ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tim Harford - Economist, journalist, broadcaster
Tim Harford's writings reveal the economic ideas behind everyday experiences.

Why you should listen

In the Undercover Economist column he writes for the Financial Times, Tim Harford looks at familiar situations in unfamiliar ways and explains the fundamental principles of the modern economy. He illuminates them with clear writing and a variety of examples borrowed from daily life.

His book, Adapt: Why Success Always Starts With Failure, argues that the world has become far too unpredictable and complex for today's challenges to be tackled with ready-made solutions and expert opinions. Instead, Harford suggests, we need to learn to embrace failure and to constantly adapt, to improvise rather than plan, to work from the bottom up rather than the top down. His next book, Messy: Thriving in a Tidy-Minded World will be published in September 2016. 

Harford also presents the BBC radio series More or Less, a rare broadcast program devoted, as he says, to "the powerful, sometimes beautiful, often abused but ever ubiquitous world of numbers."

He says: "I’d like to see many more complex problems approached with a willingness to experiment."

More profile about the speaker
Tim Harford | Speaker | TED.com
TED@Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany

Tim Harford: A powerful way to unleash your natural creativity

Filmed:
3,773,596 views

What can we learn from the world's most enduringly creative people? They "slow-motion multitask," actively juggling multiple projects and moving between topics as the mood strikes -- without feeling hurried. Author Tim Harford shares how innovators like Einstein, Darwin, Twyla Tharp and Michael Crichton found their inspiration and productivity through cross-training their minds.
- Economist, journalist, broadcaster
Tim Harford's writings reveal the economic ideas behind everyday experiences. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
"To do two things at once
is to do neither."
0
1640
4216
00:17
It's a great smackdown
of multitasking, isn't it,
1
5880
2776
00:20
often attributed to
the Roman writer Publilius Syrus,
2
8680
3536
00:24
although you know how these things are,
he probably never said it.
3
12240
3680
00:28
What I'm interested in, though,
is -- is it true?
4
16640
3296
00:31
I mean, it's obviously true
for emailing at the dinner table
5
19960
3696
00:35
or texting while driving or possibly
for live tweeting at TED Talk, as well.
6
23680
5376
00:41
But I'd like to argue
that for an important kind of activity,
7
29080
4696
00:45
doing two things at once --
or three or even four --
8
33800
2816
00:48
is exactly what we should be aiming for.
9
36640
3136
00:51
Look no further than Albert Einstein.
10
39800
2736
00:54
In 1905, he published
four remarkable scientific papers.
11
42560
4176
00:58
One of them was on Brownian motion,
12
46760
1936
01:00
it provided empirical evidence
that atoms exist,
13
48720
3336
01:04
and it laid out the basic mathematics
behind most of financial economics.
14
52080
4216
01:08
Another one was on the theory
of special relativity.
15
56320
2856
01:11
Another one was
on the photoelectric effect,
16
59200
2696
01:13
that's why solar panels work,
it's a nice one.
17
61920
2360
01:17
Gave him the Nobel prize for that one.
18
65280
2216
01:19
And the fourth introduced an equation
you might have heard of:
19
67520
3136
01:22
E equals mc squared.
20
70680
2296
01:25
So, tell me again how you
shouldn't do several things at once.
21
73000
3576
01:28
Now, obviously, working simultaneously
22
76600
3376
01:32
on Brownian motion, special relativity
and the photoelectric effect --
23
80000
3896
01:35
it's not exactly the same
kind of multitasking
24
83920
2536
01:38
as Snapchatting while
you're watching "Westworld."
25
86480
2616
01:41
Very different.
26
89120
1456
01:42
And Einstein, yeah, well,
Einstein's -- he's Einstein,
