ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Yuval Noah Harari - Historian, author
In his book "Homo Deus," Yuval Noah Harari explores the future of humankind: the destinies we may set for ourselves and the quests we'll undertake.

Why you should listen

In his book, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, Yuval Noah Harari explores the projects, dreams and nightmares that will shape the 21st century -- from overcoming death to creating artificial life. He maps the future and asks fundamental questions: Where do we go from here? How will we protect this fragile world from our own destructive powers? The book has sold four million copies since its publication in 2016.

Harari's previous book, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, explores what made homo sapiens the most successful species on the planet. His answer: We are the only animal that can believe in things that exist purely in our imagination, such as gods, states, money, human rights, corporations and other fictions, and we have developed a unique ability to use these stories to unify and organize groups and ensure cooperation. Sapiens has sold eight million copies and been translated into more than 50 languages. Bill GatesMark Zuckerberg and President Barack Obama have recommended it as a must-read.

Harari lectures as a Professor of history at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, where he specializes in world history, medieval history and military history. His current research focuses on macro-historical questions: What is the relationship between history and biology? What is the essential difference between Homo sapiens and other animals? Is there justice in history? Does history have a direction? Did people become happier as history unfolded? Harari has written for newspapers such as The Guardian, Financial Times, the Times, Nature magazine and the Wall Street Journal.

Harari's new book, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, will take the pulse of our current global climate, focusing on the biggest questions of the present moment: What is really happening right now? What are today’s greatest challenges and choices? What should we pay attention to? The book will be published in multiple languages in September 2018.

More profile about the speaker
Yuval Noah Harari | Speaker | TED.com
TED2018

Yuval Noah Harari: Why fascism is so tempting -- and how your data could power it

