something,
169
561860
1323
09:35
and if you want to do more, you can.
170
563207
1748
09:36
I will tell you that if you see
one of these detention centers
171
564979
3596
09:40
along the border
172
568599
1255
09:41
with children in them -- they're jails --
173
569878
1957
09:43
you will never be the same.
174
571849
1473
09:47
What I loved so much
about my call with Ellie
175
575320
2595
09:50
was that she knew in her core
that the stories of her grandparents
176
578792
3856
09:55
were no different than today's stories,
177
583537
2139
09:57
and she wanted to do something about it.
178
585700
2066
10:00
If I leave you with one thing,
179
588974
2346
10:03
beyond the backstory
for Mr. Potato Head,
180
591344
2402
10:05
which is, of course,
a good story to leave with,
181
593770
3428
10:09
it's that a country shows strength
182
597222
4148
10:14
through compassion and pragmatism,
183
602522
2317
10:16
not through force and through fear.
184
604863
1907
10:19
(Applause)
185
607448
5993
10:29
These stories of the Hassenfelds
and my relatives and your relatives
186
617139
4166
10:33
are still happening today;
they're all the same.
187
621329
2550
10:37
A country is strong
when it says to the refugee,
188
625269
3277
10:40
not, "Go away," but,
189
628570
3197
10:43
"It's OK, we've got you, you're safe."
190
631791
2817
10:47
Thank you.
191
635112
1163
10:48
(Applause)
192
636299
2825
10:51
Thanks.
193
639148
1206
10:52
(Applause)
194
640378
1361

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Melanie Nezer - Refugee and immigrants rights attorney
Melanie Nezer is a national leader in efforts to inform and educate individuals, institutions, elected officials and communities about refugees and asylum seekers.

Why you should listen

Melanie Nezer is Senior Vice President for Public Affairs for HIAS, the American Jewish community's international refugee agency. Founded in 1881, HIAS is the oldest refugee agency in the world and has helped refugees from all over the world find safety and freedom. In 17 years at HIAS, Nezer has shaped much of the agency's policy and advocacy agenda and its legal work. She previously served as HIAS's Vice President for Policy and Advocacy, as Migration Policy Counsel and as Director of HIAS's Employment Visa Program, representing at-risk Jewish professionals and religious workers seeking to work in the US during times of instability and crisis in their home countries.

Before joining HIAS, Nezer was the Immigration Policy Director for the organization now known as US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants, where -- in addition to conducting advocacy on immigration and asylum issues -- she was co-editor of Refugee Reports and a writer for the annual World Refugee Survey. Prior to her work in Washington DC, Nezer was in private legal practice in Miami, Florida, where she specialized in immigration law and criminal defense.

Learn more about Nezer's work by watching "The Ground Beneath My Children's Feet: Refugees and the Jewish Story," "'We Stand with You'": HIAS Responds to Synagogue Massacre with Message of Hope for Refugees," by listening to "HIAS Responds to Deadly Attack on Pittsburgh Synagogue," and by reading "Refugee Order Demystified, Q&A with Nezer of HIAS," and "The Global Plan for Dealing with Refugees Isn't Broken, It's Nearly Broke."

More profile about the speaker
Melanie Nezer | Speaker | TED.com