27
90600
3656
01:46
he's one of a kind, he's unique.
28
94280
1560
01:48
But the pattern of behavior
that Einstein was demonstrating,
29
96680
3216
01:51
that's not unique at all.
30
99920
2576
01:54
It's very common
among highly creative people,
31
102520
3296
01:57
both artists and scientists,
32
105840
2656
02:00
and I'd like to give it a name:
33
108520
1696
02:02
slow-motion multitasking.
34
110240
2800
02:06
Slow-motion multitasking
feels like a counterintuitive idea.
35
114160
4376
02:10
What I'm describing here
36
118560
1456
02:12
is having multiple projects
on the go at the same time,
37
120040
3696
02:15
and you move backwards and forwards
between topics as the mood takes you,
38
123760
4616
02:20
or as the situation demands.
39
128400
1976
02:22
But the reason it seems counterintuitive
40
130400
2376
02:24
is because we're used to lapsing
into multitasking out of desperation.
41
132800
4176
02:29
We're in a hurry,
we want to do everything at once.
42
137000
2520
02:32
If we were willing
to slow multitasking down,
43
140720
4136
02:36
we might find that it works
quite brilliantly.
44
144880
3520
02:41
Sixty years ago, a young psychologist
by the name of Bernice Eiduson
45
149720
4696
02:46
began a long research project
46
154440
1976
02:48
into the personalities
and the working habits
47
156440
3096
02:51
of 40 leading scientists.
48
159560
2696
02:54
Einstein was already dead,
49
162280
1656
02:55
but four of her subjects won Nobel prizes,
50
163960
2936
02:58
including Linus Pauling
and Richard Feynman.
51
166920
2760
03:02
The research went on for decades,
52
170560
1616
03:04
in fact, it continued even after
professor Eiduson herself had died.
53
172200
4256
03:08
And one of the questions that it answered
54
176480
2496
03:11
was, "How is it that some scientists
are able to go on producing important work
55
179000
6536
03:17
right through their lives?"
56
185560
2096
03:19
What is it about these people?
57
187680
1656
03:21
Is it their personality,
is it their skill set,
58
189360
3896
03:25
their daily routines, what?
59
193280
2120
03:28
Well, a pattern that emerged was clear,
and I think to some people surprising.
60
196400
5000
03:34
The top scientists
kept changing the subject.
61
202520
4816
03:39
They would shift topics repeatedly
62
207360
2736
03:42
during their first 100
published research papers.
63
210120
4016
03:46
Do you want to guess how often?
64
214160
2176
03:48
Three times?
65
216360
1736
03:50
Five times?
66
218120
1200
03:52
No. On average, the most
enduringly creative scientists
67
220280
4136
03:56
switched topics 43 times
in their first 100 research papers.
68
224440
6240
04:03
Seems that the secret
to creativity is multitasking
69
231840
4776
04:08
in slow motion.
70
236640
1200
04:11
Eiduson's research suggests
we need to reclaim multitasking
71
239400
3776
04:15
and remind ourselves
how powerful it can be.
72
243200
3096
04:18
And she's not the only person
to have found this.
73
246320
2336
04:20
Different researchers,
74
248680
1216
04:21
using different methods
to study different highly creative people
75
249920
3576
04:25
have found that very often
they have multiple projects in progress
76
253520
3616
04:29
at the same time,
77
257160
1215
04:30
and they're also far more likely
than most of us to have serious hobbies.
78
258399
4737
04:35
Slow-motion multitasking
among creative people is ubiquitous.
79
263160
4440
04:40
So, why?
80
268480
1200
04:43
I think there are three reasons.
81
271160
1576
04:44
And the first is the simplest.
82
272760
2536
04:47
Creativity often comes when you take
an idea from its original context
83
275320
4256
04:51
and you move it somewhere else.
84
279600
1496
04:53
It's easier to think outside the box
85
281120
1736
04:54
if you spend your time clambering
from one box into another.
86
282880
3120
04:58
For an example of this,
consider the original eureka moment.
87
286840
5040
05:04
Archimedes -- he's wrestling