Filmed:
3,018,055 views

In a profound talk about technology and power, author and historian Yuval Noah Harari explains the important difference between fascism and nationalism -- and what the consolidation of our data means for the future of democracy. Appearing as a hologram live from Tel Aviv, Harari warns that the greatest danger that now faces liberal democracy is that the revolution in information technology will make dictatorships more efficient and capable of control. "The enemies of liberal democracy hack our feelings of fear and hate and vanity, and then use these feelings to polarize and destroy," Harari says. "It is the responsibility of all of us to get to know our weaknesses and make sure they don't become weapons." (Followed by a brief conversation with TED curator Chris Anderson)
- Historian, author
In his book "Homo Deus," Yuval Noah Harari explores the future of humankind: the destinies we may set for ourselves and the quests we'll undertake. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Hello, everyone.
0
968
1150
00:15
It's a bit funny, because I did write
that humans will become digital,
1
3562
4936
00:20
but I didn't think it will happen so fast
2
8522
2714
00:23
and that it will happen to me.
3
11260
1659
00:25
But here I am, as a digital avatar,
4
13649
2682
00:28
and here you are, so let's start.
5
16355
2666
00:32
And let's start with a question.
6
20070
2133
00:34
How many fascists are there
in the audience today?
7
22823
3534
00:38
(Laughter)
8
26381
1450
00:39
Well, it's a bit difficult to say,
9
27855
2349
00:42
because we've forgotten what fascism is.
10
30228
3467
00:46
People now use the term "fascist"
11
34498
2579
00:49
as a kind of general-purpose abuse.
12
37101
3008
00:52
Or they confuse fascism with nationalism.
13
40133
3947
00:56
So let's take a few minutes
to clarify what fascism actually is,
14
44863
5388
01:02
and how it is different from nationalism.
15
50275
3120
01:05
The milder forms of nationalism
have been among the most benevolent
16
53838
5041
01:10
of human creations.
17
58903
1458
01:12
Nations are communities
of millions of strangers
18
60990
4111
01:17
who don't really know each other.
19
65125
1713
01:19
For example, I don't know
the eight million people
20
67489
3405
01:22
who share my Israeli citizenship.
21
70918
2556
01:26
But thanks to nationalism,
22
74109
2167
01:28
we can all care about one another
and cooperate effectively.
23
76300
3806
01:32
This is very good.
24
80450
1200
01:34
Some people, like John Lennon,
imagine that without nationalism,
25
82093
5738
01:39
the world will be a peaceful paradise.
26
87855
3790
01:44
But far more likely,
27
92010
1428
01:45
without nationalism,
we would have been living in tribal chaos.
28
93462
4777
01:50
If you look today at the most prosperous
and peaceful countries in the world,
29
98684
5135
01:55
countries like Sweden
and Switzerland and Japan,
30
103843
4290
02:00
you will see that they have
a very strong sense of nationalism.
31
108157
4963
02:05
In contrast, countries that lack
a strong sense of nationalism,
32
113750
4160
02:09
like Congo and Somalia and Afghanistan,
33
117934
3421
02:13
tend to be violent and poor.
34
121379
2174
02:16
So what is fascism, and how
is it different from nationalism?
35
124855
4138
02:21
Well, nationalism tells me
that my nation is unique,
36
129941
5403
02:27
and that I have special obligations
towards my nation.
37
135368
3801
02:31
Fascism, in contrast, tells me
that my nation is supreme,
38
139641
6206
02:37
and that I have exclusive
obligations towards it.
39
145871
3912
02:42
I don't need to care about anybody
or anything other than my nation.
40
150895
4831
02:48
Usually, of course,
people have many identities
41
156465
3603
02:52
and loyalties to different groups.
42
160092
2422
02:55
For example, I can be a good patriot,
loyal to my country,
43
163036
4804
02:59
and at the same time,
be loyal to my family,
44
167864
3238
03:03
my neighborhood, my profession,
45
171126
2361
03:05
humankind as a whole,
46
173511
1460
03:06
truth and beauty.
47
174995
1604
03:09
Of course, when I have different
identities and loyalties,
48
177370
4271
03:13
it sometimes creates conflicts
and complications.
49
181665
3333
03:17
But, well, who ever told you
that life was easy?
50
185506
3634
03:21
Life is complicated.
51
189649
2040
03:23
Deal with it.
52
191713
1150
03:26
Fascism is what happens when people try
to ignore the complications
53
194331
6000
03:32
and to make life too easy for themselves.
54
200355
3109
03:36
Fascism denies all identities
except the national identity
55
204128
5572
03:41
and insists that I have obligations
only towards my nation.
56
209724
5109
03:47
If my nation demands
that I sacrifice my family,
57
215421
4104
03:51
then I will sacrifice my family.
58
219549
2436
03:54
If the nation demands
that I kill millions of people,
59
222009
4274
03:58
then I will kill millions of people.
60
226307
2658
04:01
And if my nation demands
that I betray truth and beauty,
61
229442
6075
04:07
then I should betray truth and beauty.
62
235541
3023
04:11
For example, how does
a fascist evaluate art?
63
239587
4526
04:16
How does a fascist decide whether a movie
is a good movie or a bad movie?
64
244615
5289