with a difficult problem.
88
292520
3656
05:08
And he realizes, in a flash,
89
296200
2496
05:10
he can solve it, using
the displacement of water.
90
298720
3656
05:14
And if you believe the story,
91
302400
1696
05:16
this idea comes to him
as he's taking a bath,
92
304120
3496
05:19
lowering himself in, and he's watching
the water level rise and fall.
93
307640
5176
05:24
And if solving a problem
while having a bath isn't multitasking,
94
312840
4616
05:29
I don't know what is.
95
317480
1400
05:32
The second reason
that multitasking can work
96
320200
2416
05:34
is that learning to do one thing well
97
322640
3376
05:38
can often help you do something else.
98
326040
2536
05:40
Any athlete can tell you
about the benefits of cross-training.
99
328600
2976
05:43
It's possible to cross-train
your mind, too.
100
331600
2560
05:47
A few years ago, researchers took
18 randomly chosen medical students
101
335400
5096
05:52
and they enrolled them in a course
at the Philadelphia Museum of Art,
102
340520
5136
05:57
where they learned to criticize
and analyze works of visual art.
103
345680
4776
06:02
And at the end of the course,
104
350480
1856
06:04
these students were compared
with a control group
105
352360
2616
06:07
of their fellow medical students.
106
355000
1576
06:08
And the ones who had taken the art course
107
356600
2736
06:11
had become substantially better
at performing tasks
108
359360
3816
06:15
such as diagnosing diseases of the eye
by analyzing photographs.
109
363200
4856
06:20
They'd become better eye doctors.
110
368080
2696
06:22
So if we want to become
better at what we do,
111
370800
3016
06:25
maybe we should spend some time
doing something else,
112
373840
2536
06:28
even if the two fields
appear to be as completely distinct
113
376400
3736
06:32
as ophthalmology and the history of art.
114
380160
3160
06:36
And if you'd like an example of this,
115
384360
2816
06:39
should we go for a less intimidating
example than Einstein? OK.
116
387200
3336
06:42
Michael Crichton, creator
of "Jurassic Park" and "E.R."
117
390560
4336
06:46
So in the 1970s,
he originally trained as a doctor,
118
394920
3376
06:50
but then he wrote novels
119
398320
2536
06:52
and he directed
the original "Westworld" movie.
120
400880
3256
06:56
But also, and this is less well-known,
121
404160
2136
06:58
he also wrote nonfiction books,
122
406320
1736
07:00
about art, about medicine,
about computer programming.
123
408080
3200
07:04
So in 1995, he enjoyed
the fruits of all this variety
124
412480
5056
07:09
by penning the world's
most commercially successful book.
125
417560
4200
07:14
And the world's most commercially
successful TV series.
126
422440
4320
07:19
And the world's most commercially
successful movie.
127
427680
3680
07:24
In 1996, he did it all over again.
128
432280
2880
07:29
There's a third reason
129
437240
1656
07:30
why slow-motion multitasking
can help us solve problems.
130
438920
4296
07:35
It can provide assistance
when we're stuck.
131
443240
3696
07:38
This can't happen in an instant.
132
446960
2216
07:41
So, imagine that feeling
of working on a crossword puzzle
133
449200
3376
07:44
and you can't figure out the answer,
134
452600
1776
07:46
and the reason you can't is because
the wrong answer is stuck in your head.
135
454400
4176
07:50
It's very easy --
just go and do something else.
136
458600
2536
07:53
You know, switch topics, switch context,
137
461160
2856
07:56
you'll forget the wrong answer
138
464040
1456
07:57
and that gives the right answer space
to pop into the front of your mind.
139
465520
3600
08:02
But on the slower timescale
that interests me,
140
470080
3776
08:05
being stuck is a much more serious thing.
141
473880
2000
08:08
You get turned down for funding.
142
476920
2120
08:11
Your cell cultures won't grow,
your rockets keep crashing.
143
479760
3240
08:16
Nobody wants to publish you fantasy novel
about a school for wizards.
144
484000