04:22
Well, it's very, very, very simple.
65
250728
4172
04:27
There is really just one yardstick:
66
255260
1928
04:29
if the movie serves
the interests of the nation,
67
257593
3476
04:33
it's a good movie;
68
261093
1444
04:34
if the movie doesn't serve
the interests of the nation,
69
262561
3183
04:37
it's a bad movie.
70
265768
1222
04:39
That's it.
71
267014
1150
04:40
Similarly, how does a fascist decide
what to teach kids in school?
72
268496
4888
04:45
Again, it's very simple.
73
273877
2087
04:47
There is just one yardstick:
74
275988
1945
04:49
you teach the kids whatever serves
the interests of the nation.
75
277957
4945
04:55
The truth doesn't matter at all.
76
283323
2587
05:00
Now, the horrors of the Second World War
and of the Holocaust remind us
77
288372
5426
05:05
of the terrible consequences
of this way of thinking.
78
293822
4133
05:10
But usually, when we talk
about the ills of fascism,
79
298508
4545
05:15
we do so in an ineffective way,
80
303077
2960
05:18
because we tend to depict fascism
as a hideous monster,
81
306061
4738
05:22
without really explaining
what was so seductive about it.
82
310823
3906
05:27
It's a bit like these Hollywood movies
that depict the bad guys --
83
315284
4714
05:32
Voldemort or Sauron
or Darth Vader --
84
320022
4023
05:36
as ugly and mean and cruel.
85
324069
2632
05:38
They're cruel even
to their own supporters.
86
326725
2538
05:41
When I see these movies,
I never understand --
87
329670
3621
05:45
why would anybody be tempted to follow
a disgusting creep like Voldemort?
88
333315
6505
05:52
The problem with evil
is that in real life,
89
340895
3516
05:56
evil doesn't necessarily look ugly.
90
344435
2891
05:59
It can look very beautiful.
91
347688
1892
06:02
This is something that
Christianity knew very well,
92
350354
2723
06:05
which is why in Christian art,
as [opposed to] Hollywood,
93
353101
3706
06:08
Satan is usually depicted
as a gorgeous hunk.
94
356831
3868
06:13
This is why it's so difficult
to resist the temptations of Satan,
95
361259
4596
06:17
and why it is also difficult
to resist the temptations of fascism.
96
365879
4744
06:22
Fascism makes people see themselves
97
370980
2722
06:25
as belonging to the most beautiful
and most important thing in the world --
98
373726
5243
06:30
the nation.
99
378993
1302
06:32
And then people think,
100
380319
1346
06:33
"Well, they taught us
that fascism is ugly.
101
381689
3189
06:37
But when I look in the mirror,
I see something very beautiful,
102
385442
3024
06:40
so I can't be a fascist, right?"
103
388490
2191
06:43
Wrong.
104
391022
1151
06:44
That's the problem with fascism.
105
392197
1547
06:45
When you look in the fascist mirror,
106
393768
2619
06:48
you see yourself as far more beautiful
than you really are.
107
396411
4534
06:53
In the 1930s, when Germans
looked in the fascist mirror,
108
401371
4293
06:57
they saw Germany as the most
beautiful thing in the world.
109
405688
4040
07:02
If today, Russians look
in the fascist mirror,
110
410244
3436
07:05
they will see Russia as the most
beautiful thing in the world.
111
413704
3559
07:09
And if Israelis look
in the fascist mirror,
112
417577
3128
07:12
they will see Israel as the most
beautiful thing in the world.
113
420729
4380
07:18
This does not mean that we are now
facing a rerun of the 1930s.
114
426657
5057
07:24
Fascism and dictatorships might come back,
115
432304
3475
07:27
but they will come back in a new form,
116
435803
3239
07:31
a form which is much more relevant
117
439066
2741
07:33
to the new technological realities
of the 21st century.
118
441831
3809
07:38
In ancient times,
119
446538
1547
07:40
land was the most important
asset in the world.
120
448109
4160
07:44
Politics, therefore,
was the struggle to control land.
121
452911
3864
07:49
And dictatorship meant that all the land
was owned by a single ruler
122
457141
5860
07:55
or by a small oligarch.
123
463025
1872
07:57
And in the modern age,
machines became more important than land.
124
465827
4819
08:03
Politics became the struggle
to control the machines.
125
471347
3600
08:07
And dictatorship meant
126
475354
1996
08:09
that too many of the machines
became concentrated
127
477374
3910
08:13
in the hands of the government
or of a small elite.
128
481308
3280
08:17
Now data is replacing
both land and machines
129
485109
4706
08:21
as the most important asset.
130
489839
2111
08:24
Politics becomes the struggle
to control the flows of data.
131
492600
5340
08:29
And dictatorship now means
132
497964
2708
08:32
that too much data is being concentrated
in the hands of the government
133
500696
5780
08:38
or of a small elite.
134
506500
1920
08:40
The greatest danger
that now faces liberal democracy
135
508871
4912
08:45
is that the revolution
in information technology
136
513807
3270
08:49
will make dictatorships
more efficient than democracies.
137
517101
4790
08:54
In the 20th century,
138
522760
1619
08:56
democracy and capitalism
defeated fascism and communism
139
524403
4960
09:01
because democracy was better
at processing data and making decisions.
140
529387
5202
09:07
Given 20th-century technology,
141
535319
2366
09:09
it was simply inefficient to try
and concentrate too much data
142
537709
6035
09:15
and too much power in one place.
143
543768
2759
09:19
But it is not a law of nature
144
547244
4483
09:23
that centralized data processing
is always less efficient
145
551751
5604
09:29
than distributed data processing.
146
557379
2547
09:32
With the rise of artificial intelligence
and machine learning,
147
560605
3437
09:36
it might become feasible to process
enormous amounts of information
148
564066
5837
09:41
very efficiently in one place,
149
569927
2610
09:44
to take all the decisions in one place,
150
572561
3191
09:47
and then centralized data processing
will be more efficient
151
575776
4420
09:52
than distributed data processing.
152
580220
2200
09:55
And then the main handicap
of authoritarian regimes
153
583053
3760
09:58
in the 20th century --
154
586837
1637
10:00
their attempt to concentrate
all the information in one place --
155
588498
4516
10:05
it will become their greatest advantage.
156
593038
3366
10:10
Another technological danger
that threatens the future of democracy
157
598768
4907
10:15
is the merger of information technology
with biotechnology,
158
603699
5159
10:20
which might result
in the creation of algorithms
159
608882
4005
10:24
that know me better than I know myself.
160
612911
4316
10:29
And once you have such algorithms,
161
617688
2080
10:31
an external system, like the government,
162
619792
2849
10:34
cannot just predict my decisions,
163
622665
3524
10:38
it can also manipulate
my feelings, my emotions.
164
626213
3921
10:42
A dictator may not be able
to provide me with good health care,
165
630641
5245
10:47
but he will be able to make me love him
166
635910
3373
10:51
and to make me hate the opposition.
167
639307
2667
10:55
Democracy will find it difficult
to survive such a development
168
643037
5463
11:00
because, in the end,
169
648524
2150
11:02
democracy is not based
on human rationality;
170
650698
4127
11:06
it's based on human feelings.
171
654849
2420
11:10
During elections and referendums,
172
658355
2500
11:12
you're not being asked,
"What do you think?"
173
660879
2696
11:15
You're actually being asked,
"How do you feel?"
174
663998
3396
11:20
And if somebody can manipulate
your emotions effectively,
175
668228
4627
11:24
democracy will become
an emotional puppet show.
176
672879
3753
11:30
So what can we do to prevent
the return of fascism
177
678006
4515
11:34
and the rise of new dictatorships?
178
682545
2650
11:37
The number one question that we face
is: Who controls the data?
179
685990
6310
11:44
If you are an engineer,
180
692823
1675
11:46
then find ways to prevent too much data
181
694522
3968
11:50
from being concentrated in too few hands.
182
698514
2825
11:53
And find ways to make sure
183
701752
2944
11:56
the distributed data processing
is at least as efficient
184
704720
4413
12:01
as centralized data processing.
185
709157
2396
12:04
This will be the best
safeguard for democracy.
186
712077
3841
12:07
As for the rest of us
who are not engineers,
187
715942
3326
12:11
the number one question facing us
188
719292
3444
12:14
is how not to allow
ourselves to be manipulated
189
722760
4647
12:19
by those who control the data.
190
727431
2806
12:23
The enemies of liberal democracy,
they have a method.
191
731387
4106
12:27
They hack our feelings.
192
735919
2372
12:30
Not our emails, not our bank accounts --
193
738315
2452
12:32
they hack our feelings of fear
and hate and vanity,
194
740791
5207
12:38
and then use these feelings
195
746022
2428
12:40
to polarize and destroy
democracy from within.
196
748474
3952
12:44
This is actually a method
197
752903
1920
12:46
that Silicon Valley pioneered
in order to sell us products.
198
754847
5049
12:52
But now, the enemies of democracy
are using this very method
199
760381
5022
12:57
to sell us fear and hate and vanity.
200
765427
3724
13:01
They cannot create
these feelings out of nothing.
201
769863
3659
13:06
So they get to know our own
preexisting weaknesses.
202
774212
3831
13:10
And then use them against us.
203
778403
2571
13:13
And it is therefore
the responsibility of all of us
204
781482
3508
13:17
to get to know our weaknesses
205
785014
2634
13:19
and make sure that they
do not become a weapon
206
787672
3635
13:23
in the hands of the enemies of democracy.
207
791331
2883
13:27
Getting to know our own weaknesses
208
795315
2548
13:29
will also help us to avoid the trap
of the fascist mirror.
209
797887
5583
13:36
As we explained earlier,
fascism exploits our vanity.
210
804204
4151
13:40
It makes us see ourselves
as far more beautiful than we really are.
211
808805
5746
13:46
This is the seduction.
212
814575
1467
13:48
But if you really know yourself,
213
816424
2447
13:50
you will not fall
for this kind of flattery.
214
818895
3468
13:54
If somebody puts a mirror
in front of your eyes
215
822879
4063
13:58
that hides all your ugly bits
and makes you see yourself
216
826966
5060
14:04
as far more beautiful
and far more important
217
832050
4284
14:08
than you really are,
218
836358
1591
14:09
just break that mirror.
219
837973
2864
14:13
Thank you.
220
841696
1151
14:14
(Applause)
221
842871
6382
14:22
Chris Anderson: Yuval, thank you.
222
850677
1632
14:24
Goodness me.
223
852333
1151
14:25
It's so nice to see you again.
224
853958