3880
08:21
Or maybe you just can't find the solution
to the problem that you're working on.
145
489040
4496
08:25
And being stuck like that
means stasis, stress,
146
493560
4736
08:30
possibly even depression.
147
498320
1680
08:33
But if you have another exciting,
challenging project to work on,
148
501280
5176
08:38
being stuck on one is just an opportunity
to do something else.
149
506480
4136
08:42
We could all get stuck sometimes,
even Albert Einstein.
150
510640
3976
08:46
Ten years after the original,
miraculous year that I described,
151
514640
4375
08:51
Einstein was putting together the pieces
of his theory of general relativity,
152
519039
4937
08:56
his greatest achievement.
153
524000
1920
08:58
And he was exhausted.
154
526680
1320
09:01
And so he turned to an easier problem.
155
529080
2776
09:03
He proposed the stimulated
emission of radiation.
156
531880
3576
09:07
Which, as you may know, is the S in laser.
157
535480
4816
09:12
So he's laying down the theoretical
foundation for the laser beam,
158
540320
4496
09:16
and then, while he's doing that,
159
544840
1856
09:18
he moves back to general relativity,
and he's refreshed.
160
546720
3216
09:21
He sees what the theory implies --
161
549960
3336
09:25
that the universe isn't static.
162
553320
3336
09:28
It's expanding.
163
556680
1616
09:30
It's an idea so staggering,
164
558320
2096
09:32
Einstein can't bring himself
to believe it for years.
165
560440
3920
09:37
Look, if you get stuck
166
565680
2296
09:40
and you get the ball rolling
on laser beams,
167
568000
4440
09:45
you're in pretty good shape.
168
573520
1456
09:47
(Laughter)
169
575000
1976
09:49
So, that's the case
for slow-motion multitasking.
170
577000
3496
09:52
And I'm not promising
that it's going to turn you into Einstein.
171
580520
3016
09:55
I'm not even promising it's going
to turn you into Michael Crichton.
172
583560
3216
09:58
But it is a powerful way
to organize our creative lives.
173
586800
2960
10:03
But there's a problem.
174
591240
1480
10:06
How do we stop all of these projects
becoming completely overwhelming?
175
594360
5080
10:12
How do we keep all these ideas
straight in our minds?
176
600520
3480
10:16
Well, here's a simple solution,
a practical solution
177
604920
3976
10:20
from the great American
choreographer, Twyla Tharp.
178
608920
3496
10:24
Over the last few decades,
179
612440
1776
10:26
she's blurred boundaries,
mixed genres, won prizes,
180
614240
4496
10:30
danced to the music of everybody,
from Philip Glass to Billy Joel.
181
618760
4776
10:35
She's written three books.
182
623560
1576
10:37
I mean, she's a slow-motion
multitasker, of course she is.
183
625160
3280
10:41
She says, "You have to be all things.
184
629800
4016
10:45
Why exclude?
185
633840
1616
10:47
You have to be everything."
186
635480
2560
10:51
And Tharp's method
187
639240
2376
10:53
for preventing all of these different
projects from becoming overwhelming
188
641640
4336
10:58
is a simple one.
189
646000
1296
10:59
She gives each project
a big cardboard box,
190
647320
2536
11:01
writes the name of the project
on the side of the box.
191
649880
2696
11:04
And into it, she tosses DVDs
and books, magazine cuttings,
192
652600
4416
11:09
theater programs, physical objects,
193
657040
1976
11:11
really anything that's provided a source
of creative inspiration.
194
659040
4976
11:16
And she writes,
195
664040
1736
11:17
"The box means I never
have to worry about forgetting.
196
665800
4240
11:22
One of the biggest fears
for a creative person
197
670880
2936
11:25
is that some brilliant idea will get lost
198
673840
2456
11:28
because you didn't write it down
and put it in a safe place.
199
676320
3480
11:32
I don't worry about that.
200
680920
1776
11:34
Because I know where to find it.
201
682720
2360
11:38
It's all in the box."
202
686160
1480
11:41
You can manage many ideas like this,
203
689480
2136
11:43
either in physical boxes
or in their digital equivalents.