1940
14:27
So, if I understand you right,
225
855922
1591
14:29
you're alerting us
to two big dangers here.
226
857537
2667
14:32
One is the possible resurgence
of a seductive form of fascism,
227
860228
4492
14:36
but close to that, dictatorships
that may not exactly be fascistic,
228
864744
4254
14:41
but control all the data.
229
869022
2563
14:43
I wonder if there's a third concern
230
871609
2096
14:45
that some people here
have already expressed,
231
873729
2118
14:47
which is where, not governments,
but big corporations control all our data.
232
875871
4897
14:52
What do you call that,
233
880792
1309
14:54
and how worried should we be about that?
234
882125
2387
14:56
Yuval Noah Harari: Well, in the end,
there isn't such a big difference
235
884536
3339
14:59
between the corporations
and the governments,
236
887899
2426
15:02
because, as I said, the questions is:
Who controls the data?
237
890349
3420
15:05
This is the real government.
238
893793
1395
15:07
If you call it a corporation
or a government --
239
895212
2444
15:09
if it's a corporation
and it really controls the data,
240
897680
3155
15:12
this is our real government.
241
900859
1928
15:14
So the difference
is more apparent than real.
242
902811
3067
15:18
CA: But somehow,
at least with corporations,
243
906529
2858
15:21
you can imagine market mechanisms
where they can be taken down.
244
909411
3519
15:24
I mean, if consumers just decide
245
912954
1917
15:26
that the company is no longer
operating in their interest,
246
914895
2754
15:29
it does open the door to another market.
247
917673
1913
15:31
It seems easier to imagine that
248
919610
1546
15:33
than, say, citizens rising up
and taking down a government
249
921180
3151
15:36
that is in control of everything.
250
924355
1612
15:37
YNH: Well, we are not there yet,
251
925991
1555
15:39
but again, if a corporation really
knows you better than you know yourself --
252
927570
5158
15:44
at least that it can manipulate
your own deepest emotions and desires,
253
932752
5254
15:50
and you won't even realize --
254
938030
1666
15:51
you will think this is
your authentic self.
255
939720
2579
15:54
So in theory, yes, in theory,
you can rise against a corporation,
256
942768
4055
15:58
just as, in theory, you can rise
against a dictatorship.
257
946847
3733
16:02
But in practice,
it is extremely difficult.
258
950982
3283
16:07
CA: So in "Homo Deus," you argue
that this would be the century
259
955281
4082
16:11
when humans kind of became gods,
260
959387
3411
16:14
either through development
of artificial intelligence
261
962822
2993
16:17
or through genetic engineering.
262
965839
2929
16:20
Has this prospect of political
system shift, collapse
263
968792
5468
16:26
impacted your view on that possibility?
264
974284
2664
16:29
YNH: Well, I think it makes it
even more likely,
265
977553
3095
16:32
and more likely
that it will happen faster,
266
980672
2929
16:35
because in times of crisis,
people are willing to take risks
267
983625
5023
16:40
that they wouldn't otherwise take.
268
988672
1984
16:42
And people are willing to try
269
990680
2818
16:45
all kinds of high-risk,
high-gain technologies.
270
993522
3873
16:49
So these kinds of crises
might serve the same function
271
997760
4230
16:54
as the two world wars in the 20th century.
272
1002014
3214
16:57
The two world wars greatly accelerated
273
1005252
3212
17:00
the development of new
and dangerous technologies.
274
1008488
3612
17:04
And the same thing might happen
in the 21st century.
275
1012124
3284
17:07
I mean, you need to be
a little crazy to run too fast,
276
1015721
3897
17:11
let's say, with genetic engineering.
277
1019642
2325
17:13
But now you have more
and more crazy people
278
1021991
3110
17:17
in charge of different
countries in the world,
279
1025125
2681
17:19
so the chances are getting
higher, not lower.
280
1027830
3067
17:23
CA: So, putting it all together, Yuval,
you've got this unique vision.
281
1031647
3365
17:27
Roll the clock forward 30 years.
282
1035036
1587
17:28
What's your guess --
does humanity just somehow scrape through,
283
1036647
3263
17:31
look back and say, "Wow,
that was a close thing. We did it!"
284
1039934
3135
17:35
Or not?
285
1043093
1436
17:36
YNH: So far, we've managed
to overcome all the previous crises.
286
1044553
3848
17:40
And especially if you look
at liberal democracy
287
1048425
2819
17:43
and you think things are bad now,
288
1051268
2944
17:46
just remember how much worse
things looked in 1938 or in 1968.
289
1054236
6466
17:52
So this is really nothing,
this is just a small crisis.
290
1060726
2991
17:56
But you can never know,
291
1064167
1969
17:58
because, as a historian,
292
1066160
2131
18:00
I know that you should never
underestimate human stupidity.
293
1068315
4774
18:05
(Laughter) (Applause)
294
1073113
1155
18:06
It is one of the most powerful forces
that shape history.
295
1074292
4004
18:11
CA: Yuval, it's been an absolute delight
to have you with us.
296
1079433
2865
18:14
Thank you for making the virtual trip.
297
1082322
1817
18:16
Have a great evening there in Tel Aviv.
298
1084163
1873
18:18
Yuval Harari!
299
1086060
1151
18:19
YNH: Thank you very much.
300
1087235
1376
18:20
(Applause)
301
1088635
1150