204
691640
4656
11:48
So, I would like to urge you
205
696320
2256
11:50
to embrace the art
of slow-motion multitasking.
206
698600
3320
11:54
Not because you're in a hurry,
207
702720
2056
11:56
but because you're in no hurry at all.
208
704800
3040
12:01
And I want to give you one final example,
209
709360
2696
12:04
my favorite example.
210
712080
2136
12:06
Charles Darwin.
211
714240
1200
12:08
A man whose slow-burning
multitasking is so staggering,
212
716200
4696
12:12
I need a diagram to explain it all to you.
213
720920
3176
12:16
We know what Darwin
was doing at different times,
214
724120
2336
12:18
because the creativity researchers
Howard Gruber and Sara Davis
215
726480
3696
12:22
have analyzed his diaries
and his notebooks.
216
730200
2896
12:25
So, when he left school, age of 18,
217
733120
2576
12:27
he was initially interested in two fields,
218
735720
2616
12:30
zoology and geology.
219
738360
3256
12:33
Pretty soon, he signed up to be
the onboard naturalist on the "Beagle."
220
741640
4456
12:38
This is the ship
that eventually took five years
221
746120
2816
12:40
to sail all the way around
the southern oceans of the Earth,
222
748960
3496
12:44
stopping at the Galápagos,
passing through the Indian ocean.
223
752480
2816
12:47
While he was on the "Beagle,"
he began researching coral reefs.
224
755320
2976
12:50
This is a great synergy
between his two interests
225
758320
3256
12:53
in zoology and geology,
226
761600
1496
12:55
and it starts to get him thinking
about slow processes.
227
763120
4480
13:00
But when he gets back from the voyage,
228
768720
2776
13:03
his interests start to expand
even further: psychology, botany;
229
771520
4656
13:08
for the rest of his life,
230
776200
1336
13:09
he's moving backwards and forwards
between these different fields.
231
777560
3616
13:13
He never quite abandons any of them.
232
781200
2856
13:16
In 1837, he begins work
on two very interesting projects.
233
784080
3896
13:20
One of them: earthworms.
234
788000
2816
13:22
The other, a little notebook
which he titles
235
790840
3576
13:26
"The transmutation of species."
236
794440
2896
13:29
Then, Darwin starts
studying my field, economics.
237
797360
5936
13:35
He reads a book
by the economist Thomas Malthus.
238
803320
4856
13:40
And he has his eureka moment.
239
808200
2216
13:42
In a flash, he realizes how species
could emerge and evolve slowly,
240
810440
5536
13:48
through this process
of the survival of the fittest.
241
816000
3056
13:51
It all comes to him,
he writes it all down,
242
819080
2296
13:53
every single important element
of the theory of evolution,
243
821400
3736
13:57
in that notebook.
244
825160
1736
13:58
But then, a new project.
245
826920
3816
14:02
His son William is born.
246
830760
1600
14:05
Well, there's a natural
experiment right there,
247
833200
2696
14:07
you get to observe
the development of a human infant.
248
835920
2576
14:10
So immediately,
Darwin starts making notes.
249
838520
2696
14:13
Now, of course, he's still working
on the theory of evolution
250
841240
2896
14:16
and the development of the human infant.
251
844160
2856
14:19
But during all of this,
252
847040
1416
14:20
he realizes he doesn't really know
enough about taxonomy.
253
848480
4176
14:24
So he starts studying that.
254
852680
1736
14:26
And in the end, he spends eight years
becoming the world's leading expert
255
854440
6456
14:32
on barnacles.
256
860920
1440
14:35
Then, "Natural Selection."
257
863320
2096
14:37
A book that he's to continue working on
for his entire life, he never finishes it.
258
865440
5136
14:42
"Origin of Species" is finally published
259
870600
2856
14:45
20 years after Darwin set out
all the basic elements.
260
873480
3976
14:49
Then, the "Descent of Man,"
controversial book.
261
877480
2896
14:52
And then, the book about
the development of the human infant.
262
880400
3856
14:56
The one that was inspired
when he could see his son, William,