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Yuval Noah Harari - Historian, author
In his book "Homo Deus," Yuval Noah Harari explores the future of humankind: the destinies we may set for ourselves and the quests we'll undertake.

Why you should listen

In his book, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, Yuval Noah Harari explores the projects, dreams and nightmares that will shape the 21st century -- from overcoming death to creating artificial life. He maps the future and asks fundamental questions: Where do we go from here? How will we protect this fragile world from our own destructive powers? The book has sold four million copies since its publication in 2016.

Harari's previous book, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, explores what made homo sapiens the most successful species on the planet. His answer: We are the only animal that can believe in things that exist purely in our imagination, such as gods, states, money, human rights, corporations and other fictions, and we have developed a unique ability to use these stories to unify and organize groups and ensure cooperation. Sapiens has sold eight million copies and been translated into more than 50 languages. Bill GatesMark Zuckerberg and President Barack Obama have recommended it as a must-read.

Harari lectures as a Professor of history at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, where he specializes in world history, medieval history and military history. His current research focuses on macro-historical questions: What is the relationship between history and biology? What is the essential difference between Homo sapiens and other animals? Is there justice in history? Does history have a direction? Did people become happier as history unfolded? Harari has written for newspapers such as The Guardian, Financial Times, the Times, Nature magazine and the Wall Street Journal.

Harari's new book, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, will take the pulse of our current global climate, focusing on the biggest questions of the present moment: What is really happening right now? What are today’s greatest challenges and choices? What should we pay attention to? The book will be published in multiple languages in September 2018.

More profile about the speaker
Yuval Noah Harari | Speaker | TED.com