263
884280
4136
15:00
crawling on the sitting room
floor in front of him.
264
888440
3176
15:03
When the book was published,
William was 37 years old.
265
891640
4000
15:08
And all this time,
266
896640
2216
15:10
Darwin's working on earthworms.
267
898880
2976
15:13
He fills his billiard room with earthworms
in pots, with glass covers.
268
901880
5976
15:19
He shines lights on them,
to see if they'll respond.
269
907880
2696
15:22
He holds a hot poker next to them,
to see if they move away.
270
910600
2856
15:25
He chews tobacco and --
271
913480
1816
15:27
(Blows)
272
915320
1216
15:28
He blows on the earthworms
to see if they have a sense of smell.
273
916560
3016
15:31
He even plays the bassoon
at the earthworms.
274
919600
3280
15:36
I like to think of this great man
275
924200
2696
15:38
when he's tired, he's stressed,
276
926920
2456
15:41
he's anxious about the reception
of his book "The Descent of Man."
277
929400
4016
15:45
You or I might log into Facebook
or turn on the television.
278
933440
4080
15:50
Darwin would go
into the billiard room to relax
279
938440
3816
15:54
by studying the earthworms intensely.
280
942280
3080
15:58
And that's why it's appropriate
that one of his last great works
281
946960
3896
16:02
is the "Formation of Vegetable Mould
Through The Action of Worms."
282
950880
5016
16:07
(Laughter)
283
955920
1336
16:09
He worked upon that book for 44 years.
284
957280
5120
16:16
We don't live in the 19th century anymore.
285
964080
2696
16:18
I don't think any of us could sit
286
966800
2336
16:21
on our creative or scientific
projects for 44 years.
287
969160
4120
16:26
But we do have something to learn
from the great slow-motion multitaskers.
288
974280
4336
16:30
From Einstein and Darwin
to Michael Crichton and Twyla Tharp.
289
978640
5360
16:37
The modern world seems
to present us with a choice.
290
985040
3816
16:40
If we're not going to fast-twitch
from browser window to browser window,
291
988880
4016
16:44
we have to live like a hermit,
292
992920
1616
16:46
focus on one thing
to the exclusion of everything else.
293
994560
3320
16:50
I think that's a false dilemma.
294
998680
2376
16:53
We can make multitasking work for us,
295
1001080
2656
16:55
unleashing our natural creativity.
296
1003760
2560
16:59
We just need to slow it down.
297
1007440
1480
17:02
So ...
298
1010200
1240
17:04
Make a list of your projects.
299
1012880
2496
17:07
Put down your phone.
300
1015400
1400
17:09
Pick up a couple of cardboard boxes.
301
1017640
2040
17:12
And get to work.
302
1020880
1200
17:15
Thank you very much.
303
1023240
1376
17:16
(Applause)
304
1024640
3840

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tim Harford - Economist, journalist, broadcaster
Tim Harford's writings reveal the economic ideas behind everyday experiences.

Why you should listen

In the Undercover Economist column he writes for the Financial Times, Tim Harford looks at familiar situations in unfamiliar ways and explains the fundamental principles of the modern economy. He illuminates them with clear writing and a variety of examples borrowed from daily life.

His book, Adapt: Why Success Always Starts With Failure, argues that the world has become far too unpredictable and complex for today's challenges to be tackled with ready-made solutions and expert opinions. Instead, Harford suggests, we need to learn to embrace failure and to constantly adapt, to improvise rather than plan, to work from the bottom up rather than the top down. His next book, Messy: Thriving in a Tidy-Minded World will be published in September 2016. 

Harford also presents the BBC radio series More or Less, a rare broadcast program devoted, as he says, to "the powerful, sometimes beautiful, often abused but ever ubiquitous world of numbers."

He says: "I’d like to see many more complex problems approached with a willingness to experiment."

More profile about the speaker
Tim Harford | Speaker | TED.com